My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jan 2, 2025
2:05
:46
pm
kimdaddy35
Former Fly Half
You would be wrong. I would still have him as my QB1 going into next season.
I don't think you can move on from him. But he was awful in the bowl game.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
kimdaddy35
Bio page
kimdaddy35
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Last login
Jan 4, 2025
Total posts
52,732 (1,561 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
11-2. Tied for first. Eliminated from the CCG by a tie breaker. Biggest bowl win since the '96 Cotton Bowl
Adrielle
Board Misanthrope
Jan 2, 1:54pm
RE: 11-2. Tied for first. Eliminated from the CCG by a tie breaker. Biggest bowl win since the '96 Cotton Bowl
Indy Coug
Jan 2, 1:55pm
That's perfect
Adrielle
Jan 2, 1:56pm
I like Jake, he was awful in the bowl game.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 1:57pm
ya know who else was awful? the guys who are going to be drafted in the 1st
LeonMarek
Jan 2, 2:00pm
But those guys had to play our defense
tacallaway
Jan 2, 2:00pm
You thought Hunter was awful? What? Shedeur struggled, but still had a PER 60 points higher
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:03pm
Because of hunters YAC that’s all. He was awful and couldn’t move an offense
Hammurabi
Jan 3, 12:27am
Awful is a pretty big overstatement
Adrielle
Jan 2, 2:01pm
He made more mistakes than he usually did throughout the season but ...
Archaea
Jan 2, 2:02pm
Based on what? 12-21 with 2 interceptions, 151 yards a 98 passer rating, another pick on
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:05pm
Another fumble we were fortunate to recover....
byubyu
Jan 2, 2:10pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:13pm
Oh I think it was. He should not have thrown that ball.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:14pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:16pm
You are 100% wrong on the read. It is a play just like a screen pass where of course you are
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:27pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:31pm
I'm sorry, but you are flat out wrong.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:00pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:07pm
Ha, ha, ha...now I know you are not serious. My screenshot has the ball right in his hand ready
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:16pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:19pm
He could have completed the pitch by the fact that it hit his receiver in his hands when the receiver
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:24pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:27pm
Looking back what a dumb thread. I apologize for my part in it. I don't think he should
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:39pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:41pm
Here is a screenshot a full 1.3 seconds before the ball leaves his hand. Where are his eyes?
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:22pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:25pm
Not sure what you are using. I freeze framed two shots that were 1.3 seconds apart.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:34pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:38pm
And after re-reading your posts I better understand the "read" that you are saying.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 3:40pm
That disconnect makes sense. And now I understand your posts better, which all
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 3:43pm
Awwwww… you guyyyyyyys…
mvtoro
Jan 2, 8:11pm
How about 7 carries for 29 yds despite 2 of those being sacks? Maybe you'd prefer Sanders 9 carries for a -34 yds?
ManicBlue
Jan 2, 4:14pm
He was awful last year with a 97 rating. 98 is still awful. Overall he improved a lot but was bad the 2nd half of 24 BUT
byuTX
Jan 2, 3:31pm
I don't think you like Jake.
Conan
Jan 2, 2:04pm
You would be wrong. I would still have him as my QB1 going into next season.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:05pm
Your posting history suggests otherwise. Maybe you're less hypercritical of him in private.
Conan
Jan 2, 2:08pm
If you think my posting history suggest hypercritical behavior then I'm not sure what to tell you.
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 4:30pm
and yet, he had a better overall game than the likely #1 pick in the upcoming NFL draft. hmmm ....
ManicBlue
Jan 2, 2:27pm
NO HE'S AN ACCURATE PASSER CB TOLD ME SO
Haysom Till
Jan 2, 2:28pm
I still don’t get why people can’t handle simple truths and criticism
MrSandman
Jan 2, 5:01pm
How about putting your life on display so we can see how you handle "simple truths and criticism"? 🙂
ManicBlue
Jan 2, 5:26pm
Oh, sure, college football is sacred—because nothing says ‘untouchable’ like an
MrSandman
Jan 2, 10:07pm
Wow ... I see that you really can't understand the concept.
ManicBlue
Jan 2, 11:28pm
Lol, nice try.
MrSandman
Jan 3, 8:05am
<< Deleted >>
Adrielle
Jan 2, 2:00pm
Below a 100 QB rating while completing 12-21 passes for 151 yards and 2 ints is most
kimdaddy35
Jan 2, 2:02pm
Almost like when people (Indy) said not to get rid of Tuiaki because we won 10
byubyu
Jan 2, 2:02pm
It’s amazing he continued to defend Tuiaki when it was such an obvious mess. And we’ve since been completely vindicated
WP17
Jan 2, 2:21pm
or ... heaven forbid, a player continues to improve. Difficult concept I know.
ManicBlue
Jan 2, 2:44pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:46pm
Why not cite QB stats in support of the QB, rather than team achievements?
russkiejedi
Jan 2, 2:06pm
Because posting stats, either season or game by game, would open the door for
foofcoug
Jan 2, 2:12pm
It's not that people point out flaws, but 90% of these posts just point out how
SUAVO
Jan 2, 2:06pm
Wait, you mean people acknowledge the things he does well while also pointing
russkiejedi
Jan 2, 2:16pm
No, I'm saying that people don't acknowledge what he does well or don't
SUAVO
Jan 2, 2:23pm
The post the OP linked to starts out pointing out what a likeable guy he is and
russkiejedi
Jan 2, 2:26pm
I hope Jake doesn’t read this board, or any BYU players. Bad look for our fans
Japan Coug
Jan 2, 2:15pm
Outside of 1 game, Jake and the offense owes the defense steak dinners for the entire offseason....
Coug
Jan 2, 2:37pm
*2 games: Oklahoma St. & ASU. The D was bad in both games, worse than the O.
Japan Coug
Jan 2, 2:51pm
The team was bad entirely vs ASU...
Coug
Jan 2, 2:52pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:56pm
<< Deleted >>
chilawcoug
Jan 2, 2:56pm
Both were bad in the 1st half, but in the second the O outplayed the D by a lot.
Japan Coug
Jan 2, 3:00pm
Are you an apologist that is paid by BYU to go after anyone that doesn't carry
SnickSnack
Jan 2, 3:23pm
Unbelievable
Blue Heart
Jan 2, 3:38pm
Because being 12-1 after playing in the CCG and playing yesterday was a realistic alternative?
unctoothman
Jan 2, 5:28pm
The team can be both good and the quarterback vulnerable to errors.
Plantagenet
Jan 2, 5:53pm
Not unreal. Perfectly reasonable to criticize his performance in the last 5
WillsPitStop
Jan 2, 8:07pm
Yikes, definitely not a good stretch of 5 games for the offense/qb
palangi
Jan 2, 10:00pm
Nah, any criticism is warranted. I like Retzlaff but he’s been a below average
palangi
Jan 2, 9:58pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad