I'm not so sure, however, that I'd pick him over every guy BYU gained from the portal last year.
You still won't even list those players. It's sort of weird. It's as if you made your decision before making an evaluation.
You haven't even mentioned Heckard, Garrett, or Cravens.
The only guy you mentioned is Etienne, while completely disregardind Maile.
How about Bagnah? Again, you didn't even mention him.
How about the others? Let's see your list.