My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Dec 3, 2023
1:47
:53
pm
ABCoug
All-American
^This - the criteria has always been rediculas
FSU didnt complain then, this was so predictable.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
ABCoug
Bio page
ABCoug
Joined
Mar 16, 2003
Last login
Sep 7, 2024
Total posts
15,743 (4 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Statement from FSU AD
Adam_Pontipee
12/3/23 10:52am
It's only damaged today because FSU didn't get what they wanted....
WJCougar
12/3/23 10:53am
He's right. Their QB went down but they still won games because of their Defense
jrifkin48
12/3/23 11:46am
And FSU has been just fine with that....until today.
WJCougar
12/3/23 11:49am
That’s the very purpose of a committee.
eyebleedblu
12/3/23 12:15pm
^This - the criteria has always been rediculas
ABCoug
12/3/23 1:47pm
Dang that's pretty scathing
Kajdin
12/3/23 10:53am
Did he issue the same statement supporting ucf a few years ago. Or what about
cougarfann888
12/3/23 10:53am
He said P5…this isn’t hard
ordinary tri guy
12/3/23 10:55am
Ok and someone else said sec. It's the exact same argument
cougarfann888
12/3/23 10:57am
Sec>acc> non p5 that's not hard to understand either
cougarfann888
12/3/23 10:57am
Probably true, but that's subjective.
Loyal2Royal
12/3/23 11:26am
Agree but there is irony of a blue blood making this argument now.
cougarfann888
12/3/23 11:33am
I have no sympathy for FSU, but it doesn't bode well for BYU.
NumbersGuy
12/3/23 1:06pm
We are going to a 12 team playoff next year
Hutch65
12/3/23 1:18pm
But what if we're 12-1 or 11-2 with a CCG loss, does that mean we'll get left out for a 9-3 SEC team?
krindorr
12/3/23 1:29pm
I would probably expect to be left out
Hutch65
12/3/23 1:30pm
no it’s not. there’s hundreds of games that decide it. G5 is closer to FCS than P5. Michigan had just as easy a schedule
FieroCoug
12/3/23 4:29pm
That shows you don't know what you are talking about. I almost guarentee
cougarfann888
12/3/23 5:05pm
G5 used to be closer but not anymore. in the strength ratings that include fcs teams, fcs teams make it higher up in the
FieroCoug
12/3/23 5:12pm
in sagarin there are 18 FCS schools in the top 130. in fact the highest fcs is higher than the highest G5.
FieroCoug
12/3/23 5:15pm
And Sagarin rankings suck. They are entirely point-based
BYUDM93
12/3/23 8:21pm
<< Deleted >>
Jcaps
12/3/23 12:16pm
I agree except we are talking about a
HonestTakes
12/3/23 12:19pm
Except the acc was a weak p5 this year. As was the pac. But uw beat a strong uo
BYU '80
12/3/23 2:37pm
There were only two conferences with winning OOC records vs other P5s. And those were the ACC and the PAC
krindorr
12/3/23 2:52pm
And that is a worthless stat. What were the matchups?
BYU '80
12/3/23 2:57pm
Frankly, if you're looking for good OOC wins, there's really only 3
krindorr
12/3/23 3:05pm
According to Sagarin, he actually has the PAC as the STRONGEST conference
krindorr
12/3/23 3:08pm
Umm. No. That PAC narrative does not reflect the reality of this season. All of
BYUDM93
12/3/23 8:27pm
Signed Cincinnati. Also signed all of the G5s who have won a ny6 over a p5
BYU '80
12/3/23 2:36pm
RE: Sec>acc> non p5 that's not hard to understand either
Mormons4Coffee
12/3/23 3:42pm
FSU unfortunately isnt P2 though, which is more important than P5
ABCoug
12/3/23 1:49pm
Agree 100%
displacedute
12/3/23 10:53am
I agree 100% with everything he said.
Duke Silver
12/3/23 10:53am
I’ve never really liked them, but they’ve been hosed.
Nittany Cougar
12/3/23 10:54am
Good write up and I agree FSU was robbed.
ADK
12/3/23 10:54am
They were never going to leave out the sec. FSU isn’t the same without the qb
BYU '80
12/3/23 2:38pm
fsu still beat a top 15 team by 10, in bad weather, with a 3rd string freshman QB. FSU is a dang good team. not just QB
FieroCoug
12/3/23 4:30pm
Unfortunately for them the sample size was too small with backup QB
ABCoug
12/3/23 5:09pm
So true and so frustrating. Why even play a regular season?
ordinary tri guy
12/3/23 10:55am
Wouldn’t it be funny if they found a judge willing to issue an injunction and
blueaussie
12/3/23 10:55am
Maybe they could organize a rally and storm the stadium
ryebrye
12/3/23 11:26am
He's not wrong
Born2Fish
12/3/23 10:55am
Hard to disagree with that
CPAcoug87
12/3/23 10:55am
Well they are, but that’s impossible to do with unbalanced schedules
PHXSUNS31
12/3/23 10:57am
He’s right, but we already knew college football was broken..the fix is coming
PHXSUNS31
12/3/23 10:55am
FSU is playing Georgia…beat them and they can have an argument.
IGlowInTheDark
12/3/23 10:57am
Yeah, except Georgia is better than Alabama
krindorr
12/3/23 1:06pm
Because 24 is better than 27?
Florwood
12/3/23 1:44pm
I was under the impression we were ignoring H2H and on-field play and just going with what we think
krindorr
12/3/23 3:11pm
I love this. Great to see a blue blood reap and feel their own medicine used
Crowd Factor
12/3/23 10:57am
EXACTLY!
Idacoug
12/3/23 3:52pm
It's a travesty that an undefeated team is locked out from being able to compete
cougarfan84
12/3/23 10:57am
I don’t have a lot of sympathy. The ACC helped build the system, then their
Sircumference
12/3/23 11:27am
You don't have to have sympathy, but the statement is true.
sah22
12/3/23 11:33am
Well said
EDthoracotomy
12/3/23 11:29am
I love watching blue bloods become victim to their own monster.
EDthoracotomy
12/3/23 11:30am
This is the beginning of the end of the ACC
runningryan
12/3/23 11:36am
Let the scramble begin
EDthoracotomy
12/3/23 11:42am
I feel the same way about FSU as I do about WSU and OSU getting screwed by the
Emmett Fitz-Hume
12/3/23 11:37am
P5 just went to P2. Welcome to the outsiders club
davidmj10
12/3/23 11:42am
Also I agree with what he said.
davidmj10
12/3/23 11:46am
These people fed the monster. Can't complain when it eats 'em.
KCFan85
12/3/23 11:52am
They have every right to be very, very upset. And they know a bit now what
Mitty
12/3/23 12:09pm
Cry me a river. None of these complaints by blue blood schools engender any sympathy at all. They created this
YIsForBrigham
12/3/23 12:14pm
I’m just frustrated it isn’t the SEC on the outside looking in.
davidmj10
12/3/23 12:15pm
Yeah could have gone with FSU over Bama But the ACC did oppose the 12 team CFP
wildwilderness
12/3/23 12:18pm
I didn’t know that. So it is just karma for them.
davidmj10
12/3/23 12:22pm
I actually agree with much of that. Problem is there are four spots.
All-American
12/3/23 12:40pm
They have spent decades trying to keep teams out, now they know how it feels.
slatecoug
12/3/23 12:50pm
Boo hoo
Turd Ferguson
12/3/23 12:50pm
Cry me a river…you reap what you sow.
AlternateShot
12/3/23 1:25pm
He’s right
zerome4sooners
12/3/23 1:32pm
Next year’s playoff fixes all that.
canofpicante
12/3/23 2:17pm
My unpopular opinion
Happy As Larry
12/3/23 2:25pm
Unforgivable is a bit over the top. An acknowledgment of the difficulty
BYU '80
12/3/23 2:33pm
an undefeated team left out is very questionable.
Count Cougar
12/3/23 2:35pm
RE: Statement from FSU AD
Ikuna
12/3/23 2:49pm
Well argued. As a spectator, I'd still rather watch the 4 that made the playoff.
Forzaitalia
12/3/23 3:02pm
Playoff of 2 SEC teams and 2 B1G teams.
ParentingNotForSissy
12/3/23 3:47pm
Boo hoo. You made your own bed. Lie in it.
Idacoug
12/3/23 3:50pm
FSU helped build the current stupid system, and now they are victims of it.
Junior Deputy
12/3/23 5:17pm
Where were they during the BCS years?
Robert Baratheon
12/3/23 8:11pm
Doesnt persuade me. Everyone in the playoff beat a playoff worthy team. FSU
cougsareforreal
12/4/23 6:36am
FSU played two ranked teams, same as Michigan
krindorr
12/4/23 6:49am
You’re right, I spaced on LSU. Every team in the playoff has a win
cougsareforreal
12/4/23 7:06am
This is a true statement even years ago.
First-n-10
12/4/23 8:44am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad