There's probably a good argument to be had about how much BYU's recruiting is the coaches fault vs P5 status

Aug 2, 2024
9:00:45am

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

But I'd point out that essentially no one from G5 gets top 50 recruiting results, and no recruits appeared to be interested in some of the Independence semantics people tried the last 13 years to claim we were a quasi-P5 team.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Aug 2, 2024 at 9:00:45am

Message modified by Indy Coug on Aug 2, 2024 at 9:01:45am

Message modified by Indy Coug on Aug 2, 2024 at 9:02:10am

Report problem with this ad

Indy Coug

Bio page: Indy Coug
Joined: Dec 20, 2001
Last login: Sep 8, 2024
Total posts: 187,266 (9,996 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I just find it astounding how little our results vs P5 teams changes over time

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

Aug 2, 8:46am

Sure, but until now they were stuck on the outside

Gustav

Aug 2, 8:48am

That's the theory....

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 8:49am

I would guess that the winning percentages of the P5 teams that we've played in the past have been higher than the

ManicBlue

Aug 2, 9:06am

Yep. Until our talent level & depth improve, those records won't change

RockyBalboa

Aug 2, 8:49am

Is there enough data in your models to break that out a bit?

Tokolosh

Aug 2, 8:50am

Here's my data: (*updated)

Spiff

Aug 2, 9:06am

Would be interesting to see home/road splits, too if you have it.

Abe Froman

Aug 2, 9:11am

If my filters are correct this is what I have:

Spiff

Aug 2, 9:57am

So Sitake’s record is as good as

deljdc

Aug 2, 9:25am

I think it says the opposite, no? He wins as much as the other coaches against

kos

Aug 2, 11:16am

I have that info (or very nearly that) for the last decade

krindorr

Aug 2, 12:26pm

Incredible data. CB needs a wake up call. Kalani doesn’t suck, we just play

macdizzle

Aug 2, 8:53am

Your back should get stronger as you put more weight on your shoulders

2FarGone

Aug 2, 8:55am

Unless your recruiting materially improves, I'm not sure banging your head against the wall more frequently

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 8:57am

There's probably a good argument to be had about how much BYU's recruiting is the coaches fault vs P5 status

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 9:00am

Right now, there's a real argument that BYU's 2025 recruiting is currently the worst in the P5

krindorr

Aug 2, 2:58pm

It's a conversation worth having a few months from now if things don't pick up

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 3:36pm

It’s not going to be a lot of fun if we can’t change that. It’s more fun

RobDog

Aug 2, 8:57am

Do you have the numbers against G5. Seems like recently we have lost a lot

RobDog

Aug 2, 9:02am

what is a P5 team in Lavell's numbers since that didn't exist back then?

byujag

Aug 2, 9:02am

He shouldn't because utah wasn't receiving P5 money or a P5 recruiting advantage. They weren't even a good G5 team then.

ManicBlue

Aug 2, 9:08am

I'm not arguing he should, I'm just trying to figure out how Indy calculated his numbers

byujag

Aug 2, 9:09am

Since 1972, BYU is the only non-P5 team to win the national championship

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 9:09am

So we should bring Crowton back?

TailgateU

Aug 2, 9:16am

That is astounding. Crazy to have the numbers be so close.

MyTwoCents

Aug 2, 9:39am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad