Literally every college sport has gaps of that size, if not bigger, including

Jan 1, 2025
9:13:00pm

shoganai All-American

every other football division.

FBS is the only one that insists it's too special to have the same kind of basic, proven playoff format all the others have had for generations.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jan 1, 2025 at 9:13:00pm

Message modified by shoganai on Jan 1, 2025 at 9:14:03pm

Message modified by shoganai on Jan 1, 2025 at 9:15:30pm

Report problem with this ad

shoganai

Bio page: shoganai
Joined: Jul 15, 2004
Last login: Jan 8, 2025
Total posts: 33,555 (790 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

24 teams. Every conference champ gets in. First three rounds at home sites. Rose

shoganai

Jan 1, 6:55pm

This would be way more fun.

LeperKhan

Jan 1, 6:56pm

Not all champs deserve a bid. Marshall couldn't even field a team. This CFP has shown that more teams isn’t the answer

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:02pm

We've had enough of committees and computers deciding who "deserves" to be in.

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:13pm

If you win a conference that has good teams then you deserve to be in. Most years one or no G6

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:27pm

Here's an idea. Let's have the lowly G5 champions play some games against the

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:30pm

It’s so different that it’s not even comparable. Let highly ranked teams play. Give an autobid to one G6 to avoid legal

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:32pm

The argument that FBS college football is so uniquely "different" and beyond

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:39pm

Within FBS is where the difference is. Most of the CFP games haven’t been competitive and you think adding

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:41pm

Yet somehow FCS has been doing it for years...

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:42pm

All those g6 should drop to FCs and compete with them. Much better fit

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:45pm

I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but if you're in favor of divisional

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:48pm

Very possible. But what you don’t want is equality. You want to give everyone a trophy

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:51pm

Total nonsense. I want exactly one trophy.

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:52pm

You don’t want them to earn it you want it given to them without having to compete during the season

byuTX

Jan 1, 8:13pm

That is not even close to an accurate summary of my argument. Completely unfair

shoganai

Jan 1, 8:15pm

How would you rearrange the conferences to make them somewhat equal? How would you convince blue bloods and networks?

byuTX

Jan 1, 8:33pm

You don't need equal conferences. You don't have those in any other sport and

shoganai

Jan 1, 8:43pm

There is no pro league with gaps between the top and bottom conferences like you

russkiejedi

Jan 1, 9:09pm

Literally every college sport has gaps of that size, if not bigger, including

shoganai

Jan 1, 9:13pm

Not close. And it’s going to be an even wider gap when top teams start sharing 20 million a year with players. Kennesaw

byuTX

Jan 1, 10:24pm

I think that assertion simply doesn't stand up to any objective analysis

shoganai

Jan 1, 10:55pm

Of course it does - the gap between a top and bottom football team is much

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 6:39am

I just completely disagree. I don't think there's any way you can look at the

shoganai

Jan 2, 7:36am

NIU has been an FBS team for over 40 years, they're not the comparison between a

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 9:43am

So, it turns out you actually agree with me on the gap issue.

shoganai

Jan 2, 10:09am

Nah, not unless you're making an argument about it that I didn't catch above.

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 10:46am

16 seeds in basketball have a 2-154 all-time record. I don't think you can make

shoganai

Jan 2, 10:56am

You keep comparing apples to oranges. A 9/24 play-in round wouldn't be

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 2:46pm

I can and do because it is. But what you want can't, won't and shouldn't happen

byuTX

Jan 2, 9:44am

Not even close.

russkiejedi

Jan 1, 10:36pm

Yeah, the current format gives the G5 a shot. A G5 team got the 3 seed and a bye

russkiejedi

Jan 1, 8:06pm

The problem is we currently have very unbalanced conferences and this will not

mudpupper

Jan 1, 8:13pm

Why is this such a perplexing problem? It doesn't stop any other major college

shoganai

Jan 1, 8:22pm

Have alwaya thought this would be the beat format. Aligns with the traditional

BYU2ATM

Jan 1, 7:05pm

Until a team actually ranked outside the top 10 wins a game…

OPINIONS

Jan 1, 7:22pm

There's no "need" to have any teams. College football did just fine when it had

shoganai

Jan 1, 7:27pm

It has never been more popular than ever and I thought you wanted to prove it on the field?

byuTX

Jan 1, 7:31pm

10 conferences, 30 divisions

1984coug

Jan 1, 7:56pm

Agree, plus autobids for Alabama and other blue bloods.

RoboKayne

Jan 1, 8:06pm

One game has been decided by a single score. Average margin of victory is 17 points. And your solution is to let Ohio,

RealTaysomHill

Jan 2, 10:18am

It depends on what problem you think needs solving.

shoganai

Jan 2, 10:26am

Who doesn’t have access to the playoffs?

RealTaysomHill

Jan 2, 10:42am

Approximately half of each season's conference champions and several other

shoganai

Jan 2, 1:32pm

They do have access though. BYU could have gone to the playoffs this year. So could any G5 conference champion.

RealTaysomHill

Jan 2, 3:22pm

You and I have different opinions on what that means.

shoganai

Jan 2, 3:35pm

If BYU went undefeated, would we have gone to the playoffs?

RealTaysomHill

Jan 2, 3:41pm

I understand your argument. I just don't have quite the same view on it.

shoganai

Jan 2, 6:54pm

Why are people so concerned about lopsided games?

BYU2ATM

Jan 2, 1:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad