I think you need 3-4 LDS kids, 3-4 outwardly religious kids (e.g. Fouss), then
the best players you can get who will keep the HC.
I just think BYU does better when it doesn't lose it's LDS/religious identity. Players like Fouss, Aly, and even Dybantsa (I believe he's strong Christian if I remember), help with that.