Yep. Until our talent level & depth improve, those records won't change

Aug 2, 2024
8:49:23am

RockyBalboa All-American

And improving the talent/depth in this new era of P4, NIL and endless transfers is going to be a constant challenge. Especially at BYU.

Report problem with this ad

RockyBalboa

Previous username: MesaCougar
Bio page: RockyBalboa
Joined: Apr 24, 2002
Last login: Sep 8, 2024
Total posts: 49,462 (1,489 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I just find it astounding how little our results vs P5 teams changes over time

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

Aug 2, 8:46am

Sure, but until now they were stuck on the outside

Gustav

Aug 2, 8:48am

That's the theory....

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 8:49am

I would guess that the winning percentages of the P5 teams that we've played in the past have been higher than the

ManicBlue

Aug 2, 9:06am

Yep. Until our talent level & depth improve, those records won't change

RockyBalboa

Aug 2, 8:49am

Is there enough data in your models to break that out a bit?

Tokolosh

Aug 2, 8:50am

Here's my data: (*updated)

Spiff

Aug 2, 9:06am

Would be interesting to see home/road splits, too if you have it.

Abe Froman

Aug 2, 9:11am

If my filters are correct this is what I have:

Spiff

Aug 2, 9:57am

So Sitake’s record is as good as

deljdc

Aug 2, 9:25am

I think it says the opposite, no? He wins as much as the other coaches against

kos

Aug 2, 11:16am

I have that info (or very nearly that) for the last decade

krindorr

Aug 2, 12:26pm

Incredible data. CB needs a wake up call. Kalani doesn’t suck, we just play

macdizzle

Aug 2, 8:53am

Your back should get stronger as you put more weight on your shoulders

2FarGone

Aug 2, 8:55am

Unless your recruiting materially improves, I'm not sure banging your head against the wall more frequently

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 8:57am

There's probably a good argument to be had about how much BYU's recruiting is the coaches fault vs P5 status

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 9:00am

Right now, there's a real argument that BYU's 2025 recruiting is currently the worst in the P5

krindorr

Aug 2, 2:58pm

It's a conversation worth having a few months from now if things don't pick up

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 3:36pm

It’s not going to be a lot of fun if we can’t change that. It’s more fun

RobDog

Aug 2, 8:57am

Do you have the numbers against G5. Seems like recently we have lost a lot

RobDog

Aug 2, 9:02am

what is a P5 team in Lavell's numbers since that didn't exist back then?

byujag

Aug 2, 9:02am

He shouldn't because utah wasn't receiving P5 money or a P5 recruiting advantage. They weren't even a good G5 team then.

ManicBlue

Aug 2, 9:08am

I'm not arguing he should, I'm just trying to figure out how Indy calculated his numbers

byujag

Aug 2, 9:09am

Since 1972, BYU is the only non-P5 team to win the national championship

Indy Coug

Aug 2, 9:09am

So we should bring Crowton back?

TailgateU

Aug 2, 9:16am

That is astounding. Crazy to have the numbers be so close.

MyTwoCents

Aug 2, 9:39am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad