I will grant you, that was not at all an insightful statement

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 2, 2024
11:03:51am

nova_coug_fan Playmaker

I will grant you, that was not at all an insightful statement

Report problem with this ad

nova_coug_fan

Bio page: nova_coug_fan
Joined: Jan 5, 2013
Last login: Jul 6, 2024
Total posts: 1,473 (3 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU's eleven 86+ rated players in the 2025 class are all graded as p4 caliber

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:18pm

How can anyone take that seriously?

Jul 1, 6:20pm

It’s all science. Trust science.

WallaX2

Jul 1, 6:24pm

Man, this debate gets old. The ratings are not always right, but are on average

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:31pm

Do you think they actually evaluate 600 players? Why have they inflated the

Jul 1, 6:34pm

You switched from differentiating between 85 and 88 to differentiating between

Belboz

Jul 1, 6:38pm

So what??

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:46pm

You wrote about 3 stars versus 4 stars as if that addressed something else

Belboz

Jul 1, 6:55pm

Ok, looking at ratings, here's an analysis

krindorr

Jul 1, 9:02pm

And that list doesn't distinguish between an 87 or 88

Belboz

Jul 2, 9:11am

Ratings are subjective.. but they're also really good indicators

krindorr

Jul 2, 10:14am

There's such a significant difference, that ranges are grouped in that report

Belboz

Jul 2, 10:25am

Thanks for your analysis- I don't understand the debate here

nova_coug_fan

Jul 2, 10:40am

The primary reason for debate is that the analysis doesn't say what we want it to

krindorr

Jul 2, 10:53am

Complete straw man

Jul 2, 11:16am

No, my only issue is when we pretend there a big difference between 86 and 87

Belboz

Jul 2, 5:55pm

You can’t. But it probably beats guys no other P4 offers

cajuncoug

Jul 1, 7:54pm

I love the thoughtful analysis evidenced in this statement:

lurKing5000

Jul 1, 10:21pm

I will grant you, that was not at all an insightful statement

nova_coug_fan

Jul 2, 11:03am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad