It was the most amazing, disappointing season in byu history.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 28, 2024
10:25:05pm

idcougarfan All-American

It was the most amazing, disappointing season in byu history.

Report problem with this ad

idcougarfan

Bio page: idcougarfan
Joined: Nov 7, 2009
Last login: Dec 30, 2024
Total posts: 27,382 (55 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Strong case to be made that this is the third-best season in program history.

shoganai

Dec 28, 10:23pm

It was the most amazing, disappointing season in byu history.

idcougarfan

Dec 28, 10:25pm

Nonsense. The word "disappointing" doesn't belong anywhere near this team.

shoganai

Dec 28, 10:26pm

The Kansas loss is an all time disappointment. Im not talking about the team

stansburycoug

Dec 28, 10:33pm

Well the 2 losses were disappointing for sure, but the team itself wasn’t!

ByuImaginesDragons

Dec 28, 10:34pm

You could throw 79 and 83 in there as well

Dec 28, 10:28pm

83 absolutely. 79 deserves credit as being the squad that "did it

gopman

Dec 28, 10:33pm

I was born in 79’ in nov so I’d like to take credit for that

ByuImaginesDragons

Dec 28, 10:36pm

Go back and look at expectations preseason. Overachieved by a mile

Big Daddy D

Dec 28, 10:31pm

2001 was pretty darn good too. But yes 3rd best has validity to it.

xarope8

Dec 28, 10:25pm

2001 unfortunately had a horrible defense. Gilford was the only

gopman

Dec 28, 10:26pm

And a worse ending to the season. The Hawaii and bowl games were bad.

dfudge

Dec 28, 10:28pm

RE: And a worse ending to the season. The Hawaii and bowl games were bad.

LevZloi

Dec 28, 10:29pm

Thanks for that painful reminder lol

ByuImaginesDragons

Dec 28, 10:37pm

Most overrated team in BYU football history.

NorCal_Coug

Dec 28, 10:32pm

Crowton may well have had both the most overrated and underrated teams in our

shoganai

Dec 28, 10:35pm

2020 was more overrated than 2001

xarope8

Dec 28, 10:54pm

Lots of legit talent on 2020 team that ended up in the NFL BUT the

gopman

Dec 28, 11:00pm

1996 had the "most balanced" (pass/run) offense I've ever seen.

gopman

Dec 28, 10:25pm

Fully agree. Solid #3

UNLVcougar

Dec 28, 10:28pm

Don't tell Brisket. He is too busy looking at ways the team can get better to

dfudge

Dec 28, 10:31pm

Agree, especially considering the quality of the competition/quality wins

Still Blue

Dec 28, 10:32pm

Given the strength of schedule, I absolutely agree.

Yukon

Dec 28, 10:37pm

2007-2009 were decent teams but laid some big eggs.

dfudge

Dec 28, 10:45pm

1984, 1980, 1983, 1996, 1979, 1981, 1990, 2006, 2009, 2007, 2024.

roseyscenario

Dec 28, 10:47pm

I like that list a lot. I'd put 2007 and 1979 below 2024, but

Dec 28, 10:54pm

They're all pretty close. Liked 1977 also. Loved Gifford Nielsen, Marc Wilson, McMahon, Young. Avoiding recency bias.

roseyscenario

Dec 28, 11:02pm

Pioneers who laid the foundation. Absolute respect.

gopman

Dec 28, 11:06pm

I think you have 2024 too low.

Dec 28, 11:03pm

Maybe. But offense is certainly not top 10. Retzlaff not yet close to BYU greats. Agree defense is one of best ever. One

roseyscenario

Dec 28, 11:10pm

Fair assessment. In spring ball I want to see Jake & the entire

gopman

Dec 28, 11:14pm

True, but their ST/defense and overall resume put them above 2006, 2007, & 2009

Dec 28, 11:27pm

06 and 07 were legit well rounded teams

stansburycoug

Dec 29, 11:56am

I don’t consider well rounded to be the determination of which is better

Dec 29, 1:56pm

No way you can put 2024 below a team like 1990 that had multiple blowout losses.

shoganai

Dec 28, 11:25pm

And many more impressive blowout wins. BYU was ranked #4 going into final reg. game. Spent too much time on beach where

roseyscenario

Dec 28, 11:55pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad