RE: Looking at offensive production, Arod is average at best, not above

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 3, 2024
12:56:36pm

Forest Green All-American

RE: Looking at offensive production, Arod is average at best, not above

https://www.cougarboard.com/board/message.html?id=34374112&tab=top10

Report problem with this ad

Forest Green

Previous username: Blue Mountains
Bio page: Forest Green
Joined: Apr 1, 2014
Last login: Dec 3, 2024
Total posts: 2,739 (22 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

To the fire ARod crowd…

tkh9

Dec 1, 11:44pm

Several years of little to no improvement in play calling, time management, etc.

Les IsMore

Dec 2, 12:23am

Objectively false

xgbs

Dec 2, 8:16am

Typical CBer fluff non-response... back up what is "objectively" lol, false then

Dec 2, 8:52am

See post below. Like I've got time for this.

xgbs

Dec 2, 9:01am

...that was the best you got? haha, I think my small daughter could have easily

Dec 2, 9:33am

My takes are weak? Seriously? You: A-Rod can't Recruit! A-rod:

xgbs

Dec 2, 12:11pm

I’m prob one of the more outspoken people on Arod, and I was a fan of his

Dec 2, 12:32am

lol, the same small group of 👎 downers follow me around w/ their down votes

Dec 2, 1:47am

Sensitive, aren’t we?

Incentivize

Dec 2, 6:48am

I think you mean “they” 😂 …and yes, they are

Dec 2, 7:08am

They don't seem to want to have a cogent back and forth that's based on anything more than feelings, so they just react.

unctoothman

Dec 2, 6:52am

The same loud noise gets old. Feels like talking to

niqmadu

Dec 2, 7:09am

If it gets “old” then provide rational logic disputing it, and it will end. Even

Dec 2, 7:21am

Nah. I’ve watched you toot your horn enough to pass.

niqmadu

Dec 2, 7:35am

I find it interesting you see this as confrontational, I compliment Arod

Dec 2, 8:02am

icecougar disputed it below but you just (ironically) eye-roll-emoji’d rather

Forest Green

Dec 2, 7:35am

lol, so blaming everything on Retzlaff in your opinion disputes all points? Haha

Dec 2, 7:50am

Not my opinion. It was the icecougar opinion you didn’t respond to. I just

Forest Green

Dec 2, 8:34am

because trying to pretend it's all on Retalaff is an unserious take...

Dec 2, 8:43am

You are in such a rush to respond that you didn't read and digest either post

niqmadu

Dec 2, 9:48am

lol, ...here come the personal attacks, meaning

Dec 2, 4:43pm

There are many small issues.

Best Guess

Dec 2, 10:37am

Sincere props to you for engaging with the argument. Now, do you think Arod is

Forest Green

Dec 2, 10:53am

Looking at offensive production, Arod is average at best, not above

Dec 3, 11:26am

RE: Looking at offensive production, Arod is average at best, not above

Forest Green

Dec 3, 12:56pm

That I can agree with. The challenge is that opinions often obscure the ability to actually evaluate data and outcomes.

unctoothman

Dec 2, 8:05am

I don't like the offensive philosophy, and definitely think ARod has room for

Y05

Dec 2, 4:21am

I can concede that the offense didn't execute well (especially vs Houston)...

Dec 2, 8:41am

I don't care about boring. I care about consistency and results. ARod has moments where he makes brilliant calls. And

unctoothman

Dec 2, 6:51am

Lots of self-affirming assumptions in your critique. I’ll take on first one.

xgbs

Dec 2, 8:44am

lol, this is the hill you chose to die on? hahah. This won't be difficult...

Dec 2, 9:32am

Thanks for the reply.

tkh9

Dec 2, 9:20am

...I am bombastic at times, but sometimes on fan boards you have to be to

Dec 2, 9:35am

I agree with a good part of your post however, one glaring thing we have to..

Lefty24

Dec 2, 7:20pm

Well I suppose it’s Arod’s fault our offense sucks because he made Jake the QB1

icecougar

Dec 2, 12:36am

Per PFF Jake drops off a cliff with pressure

niqmadu

Dec 2, 7:47am

You're calling Jake the 2024 version of Kevin Feterik. That's actually pretty accurate. And you're right that the OC can

unctoothman

Dec 2, 8:09am

Retzlaff = Feterik? No. That is NOT accurate.

xgbs

Dec 2, 8:23am

I wasn't talking about leadership. I was responding to the comment

unctoothman

Dec 2, 11:17am

Arod has shown the ability to tailor the O in the past. Go back to 2019...

icecougar

Dec 2, 1:04pm

Just a few adjustments would go a long way IMO, mainly

1CougFan

Dec 2, 7:05am

I didn't say fire him. I just said

Coug Dude

Dec 2, 8:36am

This is where I’m at. He’s good, but probably not good enough to take BYU

ProvoSpain

Dec 2, 11:25am

Easiest question ever. Ignoring the many things I think he is bad at. The main

rha1211

Dec 2, 10:21am

To the Fire ARod crowd...

Dec 2, 10:48am

It's called Jay Hill and Kevin Young syndrome

byuod

Dec 2, 10:58am

Because the same things have needed to improve and have not

Dec 2, 12:00pm

would have liked to see BYU approach Kansas and AZ St more like a bowl game have

1CougFan

Dec 2, 12:12pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad