I personally believe if BYU finished the season 11-2, we would have been the #10 seed.
This may not be a popular belief, but with 1 loss to Kansas or ASU, and a CCG loss, I think we get in over SMU for sure, and possibly above Indiana.
Unfortunately that is just a gut feeling and I can't prove it. But we lost two games, and close calls against OkSt and Utah. For that reason I really don't think we deserved an at-large spot over any of the 7 other teams.