He's a good coach who made the most of a recruit no one else wanted. But a terrible recruiter that can't compete for recruits that have other P4 offers.
I'd imagine if he was able to get access to a QB that was sought after by other Power schools he'd do pretty well with that QB. Like he did with Zack Wilson and Jaren Hall.
Why don't you try making the case that he is a good recruiter by giving me examples?