average P5 coach. I tend to think he very well could have peaked and will now be a consistent bottom half of the conference coach. Comparing just W/L record is oversimplifying the situation. For all the reasons you stated beyond the W/L record.

Does anyone truly think KS is going to come close to achieving what KW has achieved?
KW is a top ten coach in my opinion.

It’s also why KW’s retiremnet can’t come soon enough for me as a BYU fan. The guy is legit. And Kalani is not that guy… pal.

Again, I like Kalani. Great guy, average coach.


At worst his contract should not be renewed. Hopefully it’s a buyout after this season unless things take a big leap forward.

8 years is enough time. Major progress needed this year or split ways. Isn’t that what happened with Bronco?