That seems even more offensive, until I realized that "Redhawk" is a totally

Mar 28, 2025
1:07:07pm

RoboKayne Contributor

different mascot and not just another way to refer to Native Americans.

To be fair, the animal is called a "Red-Tailed Hawk".

Report problem with this ad

RoboKayne

Bio page: RoboKayne
Joined: Feb 22, 2024
Last login: Apr 12, 2025
Total posts: 1,297 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

My flaming hot take is that college sports fans should cheer for the college where they went to school

TCuz Coastal Elite

Mar 28, 12:48pm

I disagree to some degree. Religion is part of it. If you’re catholic and a

Viva Campeche

Mar 28, 12:50pm

Interesting you brought up Notre Dame cause I don’t agree there at all.

TCuz

Mar 28, 12:51pm

I posted below, and disagree with you on ND.

jdub

Mar 28, 12:54pm

What if I went to Notre Dame and actively cheer against them? Bonus points?

TheLoanArranger

Mar 28, 12:58pm

I also think that if you just grew up rooting for a team (not because they were

Waluigi

Mar 28, 12:54pm

I disagree on the religion connection when it comes to sports. I don't like

RealSimsShadY

Mar 28, 1:26pm

Shouldn’t be the only reason, but it’s fine if it’s get someone interested imo

Viva Campeche

Mar 28, 5:29pm

Disagree.

Busting Coveys

Mar 28, 12:51pm

Agree. I don't really understand cheering for a school you have no connection to

chrisoc13

Mar 28, 12:51pm

I have a connection to BYU even if I didn’t attend the school. From 79-84 I went to every holiday bowl. My dad has had

Busting Coveys

Mar 28, 1:06pm

Good point. I allow connections. And always for BYU. Never for Duke.

chrisoc13

Mar 28, 1:09pm

what about people who grew up a fan of that school but

Beggar

Mar 28, 12:51pm

Mostly agree, but if you grew up next to a university, say your dad worked there

ldssdl

Mar 28, 12:52pm

I think BYU has an expanded "we" that is unique, which can include members of the church.

jdub

Mar 28, 12:53pm

I don't really care who people root for or why they root for them.

byujacob

Mar 28, 12:54pm

I do. I am the fandom police. 🚨🚔🚨

TCuz

Mar 28, 12:56pm

Right, why worry about sticking a square peg in a round hole?

Belboz

Mar 28, 12:57pm

You can't or your yankees fandom would cause you to spontaneously combust.

shimmy

Mar 28, 12:58pm

My parents went to BYU. I didn't go to college. Am I cool to cheer for them or

CougarTwins

Mar 28, 12:54pm

You should keep your rooting energies focused on the high school you attended.

garyfan

Mar 28, 12:57pm

not after they went woke and changed from Braves to Redhawks.

CougarTwins

Mar 28, 12:59pm

That seems even more offensive, until I realized that "Redhawk" is a totally

RoboKayne

Mar 28, 1:07pm

Sure, but an even hotter take is that one should not cheer against the school you attend.

Sea Chicken

Mar 28, 12:54pm

RE: Sue, but an even hotter take is that one should not cheer against the school

Belboz

Mar 28, 12:56pm

Unless you went to Utah.

paulb

Mar 28, 12:57pm

RE: Unless you went to Utah.

Belboz

Mar 28, 12:58pm

I cheer against ND. I was an MBA student there, not an athlete.

TheLoanArranger

Mar 28, 12:59pm

Free Ride? You are referring to their place in the broader CFB pecking order?

RoboKayne

Mar 28, 1:12pm

I did my MBA there and I cheer for them, if only casually

Himni

Mar 28, 1:20pm

That can be okay though. My little brother grew up a BYU fan, but ended up at

RealSimsShadY

Mar 28, 1:31pm

Completely disagree. A ton of people grow up rooting for a team because of

ATX

Mar 28, 12:54pm

As did I, and then I honored my father and mother by attending their alma mater.

TCuz

Mar 28, 12:57pm

Circumstances don’t always allow that. It doesn’t mean you should drop your team

ATX

Mar 28, 12:59pm

and if your parents had attended Utah...?

maxpowers

Mar 28, 1:25pm

They’d probably be serial killers in that universe.

TCuz

Mar 28, 1:33pm

RE: Completely disagree. A ton of people grow up rooting for a team because of

joelvandyne

Mar 28, 1:26pm

Not applicable but thanks

ATX

Mar 28, 1:48pm

I'm tired of pronoun concerns, but I always use they/them when referring to BYU

Belboz

Mar 28, 12:55pm

I would rather use the pronoun "werf", but that has not gotten any traction.

RoboKayne

Mar 28, 1:03pm

So you think that 2 years of being at a school should make me stop cheering for

cougaman

Mar 28, 1:01pm

Root for whoever you want within reason (rooting for Duke if you're not from Durham or went there is evil) but I think

shimmy

Mar 28, 1:02pm

I have never set foot on the campus of my undergraduate degree

BYUFam1

Mar 28, 1:07pm

People who have not attended college don't get to be fans?

JimmyZ

Mar 28, 1:13pm

Lesser fans or something like that. It’s a half-baked take. We are workshopping it.

TCuz

Mar 28, 1:16pm

You mean you came up with it while you were half baked

ATX

Mar 28, 1:20pm

What about current or retired employees of said school?

JohnnyC

Mar 28, 1:20pm

Mostly agree in general with 3 caveats:

RoboKayne

Mar 28, 1:29pm

"So you're a wildcat because...your ALMOST brother...ALMOST went to Kentucky..."

picklethins

Mar 28, 1:54pm

Good thing I have one whole semester at BYU…

Penske Material

Mar 28, 2:05pm

We should all be big tent BYU fans and welcome any and all bandwagon types.

SaturdaySpecialDay

Mar 28, 4:09pm

What about cheering for the sports teams that are funded by my church I pay tithing to? Can I do that?

RdF3

Mar 28, 4:44pm

Yale is not very fun to cheer for in sports

Posting on CougarBoard