This game just happened 3 days ago and i just saw this video clip earlier today,

Report problem with this ad

Sep 5, 2023
10:48:34pm

robin All-American

so it feels like talking about this right now is more relevant than games that happened 4 years ago.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 5, 2023 at 10:48:34pm

Message modified by robin on Sep 5, 2023 at 10:48:49pm

Report problem with this ad

robin

Bio page: robin
Joined: Apr 21, 2002
Last login: Nov 18, 2024
Total posts: 4,731 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

from this frame, it looks like Robinson's 2nd int is at least partially touching

robin

9/5/23 8:30pm

From the stadium cameras it felt like everyone knew it touched the ground

Julius Pepperwood

9/5/23 8:34pm

Replay refs had to only use the game feed cameras. It's a flaw in the system.

rcbyufan

9/5/23 8:44pm

Yes, but that feed wasn't available to the replay officials. They didn't get a

cougarfan84

9/5/23 10:29pm

But the stadium cameras aren't used on review. Only the TV Cameras are

crimedog

9/5/23 8:34pm

Bad call by ref, bad camera work by Fox allowed it to stand

HuskerFan2

9/5/23 8:35pm

Honestly, when you watch this at live speed it is really hard to see it hit the

robin

9/5/23 8:46pm

What's your angle here? It didn't change the outcome, the best you can come up

Corn Pop

9/5/23 8:56pm

There was a lot of discussion (at least on Saturday) about whether this was a

robin

9/5/23 9:04pm

But yet you keep proclaiming it a bad call while having yet to produce the

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:09pm

I don't think it was a bad call based on what the refs saw or what video they

robin

9/5/23 9:39pm

And did you really write, "confirm that it looks like"?

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:11pm

I did, not sure why that bothers you.

robin

9/5/23 9:40pm

Just pointing out the contradiction of definitively proclaiming the call bad

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:49pm

Yep, it absolutely might have been

dratax

9/5/23 9:51pm

Sorry, but I don't agree with you that using the term "looks like" is a

robin

9/5/23 10:02pm

No. No, the replay ref is not, or at least he's not supposed to given his strict

Corn Pop

9/5/23 10:19pm

Why aren't you talking about any of the bad calls from 2019?

ochobeeguy

9/5/23 10:30pm

This game just happened 3 days ago and i just saw this video clip earlier today,

robin

9/5/23 10:48pm

There is no "just 3 days ago". Statute of limitations is 48 hours at most.

ochobeeguy

9/6/23 10:46am

Refs make mistakes. You just hope they break even.

ImuaKahuku

9/5/23 10:15pm

Like the PI by BYU DB.. not even close to a PI……. Refs suck sometimes!

BYU4eVeR

9/5/23 10:22pm

RE: from this frame, it looks like Robinson's 2nd int is at least partially

thewaterboy

9/5/23 8:35pm

More like it’s at least partially touching his hand. Wasn’t close to a catch.

Metallicat

9/5/23 8:36pm

His hand was under it.

Thrill

9/5/23 8:36pm

That's what I'm going to say–I didn't see the big screen (photos are deceptive).

Benfica1

9/5/23 8:38pm

I think it could have been. Can totally see his hand "visually" under the ball.

BleedCougarBlue2

9/5/23 8:44pm

RE: His hand was under it.

BlueToTheBone

9/5/23 9:05pm

Fixed it for you:

byubyu

9/5/23 8:36pm

Is this you?

robin

9/5/23 8:38pm

It was a bad initial call that couldn't be overturned by the cut off video.

Mister P

9/5/23 8:36pm

The thing is, you inserted "it looks like" in your sentence. Irrefutable is the

Corn Pop

9/5/23 8:38pm

Looks like his hand is under it to me

YIsForBrigham

9/5/23 8:40pm

If the teams were reversed and sam Houston was intercepting, would it be an int?

Spaniard

9/5/23 8:50pm

Yes because the refs+replay crew made the decision and I don’t think they take

Crowd Factor

9/5/23 8:55pm

Yes. Whatever the call on the field was would have stood. You simply could

HairyCougar

9/5/23 9:18pm

No it was not an interception and was a bad call by the refs and the officating

johnnybyu

9/5/23 10:26pm

I need a bigger screen to see it on

PogiCoug

9/5/23 9:36pm

You don’t say 😂

canofpicante

9/5/23 10:04pm

I think it hit the ground, but that's not conclusive to me.

Jingleheimer

9/6/23 5:37am

Maybe 7/10 times the call gets reversed if the ref sees that angle, but I don't

momowagon

9/6/23 10:36am

Ball is allowed to touch the ground if the receiver has control first

akbarishiwatsu

9/6/23 10:26am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad