"Papers are kinda like Dad jokes - only really good the first time you use it."

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 4, 2024
12:30:37pm

Eddie All-American

"Papers are kinda like Dad jokes - only really good the first time you use it."

Report problem with this ad

Eddie

Bio page: Eddie
Joined: Dec 12, 2002
Last login: Oct 4, 2024
Total posts: 45,629 (1,006 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

A masters level student just emailed me

DataMouth

12:25pm

"She attached a $50 to it."

RobAdams

12:27pm

My colleague gives lower grades than me. I thought I’d use her grades this time.

Florwood

12:27pm

Message:

Archaea

12:27pm

how much of a grade difference are we talking? Did the same person grade each?

SalmonOfCapistrano

12:27pm

RE: A masters level student just emailed me

TheHop

12:28pm

"Papers are kinda like Dad jokes - only really good the first time you use it."

Eddie

12:30pm

Worth an F all times after that. Thanks for letting me know.

Soupie

12:44pm

Or - "I wanted to be more creative than just give the same boring grade again."

Eddie

12:48pm

"I figured one of us should have an original thought"

notaboy

12:57pm

These are the people who graduate with a masters degree in whatever it is and are considered “experts” by others

Mike Honcho

12:32pm

Usually, people don't rely upon lowly Masters people as experts. You must

Archaea

12:35pm

But there have been a lot of similar findings in "expert" publications recently.

SalmonOfCapistrano

12:40pm

Similar findings of what? Your argument is unclear.

Archaea

12:43pm

plagiarism.

SalmonOfCapistrano

12:45pm

Huh. Have people noted plagiarism in a minority of expert publications? Yes.

Archaea

12:47pm

Tough to be considered an expert if you haven't done any meaningful research.

Eddie

12:41pm

Precisely. The narrative to denigrate expertise and to place lay persons on par

Archaea

12:42pm

I’m not saying that normies should be held up to the same level. But I do 100% now start from a place of skepticism

Mike Honcho

1:44pm

I listen to what the expert says

Archaea

1:49pm

I think we’re on the same page then. I would add the application of common sense to the evaluation, though

Mike Honcho

3:37pm

My bad, I agree for most fields more than a masters is required. My comment is based off of

Mike Honcho

1:14pm

Research and experience is required to be an

Archaea

1:24pm

We’re told that people are experts by those who we trust to vet them all the time.

Mike Honcho

1:42pm

Who is "we" and what was the purpose of the meeing?

Archaea

1:57pm

I’d be careful with a funny response because

stoils

12:33pm

Yes. Subtly ask for clarification in ways that won't draw suspicion

12:37pm

Why provide an out? Let them sink or swim on his or her own account.

Archaea

12:39pm

It's just gathering information. There's still a small chance they didn't do

12:43pm

Report as is. Let the investigators determine

Archaea

12:44pm

Fair enough. If it was me, I'd want to dig a little more to confirm it is what I

12:47pm

"Can you provide me evidence of your friend's submission? I'll look into it"

ryebrye

12:44pm

Like this, but avoid words like "evidence"

Still Blue

1:24pm

Ask: Did she share the paper with you or did you steal it?

BlueKarma

12:35pm

I thought people with masters degrees were smart. Changing my thoughts now

chismoso

12:36pm

Degrees only mean people stayed in school longer. Doesn't indicate intelligence

12:49pm

That narrative isn't useful. Diligence, putting one's time in, and doing

Archaea

12:58pm

It is useful, it's a reminder to experts that they're just like everyone else.

1:07pm

Not true.

Archaea

1:26pm

We'll, thisis a master's student. Doesn't have a degree and whether they end up

fattycoug

3:13pm

Invite her to make a 30 minute presentation to the class, and let the

BlueFever

12:38pm

"The good news is, I'll change your score. The bad news is, it's now a 0."

durandal

12:39pm

Give her + 20% for comparative reasoning and -50% for cheating.

valleus

12:40pm

Deflation

Shawarma

12:41pm

Congrats on qualifying to be the next Ivy League University President!

RJCOD

12:42pm

Just don’t respond at all.

The Old Y

12:46pm

Cheating aside, are they right? You graded the same paper with a different grade? Was it the same assignment?

TCuz

12:48pm

Please post the entire message. The paraphrase leaves way too much uncertainty.

Scratch

12:52pm

If you borrowed large portions without attribution, it's plagiarism

Archaea

12:55pm

Yep, no doubt about it, but there are lots of missing relevant details.

Scratch

1:06pm

Ask for the name of the other student so you can "research it" and that you

CMM Cougar

12:56pm

+50% grade for understanding how the real business world works

Cougarclaw

12:56pm

Did you know that she plagiarized the paper ahead of time?

Zoobieman

12:59pm

Plagiarism is no laughing matter, especially at the Madter’s level.

Everyman

1:01pm

In some instances, it can get the student expelled from the program. That's what

Archaea

1:05pm

When Chuck got caught cheating on a test at Stanford, he was kicked out too.

Eddie

1:12pm

"I hope you didn't pay her too much"

thewaterboy

1:02pm

Her grade was boosted for originality. And it sounds like your grade was higher than it should have been.

unctoothman

1:45pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad