Keita did not back up Carlson

Sep 8, 2024
11:53:25pm

Remigius All-American

He backed up Lovering. Still not sure that the Utah back up center that struggled to see the floor at times, gets more minutes than our proven returning center.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 8, 2024 at 11:53:25pm

Message modified by Remigius on Sep 8, 2024 at 11:54:44pm

Message modified by Remigius on Sep 8, 2024 at 11:58:32pm

Report problem with this ad

Remigius

Previous username: BYUHoopster
Bio page: Remigius
Joined: Feb 25, 2003
Last login: Sep 16, 2024
Total posts: 14,630 (264 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Update/repost: Still too early take on the roster and who is going to play.

roseyscenario Work-in-Progress

Sep 8, 10:46pm

Is Mboup coming?

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 10:56pm

Maybe. They're still trying.

roseyscenario

Sep 8, 11:03pm

Is it an academic thing, or something else?

IdahoCoug

Sep 8, 11:08pm

Tripple and Tripplet? For real?

Heath Squashwell

Sep 8, 11:10pm

And Trey. BYU is a 3 pt shooting team, after all.

Soupie

Sep 8, 11:12pm

Don't forget Traore.

Plantagenet

Sep 9, 10:15am

Wow, prognosis for Bosko that bad huh? Here I hoped we had found our

Mitty

Sep 8, 11:16pm

Boskovic probably is that good. At this point, belief is Mag and Catchings are a notch up from the able Waterman/Bosko.

roseyscenario

Sep 8, 11:18pm

Hope so but that would require a big leap on O from Mag and Catchings

Mitty

Sep 8, 11:24pm

If they don't get it done, Bosko moves up. So far, intel tells us Mag and Catchings are stronger players. Things change.

roseyscenario

Sep 8, 11:32pm

But Mag isn't really a 4. He's certainly strong & explosive enough, but 6'7 & short-armed. Given his foot-speed

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:55am

In the highlight video I saw of Boskovic playing against pros he looked REALLY

sandiegocgrfan

Sep 9, 1:24pm

He obviously needs work in the low post, but the size, strength, speed, skill & experience makes him our surest bet at 4

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 1:32pm

Agreed. The other video someone posted when the commit came out had a lot of him

sandiegocgrfan

Sep 9, 1:48pm

Yeah, I was 1 who posted that. It gave a good glimpse of his physicality & quickness but was vs much easier competition.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 1:57pm

RE: Wow, prognosis for Bosko that bad huh? Here I hoped we had found our

SportsLover

Sep 9, 9:04am

He's much more physical than Waterman. If he's no better than rosey's saying, he was a waste.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:24am

How does that make sense? You say he is not good. I said he is as good as Waterman and there might be players better.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 9:34am

Then why do you have him ranked 12th on the team, behind 3 guys who very likely won't be in the rotation?

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:37am

RE: Then why do you have him ranked 12th on the team, behind 3 guys who very likely won't be in the rotation?

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 9:49am

Keita did not back up Carlson

Remigius

Sep 8, 11:53pm

You are right. edited. Fouss could win the #1 for 4th year. Keba is newer to the game and learning fast. Fouss has been

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 6:03am

Utah didn't use him right, imo. He shoulda left — if not to us — to someone else.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:00am

I think you may be underestimating

LifeLongLakerFan

Sep 9, 12:09am

Could be. Instead of who?

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 5:52am

Mag and Catchings. Those two can play three as well, so they'll get min there.

LifeLongLakerFan

Sep 9, 9:41am

I think Mag was primarily a 3 in the planning before Boskovic & Mboup even signed on. And making Catchings work at the 4

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 11:46am

If Mag and Catchings share the 3, then who among Demin, Hall, Baker, Saunders, Knell go to the bench?

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 3:45pm

Catchings I'm sure wants some time playing his eventual position of PF. But it's really not a winning slot for him yet.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 4:03pm

Your rotation is not impossible if Knell falls flat, which I doubt. But Baker will not see time at PG now that Demin &

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 4:16pm

If you want Baker's D to float for more than 15 min on our roster (& I think we both agree his offense needs

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 4:28pm

I don't recall saying they share the 3. I said they both CAN play the 3 as well.

LifeLongLakerFan

Sep 10, 11:10am

Good analysis, and I agree, BYU under-rated. Also think top 5 in B12, and

jaba166

Sep 9, 12:20am

Yes, Demin's intellectual and emotional maturity is off the charts. Expect big things from him on and off the court.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 7:38am

Top 5 draft pick! That's a big statement.

Lifer

Sep 9, 8:45am

Let's see how he plays out. Lots of basketball people see that as plausible. That he's smart and likable helps his case.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 8:56am

Mark this under "We'll have to wait and see."

Plantagenet

Sep 9, 10:20am

This is probably not the year to put BYU in the middle of the pack.

Plantagenet

Sep 9, 10:19am

Like what you’re saying but talented players need chemistry and time along with

44C

Sep 9, 10:54am

Yes, I agree. Winning 1 (or 2, or more) tourney games seems like really

jaba166

Sep 9, 8:31pm

#4 is wrong…Keita didn’t play behind Carlson, he played behind Lovering and as…

icecougar

Sep 9, 12:42am

Think you are undervaluing Boskovic

Projectoor

Sep 9, 5:20am

Good comments.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 6:18am

If Baker is the 2nd best player on the team we could do better than win a couple

Lifer

Sep 9, 6:57am

Those close to the program last year think Baker is a stronger player than anyone BYU lost from last year.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 8:53am

Can't wait to see him healthy! This team could be pretty special if it can jell

Lifer

Sep 9, 8:58am

Wow….Top 5….that’s definitely a 🌹 Rosey Scenario…I agree on Baker

44C

Sep 9, 6:50am

Biggest problem Mag will have is that both Keba and Fouss can’t shoot

JoeExotic

Sep 9, 7:10am

Defense still matters so I hope mag plays a lot

44C

Sep 9, 7:27am

This exactly. All the discussions about playing time are about individuals

runnincoug

Sep 9, 7:37am

Man it's going to be fun to watch how all of this plays out! So many options!

Lifer

Sep 9, 8:51am

no, you're 100% right. Knell is a pretty good defender, and better than Jax was

runnincoug

Sep 9, 9:13am

Fouss isn't as versatile as others, but saying he can't shoot is flat wrong

NYC and Japan

Sep 9, 9:51am

Fouss is extremely efficient ... in the paint. When people discuss his shooting

runnincoug

Sep 9, 9:55am

It's shorthand mainly for 3pt shooting, which Fouss takes too few of to be

Mitty

Sep 9, 10:01am

If he can’t hit the 3 at a decent clip I don’t consider him a shooter

JoeExotic

Sep 9, 11:14am

I’m seeing posts projecting top 5, even a top 3 finish in the B12. Get real!

DirtyWater

Sep 9, 7:43am

ok.. Top 2 it is baby

niqmadu

Sep 9, 1:49pm

This is 1 recruiting cycle for BYU. Kansas and Baylor have that sort of class

Thrill

Sep 9, 2:14pm

Fous is still the guy. I wish he were bigger, but he's just too good on offense.

cougargollum

Sep 9, 7:53am

He wasn't the starter or major minute guy last year. Why?

runnincoug

Sep 9, 8:17am

Healthy Fous will start.

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 8:21am

I believe he started until injured.

cougargollum

Sep 9, 8:50am

This is true.

PumaFanatico

Sep 9, 1:23pm

He is an undersized traditional 5 in a new game

Projectoor

Sep 9, 8:28am

I agree with most of that, but I don't think KY will fully run his ideal offense

cougargollum

Sep 9, 8:58am

KY doesn't have to "work with what he has". He's not a pauper w/ talent on team

runnincoug

Sep 9, 9:35am

You could be right, rosey. But I hope you're not. Cuz that rotation's defensively small & offensively has a low ceiling.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:06am

1 disagree with that, as I do almost every time you discuss athleticism and size.

roseyscenario

Sep 9, 9:37am

The key comes down to coaching & management, of course. Which isn't addressed in these tally/usage posts by us.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 9:40am

Is Baker really that good? In limited minutes last year he seemed more like a sixth-man scorer. I hope you're right.

cscougar

Sep 9, 9:40am

he was playing hurt.

HarlemCoug

Sep 9, 10:01am

Fair, but I didn't see elite shooting or athleticism, or above-average passing. I'm a little less convinced he'll be #2.

cscougar

Sep 9, 10:06am

You go watch his UCI highlights, you'll see elite shot creation and playmaking.

Mitty

Sep 9, 10:09am

I thought he looked great in his limited time. We SORELY needed his ball-handling, scoring & dynamic shooting. Too bad.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 10:10am

Yes, we did need that last year.

Plantagenet

Sep 9, 10:28am

He & a corn-fed Marcus was really JUST what we needed for personnel. Even if Marcus coulda given us only 15 min per.

SinkingQuffa

Sep 9, 10:31am

Well, unconnected fans like me don't know but besides people close to the

Mitty

Sep 9, 10:05am

U never saw him healthy. Pure speculation on what he will bring. He is better

Cougarbib

Sep 9, 11:51am

i refuse to believe Baker is that high on the actual list of whats going to

buckeyecougarguy

Sep 9, 10:23am

If Baker is our best player with all that talent we brought in...

smootharch

Sep 9, 10:42am

Or Baker is just that good when healthy.

Lifer

Sep 9, 10:47am

I suspect it would be more accurately stated "#1 scorer" rather than "#1 player"

Mitty

Sep 9, 11:29am

At this point, with so many unknowns, I'm excited to see all of them play

OldFogey

Sep 9, 10:51am

Am I reading then your projected starting 5 is:

Mitty

Sep 9, 11:25am

There are 5 potential Final 4 contenders in the B12 not including BYU.

ninja math

Sep 9, 8:54pm

Finishing 5th or 6th is a great stretch goal in my mind, and the ceiling for

Mitty

Sep 10, 9:52am

It's not all that young. Hall, Fouss, Keta, Mag, Saunders, Knell, Baker are all

LifeLongLakerFan

Sep 10, 11:14am

I play Cougar Fantasy basketball on Google Sheets with my family, have to choose

CaughtForaTouchdown

Sep 10, 9:42am

Love Fouss, but Baker is the better pick. How does it work if your player misses games?

roseyscenario

Sep 10, 9:47am

We can keep one player from year to year.

CaughtForaTouchdown

Sep 10, 10:01am

I'd pick Baker given that choice but there the injury risk with both so.....?

Posting on CougarBoard