Kansas also knocked off Iowa St and Colorado during that stretch. It's not

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 3, 2024
3:18:31pm

Mr. Scoobs All-American

Kansas also knocked off Iowa St and Colorado during that stretch. It's not

like BYU got blown out, in fact statistically they dominated. Very similar to Ohio St. losing to Michigan or Bama losing to Vanderbilt. weird game.

It's no worse than being completely blown out by OU like Bama just did.

BYU is objectively being treated much worse than other teams that have similar blemishes.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 3, 2024 at 3:18:31pm

Message modified by Mr. Scoobs on Dec 3, 2024 at 3:19:17pm

Report problem with this ad

Mr. Scoobs

Previous username: Alm
Bio page: Mr. Scoobs
Joined: Sep 8, 2011
Last login: Dec 4, 2024
Total posts: 12,310 (187 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

CB is hilarious sometimes. BYU has looked terrible the last 4 games and no one

OKchief

Dec 3, 11:24am

We haven't looked "terrible", but I agree with everything else you said

darkcoug

Dec 3, 11:26am

But did we look like a playoff team? Like a first-round bye, playoff team?

Dec 3, 11:29am

I agree with that. Part of it was that our schedule was a lot tougher and many of the bounces that went for us

darkcoug

Dec 3, 11:31am

Schedule tougher in the second half of the season? Are you kidding?

CameronG

Dec 3, 11:44am

Yes, I think @Utah with everything on the line, Kansas during their 3 ranked team massacre, and end-of-season @ASU

darkcoug

Dec 3, 11:48am

Mmmm, yes... 3-6 Kansas at home was very tough. Utah and Ok State were tough

reddead

Dec 3, 12:25pm

Utah was very much not at home

BaseCoug

Dec 3, 3:33pm

Good point. I upgrade that to an ugly win over a bad team in a tough environment

reddead

11:48am

I think yes - what 12 teams are better?

HarlemCoug

Dec 3, 11:53am

All of the undefeated and 1-loss P4 teams (yes, SMU is better right now). Boise

reddead

Dec 3, 12:29pm

Your first couple of criteria result in 11 teams, leaves 1 spot left

BYUFootballisBack

Dec 3, 3:32pm

I would bet against BYU, but I agree with you about very little resume diff

reddead

Dec 3, 3:41pm

Multiple of the projected playoff teams have not looked like "playoff" teams

BYUFootballisBack

Dec 3, 3:27pm

Right. BYU is not a top 12 team, but neither are at least half of the top 12.

9:17am

i would say BYU looked like as much of a first round bye type of team as anyone

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 3:39pm

Better than BSU

coot20

Dec 3, 5:57pm

Yeah terrible is a strong word. But they haven't looked good

OKchief

Dec 3, 11:30am

Uhhh... From the 2nd half of UCF, all of Utah, all of Kansas, and the first half of ASU. We looked really bad.

Boomcannon

Dec 3, 12:37pm

BYU hasn’t looked terrible. BYU had two close losses against solid teams, and

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 11:29am

This. We all look through our BYU lens, but other teams are also flawed.

Allstate

Dec 3, 11:30am

Terrible is the wrong word…they’ve looked mediocre

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 11:32am

idk if you noticed but there were a lot of worse losses than ours above us.

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 11:50am

I said right in my post that we didn’t play terrible. We played mediocre

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 12:58pm

the problem isn’t that BYUs was back to back to end the year and bama vs vandy

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 3:14pm

Corrupt? I don’t get that. Of course every game shouldn’t be the same

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 4:16pm

than what’s the point of playing any games before november?

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 6:34pm

College football is unique…lots of teams and you can’t play a balanced schedule

PHXSUNS31

9:49am

I agree with your last part. But the current system is extremely corrupt

FieroCoug

10:19am

We looked blah since second half against UCF, just trying to burn clock instead

88Coug

Dec 3, 11:59am

If there’s one thing that will be debated every day on CB

Cooouuugs

Dec 3, 6:02pm

We definitely did not “control the game” against Houston

Dec 3, 11:38am

almost all of their losses were by one score and they beat 3 of the top 4 big 12

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 11:50am

They could be the best 5-7 team of all time. That doesn’t make them good

Dec 3, 11:54am

i didn’t say they’re good. just that they’re solid. ASU is good and that was a

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 12:42pm

Man, Taysom is a little snarky after his injury Sunday.

Captain Stubing

Dec 3, 11:55am

not top 25

Deleted

Dec 3, 11:43am

RE: BYU hasn’t looked terrible. BYU had two close losses against solid

cougsince'84

Dec 3, 5:02pm

Collapse and looking terrible are not terms that apply this year. Try BYU 6 v Texas 35, BYU 7 v WVU 37, BYU 13 v ISU 45

PJMort

Dec 3, 11:30am

So you've been happy with the effort, focus and preparation? Sure the scores are

OKchief

Dec 3, 11:39am

So, the choices are collapse/looks terrible OR being happy?

PJMort

Dec 3, 11:46am

This is a fair analysis if you only look at BYU

Remigius

Dec 3, 11:41am

Which playoff teams should BYU be ahead of?

Dec 3, 11:43am

Miami, for one. Alabama looke far worse than we ever did in their 24-3 loss to

Threw and Through

Dec 3, 12:34pm

Did you answer the question though? I agree on Miami…

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 1:06pm

BYU has not looked like a top 25 team the past 4 games

Projectoor

Dec 3, 11:42am

BYU shouldn't be evaluated in a vacuum. What about Bama getting blown out to OU?

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 11:52am

They do have some things going for them, but some going against them

Projectoor

Dec 3, 12:22pm

Boise is an auto-bid. They are irrelevant to the discussion unless they lose

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 1:16pm

BYU has holes but not as big of a gap as they should. Being in the lower teens

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 1:39pm

BYU was #6 (and climbing) until they lost to non-bowl eligible Kansas

reddead

Dec 3, 3:00pm

Kansas also knocked off Iowa St and Colorado during that stretch. It's not

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 3:18pm

Kansas then dropped a game to Baylor to finish 5-7. They are not a good P4 team

reddead

Dec 3, 3:26pm

It's not as gigantic as you are making it out to be. Other teams have had flaws

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 3:48pm

You’re taking single events and not looking at the whole picture for those teams

PHXSUNS31

Dec 3, 4:15pm

I'm doing that intentionally because that is how BYU is being evaluated

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 4:28pm

Best wins in all of college football is a little hyperbolic

reddead

Dec 3, 4:44pm

How are you evaluating quality of wins? A&M isn't even ranked anymore.

Mr. Scoobs

Dec 3, 4:53pm

That was a rivalry game to go to the SEC championship in a top 20 environment

reddead

Dec 3, 5:03pm

I guess for me I’m just not concerned about a spot or 2 for BYU

PHXSUNS31

9:54am

I agree that it's close. I don't like defending 9-3 Bama or S Car or 10-2 Miami

reddead

Dec 3, 4:20pm

every single top 25 team, including number 1 undefeated oregon, has not

FieroCoug

Dec 3, 2:07pm

Yes we can fault the committee!

RoboKayne

Dec 3, 3:25pm

Ok Chief

HarlemCoug

Dec 3, 11:51am

RE: CB is hilarious sometimes. BYU has looked terrible the last 4 games and no

Longseason

Dec 3, 12:21pm

BYU would likely get hammered in a playoff game IF they play the way the have

Blew

Dec 3, 12:44pm

We finished tied for 1st and what appears to be about 3rd place overall, which is about right.

kccougar

Dec 3, 12:54pm

So you've been happy with the preparation, effort and execution?

OKchief

Dec 3, 1:07pm

Happy? Absolutely. We finished 10-2. Hopeful for continued improvement? That too.

kccougar

Dec 3, 3:52pm

Weak wins are the bigger problem. We had one "bad" loss.

LateToTheGame

Dec 3, 1:17pm

I can be concerned about both BYU's on-field struggles and the inherent corrupt-

Still Blue

Dec 3, 1:18pm

There are teams that will make the playoffs this year that have just as many

Dec 3, 1:35pm

A lot of very flawed teams. We should have beaten Kansas (even if they were on

SoBlueitHurts

Dec 3, 1:42pm

BYU was #6 (ahead of Georgia) when they played Kansas—getting lots of love

reddead

Dec 3, 3:02pm

Undefeated is the only way the Big 12 will get love it seems. And that is hard

Dec 3, 5:55pm

Not so. An 11-2 Big XII team is going to the playoff, 11-1 will always get love

reddead

8:45am

Who besides Notre Dame has a worse loss?

PHXSUNS31

11:17am

Both things can be true...

djbryant79

Dec 3, 1:57pm

Winning solves a lot of problems.

KCFan85

Dec 3, 2:09pm

The problem is the penalty exacted against BYU and Big 12 teams for losing, which is not exacted to the same extent

Bob Vance

Dec 3, 2:10pm

We haven't played like we deserve it but if we still used the BCS computer

Lord Jim

Dec 3, 2:17pm

Very strong resume, but definitely failed the eye test

Hill4Heisman

Dec 3, 2:18pm

Yup. What a lot of people refuse to accept (most of all Kalani)

OKchief

Dec 3, 4:02pm

Kalani unfortunately values relationships over results. He's horrified of

gopman

Dec 3, 4:11pm

The playoff was ours and it was stolen from us.

VenomFarmer

Dec 3, 2:46pm

Sure, but with the huge caveat that most of the teams above us also look weak

Dec 3, 2:58pm

Thing is that if Utah was 9-0 with the same schedule and same kind of wins then

boctabulous

Dec 3, 3:25pm

But at the same time you’d probably say Alabama is great. See this thread

Dec 3, 4:37pm

His point still stands that BYU (offensively) didn't pass the "eye test".

gopman

Dec 3, 4:44pm

Alabama just lost to Oklahoma and only score 3 points.

MarylandFan

Dec 3, 5:53pm

How did Bama look scoring only 3 points and losing to Oklahoma 2 weeks ago?

Doogal McCougar

Dec 3, 6:21pm

lol. You obviously haven’t watched much college football this year. Have you

cDog801

Dec 3, 6:22pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad