But yet you keep proclaiming it a bad call while having yet to produce the

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 5, 2023
9:09:52pm

Corn Pop Intervention Needed

But yet you keep proclaiming it a bad call while having yet to produce the

irrefutable evidence that it was. So what's your angle here? Did you argue in the moment that it wasn't an int, get shouted down, and now want validation?

It is what it is. It's not the first 50-50 call of the season that lacks irrefutable video evidence either way, and it won't be the last.

Report problem with this ad

Corn Pop

Previous username: BigCornThunder
New username: Ghost of Peanut
Bio page: Corn Pop
Joined: Jan 26, 2009
Last login: Nov 8, 2024
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

from this frame, it looks like Robinson's 2nd int is at least partially touching

robin

9/5/23 8:30pm

From the stadium cameras it felt like everyone knew it touched the ground

Julius Pepperwood

9/5/23 8:34pm

Replay refs had to only use the game feed cameras. It's a flaw in the system.

rcbyufan

9/5/23 8:44pm

Yes, but that feed wasn't available to the replay officials. They didn't get a

cougarfan84

9/5/23 10:29pm

But the stadium cameras aren't used on review. Only the TV Cameras are

crimedog

9/5/23 8:34pm

Bad call by ref, bad camera work by Fox allowed it to stand

HuskerFan2

9/5/23 8:35pm

Honestly, when you watch this at live speed it is really hard to see it hit the

robin

9/5/23 8:46pm

What's your angle here? It didn't change the outcome, the best you can come up

Corn Pop

9/5/23 8:56pm

There was a lot of discussion (at least on Saturday) about whether this was a

robin

9/5/23 9:04pm

But yet you keep proclaiming it a bad call while having yet to produce the

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:09pm

I don't think it was a bad call based on what the refs saw or what video they

robin

9/5/23 9:39pm

And did you really write, "confirm that it looks like"?

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:11pm

I did, not sure why that bothers you.

robin

9/5/23 9:40pm

Just pointing out the contradiction of definitively proclaiming the call bad

Corn Pop

9/5/23 9:49pm

Yep, it absolutely might have been

dratax

9/5/23 9:51pm

Sorry, but I don't agree with you that using the term "looks like" is a

robin

9/5/23 10:02pm

No. No, the replay ref is not, or at least he's not supposed to given his strict

Corn Pop

9/5/23 10:19pm

Why aren't you talking about any of the bad calls from 2019?

ochobeeguy

9/5/23 10:30pm

This game just happened 3 days ago and i just saw this video clip earlier today,

robin

9/5/23 10:48pm

There is no "just 3 days ago". Statute of limitations is 48 hours at most.

ochobeeguy

9/6/23 10:46am

Refs make mistakes. You just hope they break even.

ImuaKahuku

9/5/23 10:15pm

Like the PI by BYU DB.. not even close to a PI……. Refs suck sometimes!

BYU4eVeR

9/5/23 10:22pm

RE: from this frame, it looks like Robinson's 2nd int is at least partially

thewaterboy

9/5/23 8:35pm

More like it’s at least partially touching his hand. Wasn’t close to a catch.

Metallicat

9/5/23 8:36pm

His hand was under it.

Thrill

9/5/23 8:36pm

That's what I'm going to say–I didn't see the big screen (photos are deceptive).

Benfica1

9/5/23 8:38pm

I think it could have been. Can totally see his hand "visually" under the ball.

BleedCougarBlue2

9/5/23 8:44pm

RE: His hand was under it.

BlueToTheBone

9/5/23 9:05pm

Fixed it for you:

byubyu

9/5/23 8:36pm

Is this you?

robin

9/5/23 8:38pm

It was a bad initial call that couldn't be overturned by the cut off video.

Mister P

9/5/23 8:36pm

The thing is, you inserted "it looks like" in your sentence. Irrefutable is the

Corn Pop

9/5/23 8:38pm

Looks like his hand is under it to me

9/5/23 8:40pm

If the teams were reversed and sam Houston was intercepting, would it be an int?

Spaniard

9/5/23 8:50pm

Yes because the refs+replay crew made the decision and I don’t think they take

9/5/23 8:55pm

Yes. Whatever the call on the field was would have stood. You simply could

HairyCougar

9/5/23 9:18pm

No it was not an interception and was a bad call by the refs and the officating

johnnybyu

9/5/23 10:26pm

I need a bigger screen to see it on

PogiCoug

9/5/23 9:36pm

You don’t say 😂

canofpicante

9/5/23 10:04pm

I think it hit the ground, but that's not conclusive to me.

Jingleheimer

9/6/23 5:37am

Maybe 7/10 times the call gets reversed if the ref sees that angle, but I don't

momowagon

9/6/23 10:36am

Ball is allowed to touch the ground if the receiver has control first

9/6/23 10:26am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad