It is going to go into the bucket of woulda-shoulda-coulda seasons

Report problem with this ad

Nov 30, 2024
10:11:21pm

Carnac All-American

along with Jimmer's senior season.

But...both this year and Jimmer's last year are all-timers for BYU.

Report problem with this ad

Carnac

Previous username: Carnac el Magnifico
Bio page: Carnac
Joined: Dec 22, 2007
Last login: Dec 26, 2024
Total posts: 47,993 (476 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Look, I get it...

SayMyName All-American

Nov 30, 10:10pm

Macro view…great season. Awesome. Micro view…we screwed the pooch.

RalphWiggam

Nov 30, 10:10pm

We were screwed by the pooch punt

Kolipoki

Nov 30, 10:53pm

That play was so dumb. I will forever hate kansas for that stupid play. bunch of

here's to hoping

Dec 1, 12:40am

May have been dumb, but it worked.

rebelCoug

Dec 1, 5:44am

But this turned the tide for them. So they weren’t losers. They won. LOL

Oscar Bluth

Dec 1, 7:43am

You can be a loser and win a game.

here's to hoping

Dec 1, 8:55am

That and the ASU onside kick. . . Ughhh.

Zoobieman

Dec 1, 8:01am

2025 will wipe away all the bitterness.

xgbs

Dec 1, 9:13am

Stupids FADE

ybecausethatswhy

Nov 30, 10:11pm

Look, Let It Go.

UMWolverine

Nov 30, 10:11pm

I’m with you but love my byu Cougs

MajorZeus

Nov 30, 10:11pm

I love watching this team. Super sad I'll only get to watch ones more game

MaxxPower

Nov 30, 10:29pm

It is going to go into the bucket of woulda-shoulda-coulda seasons

Carnac

Nov 30, 10:11pm

And COVID w/Coastal Carolina

reddead

Dec 1, 12:47am

Boise State taking our first round bye in the CFP is too painful to forget.

WillsPitStop

Nov 30, 10:12pm

Boise will be in the playoff 8/10 years

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Nov 30, 10:14pm

Been saying this for year plus. They’re in great spot. We will struggle in B12

zerome4sooners

Nov 30, 10:27pm

Oh come on, we just tied for first in our 2nd year. We’ll be as fine as any

BaseCoug

Dec 1, 2:01am

Let me know when we make the playoffs

zerome4sooners

Dec 1, 6:45am

RE: Let me know when we make the playoffs

Socrates Johnson

Dec 1, 12:29pm

You assume they will keep letting G5 teams in the playoffs

Huge Manatee

Dec 1, 12:15am

And you assume that BYU will stay on the inside when BSU is cut out

reddead

Dec 1, 12:50am

We're not playing semi-pro ball now?

DeepCCoug

Dec 1, 6:22am

No. Colleges aren’t paying players as employees yet & there are too many teams

reddead

Dec 1, 11:50pm

This is why I'm surprised Utah didn't stay behind to retain their beloved PAC12 logo. The path to the playoff in the new

BackPacker

Dec 1, 10:00am

Don’t be silly. This is the same “BYU back to the MWC” argument that CB hated

reddead

Dec 1, 11:58pm

We get it too.

byujacob

Nov 30, 10:13pm

It's the same for me: we exceeded initial expectations, but...

BlueFever

Nov 30, 10:13pm

I get it too.

The 435

Nov 30, 10:16pm

Bitterness? This season? Dang. Bitterness is what I felt when Gary Crowton

Polecat

Nov 30, 10:17pm

Can't argue that one. The Crowton years, after the first, were REALLY bad.

DeepCCoug

Dec 1, 6:23am

Iron clad logic at work there… I’m more optimistic about getting another sniff

Pretorian

Nov 30, 10:58pm

I’m with you. 16 team league where you don’t play half the teams. 5 v 4 home.

dtownCoug

Dec 1, 12:20am

That Kansas game is going to be right there with Costal Carolina

Pangare

Dec 1, 12:36am

When KS is on the hot seat again in four or five years, we will have a good team

here's to hoping

Dec 1, 12:39am

I think at times the O play calling got too complicated. We would go away from

ImuaKahuku

Dec 1, 12:53am

I think Kalani feels the same way you do according to his post game remarks.

idcougarfan

Dec 1, 6:20am

This 2024 good record gets Sitake off the coaching hot seat. His job is secure.

Forzaitalia

Dec 1, 6:31am

I agree the thought of what could have been is always hard to deal with. But in

HonestTakes

Dec 1, 8:56am

Silver linings, we will get invited to one of the top B12 affiliated bowls.

ImuaKahuku

Dec 1, 9:11am

I truly don’t get being bitter about a game for more than a day. Especially in

Posting on CougarBoard