I would say - Based on Roster and Coaching

Jun 2, 2024
10:05:23am

DataMouth All-American

BYU is a bottom half or of the Big 12 team. I predict two losing seasons in a row and Sitake will be out after Next year.

I really hope I'm wrong.

Report problem with this ad

DataMouth

Previous username: newbie
Bio page: DataMouth
Joined: Aug 12, 2005
Last login: Jun 28, 2024
Total posts: 15,028 (197 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I like Kalani Sitake, and I think he is a bottom half of the BIG12 level coach

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 1, 11:48pm

That is what is going to happen.

Idacoug

Jun 2, 12:02am

I could see it happening and would welcome it. But when will that happen?

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 8:50am

I'm afraid we need a new OC also.

Hinta

Jun 2, 12:03am

Yep, and we'd get that if this scenario comes about. Hill would pick his own coa

Saxa

Jun 2, 6:31am

Agreed, it is would be Hill’s decision in the proposed scenario.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 8:51am

Who would be viable candidates?

Hinta

Jun 2, 9:04am

Not sure. Step one is what matters most. Nothing matters beyond it at this point

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 9:17am

When did defense became our strength? 99th in PPG allowed & 101st in Yards

arcawley

Jun 2, 12:46am

Yeah. Trying to figure out what season he watched. I remember an Iowa State team

RalphWiggam

Jun 2, 1:44am

Look at the FEI rankings. Things switched for the better on D and worse on O.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 8:57am

Deleted

CallSign

Jun 2, 9:50am

Kyle Whittington was 5-7 two seasons in a row at Utah

donnerstag

Jun 2, 12:58am

We all know Kyle Whittingham. Donnerstag, Kalani is no Kyle Whittingham

Blue2thebone

Jun 2, 1:03am

It’s apples and oranges, but if you look at the list of all time coaches

donnerstag

Jun 2, 1:09am

RE: Kyle Whittington was 5-7 two seasons in a row at Utah

deliciousmocha

Jun 2, 1:23am

This take has become so obnoxious that it is impossible to ignore.

rmarkerm

Jun 2, 3:40pm

Very well said, although I don’t think Kalani is in over his head, he is a below

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 9:58pm

KW also inherited a program that was already very healthy

donnerstag

Jun 2, 10:22pm

Agreed, it’s why it’s more than just W/L. How would you grade KS and KW?

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 11:31pm

Kalani’s ceiling is a bit more unknown

donnerstag

Jun 3, 12:13am

How about up to this point then? What grade would you give each?

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 3, 6:22am

Terrible idea instead just keep having bad seasons until his contracts over and put all the football dollars into MBB

Blue2thebone

Jun 2, 12:59am

Basketball 🏀 Baby

44C

Jun 2, 5:23am

Defense became our strength? What season were you watching?

RalphWiggam

Jun 2, 1:38am

BYU ranked 99th in offense and 54th in defense last year

Dr T-bone

Jun 2, 4:47am

Link? Because that isn’t what I’m seeing. According to this their team defense

RalphWiggam

Jun 2, 6:35am

FEI breaks things down further than just yards against and points against.

BYUfannonLDS

Jun 2, 7:10am

I do believe the defense played better than the numbers show, which is

BYUfannonLDS

Jun 2, 7:18am

Hill was a good hire and should only continue to prove so.

CallSign

Jun 2, 9:54am

I think that as well.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 10:51am

Hmm……..well, I am certain that everyone who matters in the equation, disagrees

PhilPete

Jun 2, 5:55am

Interesting Phil, how did they feel about Tuiaki the whole time as well?

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 8:58am

Because Sitake will get one more season no matter what and Hill will move on.

Longseason

Jun 2, 6:44am

I don't think we watched the same Football. I definitely did not think the

wildlandfireguy

Jun 2, 7:03am

Look at the FEI stats, defense got better in his first year…

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 8:58am

He’s easily bottom 3 with Satterfield and Aranda

byuTX

Jun 2, 8:08am

$50,000,000 NIL/yr would make him a better coach.

ParentingNotForSissy

Jun 2, 10:04am

I would say - Based on Roster and Coaching

DataMouth

Jun 2, 10:05am

Meaning we have a new coach next year or in 2026?

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 10:46am

2026

DataMouth

Jun 2, 11:08am

RE: 2026

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 2:45pm

Remember when Kyle whittingham entered the pac12

davidmj10

Jun 2, 11:25am

Agree, as stated I think we need to upgrade the talent. Same goes for the HC.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 2:46pm

I believe most of the fans on here are bottom half MWC tier fan. JMO

bookofdaniel

Jun 2, 1:43pm

RE: I believe most of the fans on here are bottom half MWC tier fan. JMO

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 2:46pm

If that were true most here would support KS as one of their own

byuTX

Jun 2, 2:54pm

I like winning more than I like KS. If he doesn’t win ( insert excuse her ),

coastcat

Jun 2, 1:52pm

Hard to argue against winning.

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 2, 2:47pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad