There are multiple factors

Sign up, and you can make all message times appear in your timezone. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 29, 2024
10:12:38pm

CougarCanuck76 Truly Addicted User

There are multiple factors

I'm not sure what you are trying to say here. Yes Arod is at BYU and not Alabama. And yes Arod should still be able to recruit a QB to BYU with Power 4 offers.

Again, if you have examples of Arod being a good recruiter feel free to share those examples.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 29, 2024 at 10:12:38pm

Message modified by CougarCanuck76 on Dec 29, 2024 at 10:14:22pm

Report problem with this ad

CougarCanuck76

Bio page: CougarCanuck76
Joined: Aug 29, 2004
Last login: Jan 6, 2025
Total posts: 40,451 (505 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Does Roderick go to coaching clinics ? Dude can evolve and improve. He’s OK.

Dr MoBYU

12/29/24 9:11pm

Good grief. ARod's playcalling is great! And FTR, in between jobs at Utah/BYU,

runnincoug

12/29/24 9:15pm

He’s ok.Not sure I’d say great.Which OC would CB like him to learn from?

Dr MoBYU

12/29/24 9:19pm

Which BYU OC has done better than Roderick? Whoever you name had a bunch of

byusage

12/29/24 9:25pm

I thought it was a rather reasonable take

cajuncoug

12/29/24 9:25pm

The moral is, recruit smart/teachable players. After a certain level of athleticism/size, smarts are more important.

roseyscenario

12/29/24 10:06pm

I go to continuing education and professional development for my job, I don’t

Polecat

12/29/24 9:19pm

Me too. That’s what I was thinking. Continuing education.

Dr MoBYU

12/29/24 9:22pm

I remember him once saying that Whittingham would send him and other assistant

Polecat

12/29/24 9:25pm

Sounds like CB would like him to keep getting tips from Ludwig

DiamondMo

12/29/24 9:47pm

He's doing well as the OC. Critics have unrealistic expectations of an OC

byusage

12/29/24 9:20pm

Sure. I agree. But my point is, he can grow and training will speed growth.

Dr MoBYU

12/29/24 9:24pm

Do you really think he doesn't do that?

byusage

12/29/24 9:26pm

Yeah, someone should alert the college football coaching profession about this

Newbutnotnew

12/29/24 10:02pm

You read a lot into things. Anyway, which clinics does he go to? I’m am

Dr MoBYU

12/29/24 10:14pm

I don't fault Arod for his playcalling.

12/29/24 9:28pm

Is he? What is it that he's not doing that he should be doing now that he's in

SoCalCoug

12/29/24 9:33pm

Here's his track record

12/29/24 9:43pm

So essentially what you’re saying is that Jake Retzlaff, a kid who really

Polecat

12/29/24 9:55pm

RE: So essentially what you’re saying is that Jake Retzlaff, a kid who really

12/29/24 10:01pm

And you’re certain there are no other factors In the recruiting of these

Polecat

12/29/24 10:06pm

There are multiple factors

12/29/24 10:12pm

As nice as it would be to see BYU land higher ranked QB’s, that’s really not the

Polecat

12/29/24 10:31pm

Again he's a great coach and that's his reason for his success.

12/29/24 10:35pm

If I were a betting man, I’d bet that he’ll get one eventually. Probably sooner

Polecat

12/29/24 10:41pm

That's what has made it so frustrating to see our QB room look the way it does

12/29/24 10:46pm

ARod convinced Slovis to come to BYU--9th ranked QB in the portal that year.

runnincoug

12/29/24 11:21pm

You have not answered my questions. You are avoiding actually answering.

SoCalCoug

12/29/24 11:48pm

Who should be at BYU that isn’t? And why should they be at BYU?

Polecat

12/29/24 9:36pm

It takes a lot of nil to land top rated QBs

I'mBatman

12/29/24 9:58pm

I'm not really asking for "top rated" QBs

12/29/24 10:06pm

You could look at Utah's qb recruiting on paper and think they have recruited

byusage

12/29/24 10:01pm

Utah recruits much better than Arod for QBs

12/29/24 10:09pm

Why imagine when BYU has won back to back games over Utah and went 11-2 in

Polecat

12/29/24 10:34pm

It's not a train of negativity but rather just being subjective

12/29/24 10:38pm

You’ve said his recruiting is terrible and that he’s doing it at the level of a

Polecat

12/29/24 10:44pm

If something factual is perceived as negative then I'll leave that to you

12/29/24 10:47pm

Too bad he can’t be like Andy Reid and score on every single drive

cougaman

12/29/24 9:49pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad