RE: They are far less qualified, but u go with whom you want. BTW, both guys

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 10, 2024
11:35:36am

imdocrob All-American

RE: They are far less qualified, but u go with whom you want. BTW, both guys

Neither one of us is going to change our minds....I have listened to Matich quite a bit to know who he is and why BYU uses him on SN every Monday....he brings the rah rah to all things BYU...any one with any unbiased opinion would all agree that Retzlaff is a turnover machine and would not be starting at any other P4 program in the country. But since this is BYU and we won't change our QB unless he is dragging an appendage behind him...we will get what we get! End of Story!

Report problem with this ad

imdocrob

Bio page: imdocrob
Joined: Jun 6, 2011
Last login: Sep 18, 2024
Total posts: 1,678 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Two things can be true at once

MaximusMeridius

Sep 8, 11:16pm

I think people take issue when the negative is the only thing posted. I'm sure

SUAVO

Sep 8, 11:19pm

Then make more positive posts.

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:20pm

Trying to

SUAVO

Sep 8, 11:20pm

Keep it up and don't engage the negative Nancys and chicken littles.

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:24pm

Sharing factual data on our offense/Retzlaffs inefficiencies is not being a

Sep 9, 12:37am

…because you think the “analysis” you post on CB will affect or change the program.

mvtoro

Sep 9, 1:53am

Because this is a fan message board where fans discuss their team’s performance.

Sep 9, 7:05am

So explain to me why it would be “wrong” (🤣) to not share this “factual data”? Explain the moral obligation that

mvtoro

Sep 9, 10:31am

lol... ratioed

Sep 9, 10:42am

🤣Bro, you can have 10,000 people back your belief that your posts in CB actually affect HC decisions and are a moral

mvtoro

Sep 9, 11:12am

...you're on an island by yourself, bud. Enjoy it

Sep 9, 11:48am

Yup. My island is boring. Your island of CB Post Scientology sounds amazing! Miserable, maybe, but the power of being

mvtoro

Sep 9, 11:56am

lol, unhinged... but go on

Sep 9, 12:30pm

It really, really is. But who am I to question? Maybe you really are “THE GUY”:

mvtoro

Sep 9, 12:41pm

RE: Sharing factual data on our offense/Retzlaffs inefficiencies is not being a

Sep 9, 6:22am

Your assumptions are flawed

travelcoug

Sep 9, 6:54am

Nothing about the OP was mean or bullying. It was 100% factual and a

Sep 9, 7:11am

Overall tone of the board since Friday nigh. It has been a horrible place

travelcoug

Sep 9, 7:21am

It was incomplete and one-sided. That is what was wrong with it.

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:41am

RE: It was incomplete and one-sided. That is what was wrong with it.

imdocrob

Sep 9, 9:14am

Your post was ridiculous, his post was right. He wins you lose.

travelcoug

Sep 9, 9:38am

RE: Your post was ridiculous, his post was right. He wins you lose.

imdocrob

Sep 9, 9:46am

Again, if you can’t see them, it’s willful blindness, and no amount of logic

travelcoug

Sep 9, 9:51am

...imdocrob, his lack of any specifics tells us all we need to know...

Sep 9, 10:30am

OK I’ll give you two specifics

travelcoug

Sep 9, 10:47am

Kalani called out the offense and the special teams after the game

stansburycoug

Sep 9, 11:07am

RE: OK I’ll give you two specifics

imdocrob

Sep 9, 11:26am

...and my rebuttal

Sep 9, 11:33am

Ancient data is definitely cold fact - hard or not. Different teams - different

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 12:09pm

Speaking of heads in dark places. Special teams sucked. He never mentioned

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 12:00pm

RE: Speaking of heads in dark places. Special teams sucked. He never mentioned

imdocrob

Sep 9, 1:20pm

Nice pivot. OP was incomplete. I recommend u watch Trevor Matich

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:49pm

RE: Nice pivot. OP was incomplete. I recommend u watch Trevor Matich

imdocrob

Sep 9, 9:06pm

I gave u some reference material from 2 people u probably respect. If u can’t

Cougarbib

Sep 10, 12:47am

RE: I gave u some reference material from 2 people u probably respect. If u

imdocrob

Sep 10, 7:42am

They are far less qualified, but u go with whom you want. BTW, both guys were

Cougarbib

Sep 10, 9:00am

RE: They are far less qualified, but u go with whom you want. BTW, both guys

imdocrob

Sep 10, 11:35am

So u didn’t listen to him even though I told u he was critical of the offense -

Cougarbib

Sep 10, 1:37pm

One more turnover by Jake is my tipping point.

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:19pm

When's the last time he didn't turn the ball over in a game? I think the bigger

MaximusMeridius

Sep 8, 11:23pm

Just win, baby! With Jake, Gerry, or whoever.

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:26pm

I have no doubt that Jake is going to look great against Wyoming

MaximusMeridius

Sep 8, 11:30pm

That's why I extended the short leash for 3 games.

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:35pm

Then fix the running game. RB was a bigger issue than QB. Adjustments in play

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:44am

And then what? We go into the gauntlet of Big 12 play where the competition goes

Sep 9, 7:19am

He's right. If we don't whine about it on CB, the coaches will do nothing about

Sep 9, 7:25am

These types of comments are hilarious

MaximusMeridius

Sep 9, 8:54am

You should probably read the post I responded to. And to be clear I've

Sep 9, 9:17am

Make sure to watch Fox and MSNBC, so u are aware of all of the things MS

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 12:28pm

I have politics turned off for a reason. Keep it there please.

Sep 9, 2:39pm

U do realize you brought up Fox News and being a conservative? Do u?

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:50pm

I think you can see the difference between my post and yours. Don't you?

Sep 9, 8:48pm

Yes. Mine was more complete and honest. Yours was a cleverly disguised pitch

Cougarbib

Sep 10, 12:49am

Depth caused the losing streak. What do you think they should have fixed

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:51am

Well then, I guess you're going to get tipped.

DeepCCoug

Sep 9, 6:19am

3 turnoverless games is your standard?

Sep 9, 6:25am

I fully agree that you would probably overreact like that.

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:42am

And Arod and Kalani are at fault for being so short-sighted thinking we had

Forbidden Fruit

Sep 8, 11:25pm

Well said. Unfortunately much of CB doesn’t want to hear this.

Lifi

Sep 8, 11:32pm

I want to hear it, but we’ve heard it a hundred times in the last 2 days…

BYUCLA

Sep 9, 12:28am

Why is that unfortunate? Just let everyone have their opinion.

ochobeeguy

Sep 9, 3:56pm

AND Sitake has a boring, terrible offensive style. He has abandoned BYU's roots.

bluefish

Sep 8, 11:52pm

I don’t think it’s true that who ever our QB is will be a game manager…

icecougar

Sep 9, 12:24am

Yes. 1). Our defense is much improved. 2) Our QB1 isn't

icecougar

Sep 9, 2:01am

They had an entire offseason and fall camp, yet he is still turnover prone.

bald man

Sep 9, 4:59am

You are right. No other teams make turn overs. Just us. Bald man is wise

travelcoug

Sep 9, 6:57am

That is a rude response. Not to mention deaf to the situation.

bald man

Sep 9, 9:47am

Exactly how I feel. Well said.

bythenumbers

Sep 9, 6:09am

I only see SEVEN "3 and outs"

cambo

Sep 9, 6:55am

Amen. I seriously can’t stand the polyannas here that make sure we are joyful

Idacoug

Sep 9, 7:09am

🤣 You are quite the peach

OldFogey

Sep 9, 7:30am

I was shocked at how often BYU kept trying to force the ball to the RB's

BYU Fan

Sep 9, 7:21am

I'm hoping Arod flips the script and uses the short and intermediate pass game

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 9, 7:36am

If you can’t run the ball, nothing else works due to being easy to defend a

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 8:00am

They can use short passes and spread the defense out.

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 9, 8:30am

Adjustments ARod made late - due to RB 1 and 2 being dinged, won the game. He

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 8:39am

I would like to upgrade your 'probably' to 'absolutely'

OldFogey

Sep 9, 8:45am

I have been saying the LJ Martin take since start of Fall camp. He is the

Cougs2012

Sep 9, 7:23am

U forgot to mention positives on Retzlaff and negatives on ST. At least u didn’t

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 7:38am

What’s weird is all of our backs averaged 4 ypc

Sep 9, 8:13am

90% of us are in this exact camp. Whats the issue?

Haysom Till

Sep 9, 8:25am

This is pretty much where I've decided to be until the end of the season.

BlueFever

Sep 9, 8:27am

How bad were his TOs in JC?

Dr MoBYU

Sep 9, 9:19am

RE: How bad were his TOs in JC?

imdocrob

Sep 9, 9:31am

If LJ is out for an extended period, I think GB is the better option at QB

Accipiter

Sep 9, 10:45am

I think LJ's injury is the strongest argument to put in GBo

MaximusMeridius

Sep 9, 10:50am

That kind of depends whether GB shoulder is ready to be lowered to give crushing

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 12:31pm

Great post. I think that everyone is happy that we have 2 wins.

ochobeeguy

Sep 9, 3:49pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad