Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up
Aug 13, 2024
9:14:48am
OGSuperfan All-American
My guess is that the coach has finally finished their team management piece
(getting the team where they want it personnel wise) and now they are just wanting to touch base with your daughter to help her understand. I would assume positive intent and hope that this is just a great coach who understands the kids are people and might want to know WHY behind being cut. I wouldn't expect this to be a re-invite to the team; rather perhaps the coach may have heard through the grapevine via current players that your daughter was perhaps confused and hurt etc - and the coach is reaching out to explain and allow questions.

Cutting kids is always a hard thing to do; being one of the players cut is a hard thing, but a good coach owns it and just explains reasons why.

When I was at the Y (years and years ago), I went through the walk-on process for one of the sports teams (I had dealt with knee injuries my first 2 years at school); went through try-outs and performed rather well. The coach at the time then sat me down, and explained the reasons he just couldn't give me a spot on the team even though my performance (even directly against the current team) out-performed about 75% of the current players. These reasons included my grade at the time (Junior), years of eligibility left compared to other kids on the team, scholarship/spots on the team dynamics, and politics/money he gets from donors for allowing certain spots to be given to certain players etc.

While I may not have agreed with every decision or rationale, I greatly appreciated the up-front and honest breakdown he gave me. I was able to prove myself against the existing team, and I got a quick view into the delicate balancing act that is smaller collegiate sports coaches have. Coming from a family of college/high-school coaches myself, I had always thought "Best 10 (or however many players are on the team) make it" - and maybe at certain levels that is the case.

I left that walk-on experience with a positive outlook, not at all depressed or feeling sorry for myself. It was a good real-life lesson that not everything is as you might think it should be, and some good coaches are always honest and straight-forward with the players - leveling expectations and reasons, not trying to hide anything.
OGSuperfan
Bio page
OGSuperfan
Joined
Sep 8, 2010
Last login
Sep 3, 2024
Total posts
5,405 (6 FO)
Messages
Author
Time
Aug 13, 12:44am

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.