Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the B12 for

Sep 10, 2024
3:45:52pm

Magneto Intervention Needed

Next year? How do we replicate a KY affect for football? BTW UCF is going to be good. They’ve been in the top 3 recruiting in the league the past two year.

https://247sports.com/season/2025-football/compositeteamrankings/?Conference=Big%2012

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 10, 2024 at 3:45:52pm

Message modified by Magneto on Sep 10, 2024 at 3:48:00pm

Report problem with this ad

Magneto

Bio page: Magneto
Joined: Jul 1, 2022
Last login: Sep 16, 2024
Total posts: 6,200 (16 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the B12 for

Magneto

Sep 10, 3:45pm

RE: Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the

Eddie

Sep 10, 3:49pm

We spent ~$2M on Egor Demin? Would that money have been better used to get a stud QB?

krindorr

Sep 10, 3:55pm

nah. Get a QB like Charlie Ward.

Eddie

Sep 10, 3:58pm

No.

Blewis15

Sep 10, 6:50pm

Only one answer

Deleted

Sep 10, 3:50pm

Is an 85 average rating all that different from 86 or 87?

RGGeemer

Sep 10, 3:54pm

I’m surprised we don’t have a single 4*. Some kids commit early too and others

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:02pm

We got a bunch of ours this year during the offseason, right? I wouldn't worry

RGGeemer

Sep 10, 4:09pm

I tried to have that discussion a couple of months ago

Belboz

Sep 10, 4:58pm

In my experience involving this type of discussion,

Everyman

Sep 10, 5:28pm

One kid can be an 85 today and an 86 tomorrow.

Belboz

Sep 10, 6:03pm

I did a pretty decent analysis of this by rating (not stars)

krindorr

Sep 10, 8:56pm

To get a better idea, you'd need to separate them more

Belboz

Sep 11, 12:34am

84% of NFL first round draft picks were 247 rated 4 stars // 27 of 32. I would

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 10, 11:13pm

RE: I tried to have that discussion a couple of months ago

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 11, 1:00pm

It's a REALLY strong relationship

krindorr

Sep 11, 3:05pm

The recruiting rankings aren't a perfect science but they are as accurate as

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 12, 5:48am

Also, here's an analysis of BYU recruiting vs Wake Forest, Northwestern, Boston College, Northwestern, Cal, USF & others

krindorr

Sep 11, 3:09pm

No because the players love Sitake and everyone is having a great time:

byuTX

Sep 10, 3:54pm

Its certainly an indicator that we're not planning on competing to win the Big12

DodgerCoug

Sep 10, 4:15pm

Nothing is being planned. There is no plan or set up. No accountability.

byuTX

Sep 10, 4:28pm

I love that you keep repeating this, hoping that it comes true. But it's not

OldFogey

Sep 10, 8:02pm

deion sanders is the football equivalent of KY. that’s what it takes to have that impact in football.

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 4:00pm

KY actually recruits good players.

spidercoug

Sep 10, 4:07pm

we don’t know that yet

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 4:17pm

We sure know that Deion doesn't

spidercoug

Sep 10, 4:27pm

RE: we don’t know that yet

getdal

Sep 10, 5:45pm

sorry but KY hasn’t even coached a game at BYU.

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 6:08pm

The statement was that we didn't know whether KY had recruited good players not

getdal

Sep 11, 6:42am

he said we know KY recruits good players like deion doesn’t. deions players are better on paper than the guys

FieroCoug

Sep 11, 7:12pm

This is fair

krindorr

Sep 12, 6:28am

Deion was an assistant coach in the NFL?

andrewg3

Sep 11, 1:09am

we’re talking about recruiting impact not actual resume

FieroCoug

Sep 12, 10:52am

If BYU wants to compete for championships, absolutely

Projectoor

Sep 10, 4:26pm

Yes

Big12Yfan

Sep 10, 4:26pm

Great way to put it.

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:53pm

Yes, it is the single most reliable predictor of wins and losses. BYU consistent

miblue

Sep 10, 9:01pm

Yes. Kalani has been a terrible recruiter and we can't sustain more years of it

YIsForBrigham

Sep 10, 4:43pm

We need to lock down Austin Pay for sure, hopefully we get Taj Crutchfield, tho

Captain Stubing

Sep 10, 4:54pm

We also MUST get Tuakoi and Akuila enrolled for winter smstr and in spring ball

Captain Stubing

Sep 10, 4:59pm

I think we're at least a few weeks in front of December's early signing period

Belboz

Sep 10, 4:54pm

We’ve seen a bump in recruiting since joininthe B12 but nothing like UCF has had

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:54pm

Thankfully our coaching and development is top notch. So we can get by with

byubyu

Sep 10, 5:01pm

It is called do the Pope thing, get rid of KS and bring in someone else.

Blue for Life

Sep 10, 5:21pm

There isn't much difference in being 15th vs 8th to be honest

boctabulous

Sep 10, 6:08pm

You don't want the answer to how to duplicate in football what happened in basketball

KYU

Sep 10, 6:22pm

We are getting 1/2 share of tv money. Double coaching money next year.

ParentingNotForSissy

Sep 10, 6:32pm

RE: Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the

Countcougula

Sep 10, 11:00pm

Love and learn

Haysom Till

Sep 10, 11:19pm

A little concerned, but it’s still early and you gotta think about transfers too

Posting on CougarBoard