The likely 2 greatest ever didn't, Brady and Mahomes.

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 8, 2024
6:25:52pm

maYbe Redshirt Freshman

The likely 2 greatest ever didn't, Brady and Mahomes.

Report problem with this ad

maYbe

Bio page: maYbe
Joined: Oct 3, 2023
Last login: Sep 16, 2024
Total posts: 190 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I think Broncos would have had a better chance with Stidham, let alone Zach

Sep 8, 5:34pm

It baffles me that other teams haven’t learned from what Green Bay has done.

ldssdl

Sep 8, 5:37pm

That ain’t it either. That was a terrible use of draft capital

TCuz

Sep 8, 5:40pm

Aside from generational talents, NFL QB success is much more strongly correlated

ldssdl

Sep 8, 5:43pm

Oh, no. It’s the exact opposite. The great QBs overcome “bad situations”

TCuz

Sep 8, 5:46pm

He was not that good a few years ago.

Sep 8, 5:45pm

The literal only thing that changed is he got to play and get better.

TCuz

Sep 8, 5:48pm

I don't know how good he would have been as rookie but

Sep 8, 6:19pm

And the Packers know how to send quarterbacks to the HOF.

Sep 8, 5:42pm

Unless you draft a huge project, you absolutely play your rookie. Almost every elite QB in the NFL started day one

Sep 8, 5:57pm

The likely 2 greatest ever didn't, Brady and Mahomes.

maYbe

Sep 8, 6:25pm

Mahomes is the one outlier and Brady started back when rookies sat. Every other elite guy in the NFL started in year one

Sep 8, 6:28pm

Brady was a 7th rd draft pick who didn’t start until Bledsoe got hurt?

ldssdl

Sep 8, 6:34pm

Brady was a late round pick who was most definitely sitting behind Drew Bledsoe

Corn Pop

Sep 8, 6:37pm

So you’re saying he was a huge project? Is that the takeaway here? Rookies didn’t start 20 years ago. They do now. Using

Sep 8, 6:43pm

I'm not the one that brought up Brady, you did. And FTR, Brady tossed a single

Corn Pop

Sep 8, 6:53pm

Read the thread, I didn’t bring up Brady first. But you can’t say, “look at past generations, they turned out better

Sep 8, 7:07pm

Really? Not Mahomes. Not Rodgers. Not Brady. Not Brees. Not Lamar. Not Allen…

DC15

Sep 8, 7:27pm

Mahomes is the only modern exception. Allen and Lamar both started as rookies, and your earliest example besides them

Sep 8, 9:07pm

You said, “started day one” and were incorrect, most greats were backups day 1.

DC15

Sep 8, 10:37pm

We’re arguing semantics here. Read through my posts and I’ve been saying play year one. You’re right, I said “day one”

Sep 9, 7:53am

Stidham agrees with you

WJCougar

Sep 8, 6:05pm

He's probably right.

Sep 8, 6:21pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad