My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 21, 2024
12:17
:05
pm
Manti
Truly Addicted User
The first "pass" wasn't a pass. It's like a hand-off. A lateral. But I've
wondered the same thing. Is there no such thing as a PI if you've handed the ball off?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Manti
Previous username
MantiCoug
Bio page
Manti
Joined
Nov 11, 2002
Last login
Oct 21, 2024
Total posts
63,489 (22,189 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I need a ruling. The Double Pass
Borg
12:15pm
There was some question of whether the ball was tipped at the line
canuckchuck
12:16pm
Nvm just watched it
canuckchuck
12:19pm
I think most of the contact happened before the ball was thrown
Future_Tacos
1:25pm
I think it should have been a defensive holding. I think if ball is not in the
cwilke1
12:16pm
The first "pass" wasn't a pass. It's like a hand-off. A lateral. But I've
Manti
12:17pm
The first pass isn't a forward pass, it's more akin to a pitch.
CougPrime
12:17pm
I liked when the announcer tried to talk about it "Was that a hold?" And the other guy just totally ignored the question
brj8
12:18pm
Yeah, “wow the home fans were not happy about that play call” uhhh no they
ChiCityCoug
12:22pm
I wasn't happy with the play call, its execution, or the reffing
byujag
12:30pm
trick plays lose their effectiveness if you run it every game from the same part
fulano
12:44pm
Don't think Hinckley will ever be asked to throw again
baldcoug74
5:10pm
To me, looks like the receiver trips trying to change directions because
Doogal McCougar
12:24pm
the guy who held was also the guy who made the interception. Whether pass is
cwilke1
12:37pm
doesn't matter, ARod got cute and used Ropati to make a throw he shouldn't be making, I know they practice those plays,
ChinaFan
12:29pm
Is it a bad idea because it didn’t work? What if it had worked ?
Polecat
3:25pm
I think it was a bad decision because it wasn't needed. We were driving the ball
morningcalmcougar
3:35pm
Fair. I think this is a moment in which Arod shows an unwillingness to develop
Polecat
3:38pm
I agree. His play calling was pretty good this game, especially he 2nd half
morningcalmcougar
3:46pm
I’ve called them out as bad ideas when they have worked sometimes. When it’s in
ColonelMustard
3:40pm
It has worked well when Kingston is throwing the ball but
NonmormonYfan89
5:08pm
a flag should have been thrown on the personnel used in the play design.
Cougarclaw
12:30pm
how so? I see seven BYU players on the line and 4 back. Doesn't 7 guys on the
cwilke1
12:39pm
Ropati didn't meet the minimum requirement for anyone throwing a D1 ball.
Cougarclaw
12:42pm
Exactly. Why have Ropati throw that?
Orem58thBall
1:12pm
My biggest gripe with ARod. He uses the B team far too often on important plays.
TheLoneCougar
2:59pm
Assuming they practiced it like that all week, wouldn’t that make them the A
Polecat
3:26pm
No, I want the best players in. Hinckely or LJ throwing that pass, LJ.
TheLoneCougar
3:35pm
Kingston, former Roy high QB, is the only one who should be passing.
Mabuhay Coug
3:46pm
That may get too predictable if we do that too many times with him.
TheLoneCougar
4:25pm
I mean you’d want the players who practiced it during the week doing it on
Polecat
3:48pm
Fair points. And I agree with you to a degree. But in general it feels like ARod has 2nd and 3rd stringers in for
TheLoneCougar
4:26pm
I assume play design was for Ropati to get outside and Lasiter running corner
fulano
12:47pm
I'm guessing it would have been called if the pass was even remotely accurate
MaximusMeridius
1:29pm
The rule doesn’t change with the a lateral…but officials give a lot more leniency. Kind of like when Batty destroyed
FromCAtoUT
2:53pm
If the first pass is not a forward lateral, then all PI rules should apply
morningcalmcougar
3:05pm
The first one is not a pass. The 2nd one is. PI applies
RGGeemer
4:11pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad