2017 is the “Godwin’s Law” of CougarBoard debates 🙄

Report problem with this ad

Jun 14, 2024
8:55:10am

andrewg3 All-American

Report problem with this ad

andrewg3

Previous username: Agarrett321
Bio page: andrewg3
Joined: Jul 19, 2016
Last login: Jul 2, 2024
Total posts: 3,780 (7 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

RE: From what has been said of spring ball. Yes, we will be very bad especially

YLife

Jun 13, 6:30pm

Dude, you have got to come to terms with reality. Our football is terrible. Kalani doesn’t even know what kind of cleats

Blue2thebone

Jun 13, 6:35pm

name doesn't really match

Zombre

Jun 13, 6:42pm

Actually, maybe it does. A true freind isn’t an enabler of destructive bad behavior of those they love.

Blue2thebone

Jun 13, 8:17pm

Give it a rest

Iki_Balam

Jun 13, 8:30pm

Great evaluation. 👎😂

nitestal

Jun 13, 8:21pm

RE: Dude, you have got to come to terms with reality. Our football is terrible.

OldFogey

Jun 13, 8:48pm

Why are you here and how many crotch punches do we get if you’re wrong?

Pretorian

Jun 14, 8:25am

RE: Dude, you have got to come to terms with reality. Our football is terrible.

Socrates Johnson

Jun 14, 9:06am

RE: From what has been said of spring ball. Yes, we will be very bad especially

pittsburghcoug

Jun 13, 6:36pm

FINALLY. Thanks.

Nodak Cougar

Jun 13, 6:43pm

Losing Rex doesn't really hurt. He was never the same after the injury.

WJCougar

Jun 13, 6:44pm

yeah, it sucks but injury just did him in, unfortunately. Barely made it 3 weeks with the Lions before being cut.

timpjynx

Jun 13, 6:52pm

Agreed. Love Rex, but he didn’t do anything special for us last year.

AZPTCOUG

Jun 13, 8:16pm

Sucks. That dude had such upside but crappy injuries just derailed his career.

IceBlue

Jun 14, 8:25am

RE: From what has been said of spring ball. Yes, we will be very bad especially

CopperLix

Jun 13, 6:51pm

Vegas and all the media have no clue. YLife is more reasonable and unbiased

stansburycoug

Jun 13, 6:52pm

Vegas is always wrong when it comes to BYU. They say 4-6 wins every year

andrewg3

Jun 13, 6:57pm

They had us at 5 wins last year. They ve nailed the last 2 years

stansburycoug

Jun 13, 6:58pm

Well that didn’t fit his narrative lol

Atmospheric_Cougar

Jun 13, 7:19pm

It completely fits my narrative. I said they have us at 4-6 wins every year.

andrewg3

Jun 14, 12:55am

They had us at 7.5 the year before so it really doesnt

stansburycoug

Jun 14, 6:12am

2017 is the “Godwin’s Law” of CougarBoard debates 🙄

andrewg3

Jun 14, 8:55am

If Vegas were always consistently wrong on BYU in the same direction

krindorr

Jun 15, 7:54am

RE: Vegas and all the media have no clue. YLife is more reasonable and unbiased

YLife

Jun 13, 7:16pm

Vegas doesnt lose money

stansburycoug

Jun 13, 8:07pm

Vegas’ goal isn’t to be correct but to have even betting on both sides so they always come out on top

22jrob22

Jun 14, 12:04am

The team was so much better in their last two games that I have hope

Belboz

Jun 13, 7:26pm

"The signs are there"...what are some of those signs?

icecougar

Jun 13, 7:05pm

There are too many experienced receivers on the team for a freshman RM to play

Belboz

Jun 13, 7:19pm

Agreed. JoJo could surprise tho

puntersarepeople

Jun 13, 7:21pm

Yes. He's far more likely to make an impact

Belboz

Jun 13, 7:25pm

Not a bad take and certainly not ridiculous. Doesn't make it right

cajuncoug

Jun 13, 7:25pm

Some of these comments are actually yewt fans posing as one of us.

Brandoblueblood

Jun 13, 7:29pm

The O-line was so bad last year. Upgrade that and the QB will be much better

Groym

Jun 13, 7:31pm

Everything you've said is in the realm of possibility

krindorr

Jun 13, 7:39pm

Excellent summary

cajuncoug

Jun 13, 7:59pm

Think your quibbles are reasonable; here's my logic, mostly comes down to...

krindorr

Jun 13, 8:39pm

Good stuff--only responding again b/c I'm enjoyng this exchange

cajuncoug

Jun 13, 9:00pm

if our lines are worse than last year, the team is in horrific shape

claw

Jun 13, 8:52pm

I don't think they will be (or can be)...but from a player talent perspective,

krindorr

Jun 13, 8:56pm

One thing that you are forgetting.

kC Cougar

Jun 14, 8:16am

Yeah, this is just comparing players from one year to the next

krindorr

Jun 14, 8:38am

The buzz for BYU is so bad, that outside people are picking us to

Plantagenet

Jun 14, 9:40am

We'll be incrementally better this year. We won't be worse.

Plantagenet

Jun 14, 9:37am

RE: Everything you've said is in the realm of possibility

DirtyWater

Jun 14, 10:24am

Ylife keep it up!

Royalblueglasses

Jun 13, 7:55pm

BYU is projected to win 4.5 games by Vegas

Dr T-bone

Jun 13, 8:35pm

Disagree on 1 point re: the schedule

cajuncoug

Jun 13, 9:29pm

Vegas was right on 4.5 O/U last season. Thinking they're right again this season

Forzaitalia

Jun 14, 9:00am

At least they're flying around the field.

Real Men Wear Blue

Jun 13, 9:19pm

Every preseason publication says the opposite. But, ya know

rmarkerm

Jun 13, 9:48pm

8 wins guaranteed. And a win over Utah

bookofdaniel

Jun 13, 9:51pm

"I believe!" like in a "Man's Search for Happiness" kinda way!

jaba166

Jun 13, 11:52pm

If we win 8 games I’ll send you 100$

gurt

Jun 14, 12:27am

Bookmarked

CopperLix

Jun 14, 11:30am

I am generally on the more pessimistic side of byu football but for some unknown

Blew

Jun 14, 2:09am

I see 5 wins. If BYU makes a bowl, I'll be shocked. Shcedule is very tough. I

PhilPete

Jun 14, 7:53am

Phillips and Hagen had more than 2 stars.

porl thompson

Jun 14, 8:00am

RE: From what has been said of spring ball. Yes, we will be very bad especially

GMGlenn

Jun 14, 8:25am

I didn't love the Funk hire either, but movement is norm for position coaches

krindorr

Jun 14, 8:52am

RE: I didn't love the Funk hire either, but movement is norm for position

GMGlenn

Jun 14, 10:37am

BYU will do nothing in Big XII Football until they increase their recruiting

Diablo and Doc

Jun 14, 9:03am

Maybe a change in recruiting philosophy is needed

GMGlenn

Jun 14, 10:47am

Defensive recruiting has been night and day different since Hill got here

stansburycoug

Jun 14, 10:57am

You are not serious

NacoCoug

Jun 14, 9:29am

Great write-up...thanks

UTAHCANE

Jun 14, 9:39am

I like your optimism but QB is the most important position. I’m worried

ColonelMustard

Jun 14, 9:42am

As we all should be

WJCougar

Jun 14, 11:27am

We are objectively worse

AFcoug7

Jun 14, 10:03am

If you're that sure, then should be easy money for you in Vegas.

ldssdl

Jun 14, 12:46pm

Thanks for the glass half full perspective

Traveling Coug

Jun 14, 1:03pm

Wait and see approach? Are you saying the past 7 years aren't valid data points?

Posting on CougarBoard