That isn’t a fair comparison to Jake.
The only non senior you’d likely take from that group is Max who had a better Jr. year.
Given this was Jake’s first full season as a D1 starter against 11 P4 opponents, I think you take 11-2 and be happy.
Also, if that fluke punt doesn’t hit Evan Johnson or a typically sure handed Jakob Robinson is able to pounce on it, things look a lot different.