Yikes, definitely not a good stretch of 5 games for the offense/qb

Report problem with this ad

Jan 2, 2025
10:00:16pm

palangi All-American

Report problem with this ad

palangi

Bio page: palangi
Joined: Nov 2, 2005
Last login: Jan 6, 2025
Total posts: 23,041 (380 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

11-2. Tied for first. Eliminated from the CCG by a tie breaker. Biggest bowl win since the '96 Cotton Bowl

Adrielle Board Misanthrope

Jan 2, 1:54pm

RE: 11-2. Tied for first. Eliminated from the CCG by a tie breaker. Biggest bowl win since the '96 Cotton Bowl

Indy Coug

Jan 2, 1:55pm

That's perfect

Adrielle

Jan 2, 1:56pm

I like Jake, he was awful in the bowl game.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 1:57pm

ya know who else was awful? the guys who are going to be drafted in the 1st

LeonMarek

Jan 2, 2:00pm

But those guys had to play our defense

tacallaway

Jan 2, 2:00pm

You thought Hunter was awful? What? Shedeur struggled, but still had a PER 60 points higher

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:03pm

Because of hunters YAC that’s all. He was awful and couldn’t move an offense

Hammurabi

Jan 3, 12:27am

Awful is a pretty big overstatement

Adrielle

Jan 2, 2:01pm

He made more mistakes than he usually did throughout the season but ...

Archaea

Jan 2, 2:02pm

Based on what? 12-21 with 2 interceptions, 151 yards a 98 passer rating, another pick on

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:05pm

Another fumble we were fortunate to recover....

byubyu

Jan 2, 2:10pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:13pm

Oh I think it was. He should not have thrown that ball.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:14pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:16pm

You are 100% wrong on the read. It is a play just like a screen pass where of course you are

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:27pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:31pm

I'm sorry, but you are flat out wrong.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:00pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:07pm

Ha, ha, ha...now I know you are not serious. My screenshot has the ball right in his hand ready

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:16pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:19pm

He could have completed the pitch by the fact that it hit his receiver in his hands when the receiver

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:24pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:27pm

Looking back what a dumb thread. I apologize for my part in it. I don't think he should

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:39pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:41pm

Here is a screenshot a full 1.3 seconds before the ball leaves his hand. Where are his eyes?

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:22pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:25pm

Not sure what you are using. I freeze framed two shots that were 1.3 seconds apart.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:34pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:38pm

And after re-reading your posts I better understand the "read" that you are saying.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 3:40pm

That disconnect makes sense. And now I understand your posts better, which all

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 3:43pm

Awwwww… you guyyyyyyys…

mvtoro

Jan 2, 8:11pm

How about 7 carries for 29 yds despite 2 of those being sacks? Maybe you'd prefer Sanders 9 carries for a -34 yds?

ManicBlue

Jan 2, 4:14pm

He was awful last year with a 97 rating. 98 is still awful. Overall he improved a lot but was bad the 2nd half of 24 BUT

byuTX

Jan 2, 3:31pm

I don't think you like Jake.

Conan

Jan 2, 2:04pm

You would be wrong. I would still have him as my QB1 going into next season.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:05pm

Your posting history suggests otherwise. Maybe you're less hypercritical of him in private.

Conan

Jan 2, 2:08pm

If you think my posting history suggest hypercritical behavior then I'm not sure what to tell you.

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 4:30pm

and yet, he had a better overall game than the likely #1 pick in the upcoming NFL draft. hmmm ....

ManicBlue

Jan 2, 2:27pm

NO HE'S AN ACCURATE PASSER CB TOLD ME SO

Haysom Till

Jan 2, 2:28pm

I still don’t get why people can’t handle simple truths and criticism

MrSandman

Jan 2, 5:01pm

How about putting your life on display so we can see how you handle "simple truths and criticism"? 🙂

ManicBlue

Jan 2, 5:26pm

Oh, sure, college football is sacred—because nothing says ‘untouchable’ like an

MrSandman

Jan 2, 10:07pm

Wow ... I see that you really can't understand the concept.

ManicBlue

Jan 2, 11:28pm

Lol, nice try.

MrSandman

Jan 3, 8:05am

<< Deleted >>

Adrielle

Jan 2, 2:00pm

Below a 100 QB rating while completing 12-21 passes for 151 yards and 2 ints is most

kimdaddy35

Jan 2, 2:02pm

Almost like when people (Indy) said not to get rid of Tuiaki because we won 10

byubyu

Jan 2, 2:02pm

It’s amazing he continued to defend Tuiaki when it was such an obvious mess. And we’ve since been completely vindicated

WP17

Jan 2, 2:21pm

or ... heaven forbid, a player continues to improve. Difficult concept I know.

ManicBlue

Jan 2, 2:44pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:46pm

Why not cite QB stats in support of the QB, rather than team achievements?

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 2:06pm

Because posting stats, either season or game by game, would open the door for

foofcoug

Jan 2, 2:12pm

It's not that people point out flaws, but 90% of these posts just point out how

SUAVO

Jan 2, 2:06pm

Wait, you mean people acknowledge the things he does well while also pointing

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 2:16pm

No, I'm saying that people don't acknowledge what he does well or don't

SUAVO

Jan 2, 2:23pm

The post the OP linked to starts out pointing out what a likeable guy he is and

russkiejedi

Jan 2, 2:26pm

I hope Jake doesn’t read this board, or any BYU players. Bad look for our fans

Japan Coug

Jan 2, 2:15pm

Outside of 1 game, Jake and the offense owes the defense steak dinners for the entire offseason....

Coug

Jan 2, 2:37pm

*2 games: Oklahoma St. & ASU. The D was bad in both games, worse than the O.

Japan Coug

Jan 2, 2:51pm

The team was bad entirely vs ASU...

Coug

Jan 2, 2:52pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:56pm

<< Deleted >>

chilawcoug

Jan 2, 2:56pm

Both were bad in the 1st half, but in the second the O outplayed the D by a lot.

Japan Coug

Jan 2, 3:00pm

Are you an apologist that is paid by BYU to go after anyone that doesn't carry

SnickSnack

Jan 2, 3:23pm

Unbelievable

Blue Heart

Jan 2, 3:38pm

Because being 12-1 after playing in the CCG and playing yesterday was a realistic alternative?

unctoothman

Jan 2, 5:28pm

The team can be both good and the quarterback vulnerable to errors.

Plantagenet

Jan 2, 5:53pm

Not unreal. Perfectly reasonable to criticize his performance in the last 5

WillsPitStop

Jan 2, 8:07pm

Yikes, definitely not a good stretch of 5 games for the offense/qb

palangi

Jan 2, 10:00pm

Nah, any criticism is warranted. I like Retzlaff but he’s been a below average

Posting on CougarBoard