Are people condemning him based off one season, or his whole body of work? If

Aug 2, 2024
10:23:23am

BYUtka Truly Addicted User

this was Kalani's second or third season, far fewer would be asking critical questions... But it isn't and there are legitimate concerns based on the many years we have seen.

Report problem with this ad

BYUtka

Previous username: yutka
Bio page: BYUtka
Joined: Aug 18, 2007
Last login: Sep 16, 2024
Total posts: 64,355 (2,140 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So it seems like a thing now to hate on Kalani? The negativity is exhausting.

Lcoug

Aug 2, 10:04am

It’s a vocal minority and it is exhausting

kC Cougar

Aug 2, 10:05am

and to have it before the season even starts is asinine.

ManicBlue

Aug 2, 10:06am

RE: and to have it before the season even starts is asinine.

Prickly Heat

Aug 2, 1:53pm

Remember 1 year ago when everyone was wanting to fire Pope?

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 10:10am

The vast majority of fans did not want to fire Pope. Also Kalani is not Pope.

tacallaway

Aug 2, 10:16am

Nobody expected UK to take Pope haha even after our awesome year. There were

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 10:18am

It was definitely unexpected and a reach by Kentucky

tacallaway

Aug 2, 10:22am

That's my point. 1 year can change everything. Pope would NOT have been

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 11:05am

But Pope had a much better resume coming into the B12 than Kalani.

tacallaway

Aug 2, 11:15am

Did he? Took 5th in the WCC. 0 ncaa tournament wins (still even now). Kalani

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 11:19am

Pope's best resume bullet for UK was winning the ncaa championship as a player

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 11:20am

.679 vs .598 win %

tacallaway

Aug 2, 11:33am

I'm just saying, let's see what happens. Stop piling on our own team/coach.

RGGeemer

Aug 2, 11:34am

I just want accountability. I'd love for Sitake to be successful.

tacallaway

Aug 2, 11:44am

Maybe we should have given Tuiaki a chance too

Huge Manatee

Aug 2, 10:10am

I'll admit I'm critical of Kalani but I want him to turn it around

CameronG

Aug 2, 10:17am

Nope. I want him gone.

DeepCCoug

Aug 2, 11:52am

Big Detmer fan? I mean this happened 7 years ago. Detmer seems to be in good

Lcoug

Aug 2, 12:00pm

BYU handled that issue extremely poorly. It was a bad mistake and they know it.

DeepCCoug

Aug 2, 12:05pm

I agree but my point is it was a long time ago. I’d let it go if it were me

Lcoug

Aug 2, 12:24pm

To each his own.

DeepCCoug

Aug 2, 12:55pm

Are people condemning him based off one season, or his whole body of work? If

BYUtka

Aug 2, 10:23am

He doesn't get me excited about BYU fotball. That is the litmus test for me

Croweater

Aug 2, 10:26am

That is a "you" problem then. Im so freaking excited for byu football to start!

viper

Aug 2, 1:40pm

Sure but 2020 and 2021 were great. The Big12 is a whole different beast and

Lcoug

Aug 2, 11:00am

I detest the hate but will defend the right of these silly folks to opine

WallaX2

Aug 2, 10:31am

I saw a lot of quit in last year's team, and that has to be on the HC and his

BlueFever

Aug 2, 10:52am

I can understand skepticism, but not the disrespect

Traveling Coug

Aug 2, 10:52am

What does calling TOs at the beginning of drives, quarters, or halves have to do

ldssdl

Aug 2, 11:06am

He’s certainly not perfect but I can find as many, if not more, positives to

Lcoug

Aug 2, 11:52am

I'm going to pretend I didn't just read that post

acadian8

Aug 2, 7:01pm

I see no posts hating on kalani

Deleted

Aug 2, 11:21am

RE: I see no posts hating on kalani

OldFogey

Aug 2, 11:37am

His past performance is not opinion or speculation. He wasn't good enough before

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 11:23am

If 2020 and 2021 finishes (in independence nonetheless) weren’t good enough then

Lcoug

Aug 2, 11:50am

If you think 2020 was at all predictive of the future, you're not looking at the

ldssdl

Aug 2, 12:36pm

So then what is acceptable. 2017 sucked. 23 was meh. 18, 19, 22 were average for

Lcoug

Aug 2, 1:09pm

CB was dying to get rid of Bronco by the end, who averaged 9 wins per season,

ldssdl

Aug 2, 1:34pm

There are only 4 other P4 schools who have been P4 schools for <2 years.

Lcoug

Aug 2, 1:40pm

Considering Holmoe pulled a rabbit out of his hat with Kevin Young, I don’t see

ldssdl

Aug 2, 3:17pm

KS has proven to only be as good as his coordinators.

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 12:57pm

Let’s dive into it then.

Lcoug

Aug 2, 1:10pm

He’s already been given more time than most college coaches get. It’s amazing

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 7:03pm

I've muted football here. The entitled fans are really annoying.

refunder

Aug 2, 11:56am

How did you find this post?

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 12:59pm

It shows on the front page of CB

refunder

Aug 2, 1:19pm

It’s not new. It’s more pronounced following an awful year

cajuncoug

Aug 2, 12:07pm

A lot of the "haters" are actually just BYU haters (AKA Yewts)

Brandoblueblood

Aug 2, 12:14pm

All the Ute fans I know hope Kalani stays here a long time.

tacallaway

Aug 2, 12:26pm

I'm sure they do.

DeepCCoug

Aug 2, 12:57pm

It's the KY comparison.

EDthoracotomy

Aug 2, 12:31pm

People see what they want to see. I can’t imagine living in such a negative spa

niqmadu

Aug 2, 12:39pm

It's really hot and humid living in a spa, but I'm doing the best I can.

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 1:01pm

on the other hand, maybe some cold therapy would be good for them

niqmadu

Aug 2, 1:17pm

I think that's true. I'm usually in a better mood when I'm not too hot.

here's to hoping

Aug 2, 2:27pm

Part of the cycle. As soon as BYU has a good year the same people will talk

AFitisemanu

Aug 2, 1:10pm

I've been ready to silence the football category because of it

BlueTemplar

Aug 2, 1:38pm

Couple more years? Haven’t we been saying that for 8 years now?

YbeatsU

Aug 2, 3:15pm

Par for the course on this board. Negativity

millar667

Aug 2, 3:17pm

RE: Par for the course on this board. Negativity

coventry94

Aug 2, 4:00pm

RE: Par for the course on this board. Negativity

OldFogey

Aug 2, 6:14pm

I wish I could agree

gurt

Aug 2, 4:57pm

I think this is a fair take. Now isn’t the time for him to go but it certainly

Lcoug

Aug 2, 6:43pm

Agreed. The season hasn't even started.

Big McLargeHuge

Aug 2, 10:59pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad