No, he does not deserve all the criticism he gets.

Report problem with this ad

Oct 13, 2024
10:24:26am

kccougar VABL

No, he does not deserve all the criticism he gets.

Report problem with this ad

kccougar

Bio page: kccougar
Joined: May 29, 2001
Last login: Oct 13, 2024
Total posts: 90,918 (15,591 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Where Are All The Kalani Haters Now?

CHUNKman

9:56am

Look, he deserved all the criticism he got. He also deserves a ton of credit

maxpowers

9:57am

He didn’t deserve for people to forget 2020 and 2021, but this season is proving those seasons weren’t a mirage.

The 435

9:59am

I agree with 2021–although iirc that was when the focus started to turn

10:08am

This is a great misconception

canuckchuck

11:51am

2021 defensively was horrible. Look at the stats. Offense was historic great.

Frankfromtheballpark

12:00pm

And yet the same people who wanted Tuiaki fired in 2021 wanted ARod fired in

2:00pm

By all objectionable metrics, Kalani has proven to only be mediocre as a HC

Frankfromtheballpark

4:16pm

Tons of funny stuff in here, but the Grimes part might be the best

bluescholar

4:19pm

No this season is proving that he should have fired Tuiaki years earlier

2:54pm

He deserved criticism for losing games, however he did not deserve much of the

Polecat

10:00am

No, he does not deserve all the criticism he gets.

kccougar

10:24am

You had me until decade of mediocrity

canuckchuck

11:48am

I’m giving him credit. He hired Jay Hill that is Big! One of the great hires in

44C

3:00pm

I was/am a Kalani doubter. He is doing fantastic this year. I will forgive an inevitable let down.

shimmy

9:58am

He fired them already

Don_Juan_El_Guapo

9:58am

Still here, hoping we don't lose Jay Hill who orchestrated this turn around

Mitty

9:59am

Yup. This is all about Jay Hill.

BYUnerd

10:00am

Do you mean the guy he added to the coaching staff?

juntao25

1:03pm

5 years too late? YEAH, that guy.

JupiterJones

1:10pm

Who hired TJ Woods and the consultants the team is utilizing? And the new S&C

Polecat

10:03am

You can't blame a guy for hiring one person and not credit him for hiring

SUAVO

10:03am

But you can blame him for holding on to his Buddy and tanking the D for 5 years too long

byuTX

10:05am

Exactly, so if you blame him for that you have to credit him for all the good

SUAVO

10:13am

Correct. Which we do. Good DC hire for sure

byuTX

10:18am

OL coach has been just as important of a hire. Has turned some Olineman around

SUAVO

10:20am

Too bad he hired a disaster OL coach before the current OL coach

byuTX

10:21am

You know why Funk was hired?

Zombre

10:31am

Blame for the bad and credit for the good

SUAVO

10:33am

Correct

byuTX

10:35am

Of course then you’d have to explain your definition of tank because the

Polecat

10:16am

Tank the program from where it was. Even sitake knows he messed up. Or do you disagree with his decision to fire Tuiaki?

byuTX

10:19am

You just said the defense tanked for 5 seasons. I responded with a remark

Polecat

10:30am

Ok thanks. You know what I meant. The D underperformed & Tuiaki needed to go. Surprised you disagree with Sitake’s move

byuTX

10:36am

Kalani is a CEO. He gets credit for his staff.

shimmy

10:06am

Who hired Hill?

Incentivize

10:54am

Tell of you know nothing about a football program without telling us.

4:13pm

Amen. A lot of haters on this board. He’s been great and he has my full support

elmerfudd

9:59am

Don’t think there are many actual haters. Most fans with concerns about Kalani

bluesloth

10:06am

There seemed to be a fair amount that didn't want him to succeed so they could

SUAVO

10:15am

There were none of those

byuTX

10:37am

There was one, and he’s literally blind. I’d prefer to have a couple bad seasons and restart than be stuck in perpetual

shimmy

11:05am

There was definitely more than one. Quite a few would, like yourself, didn't

SUAVO

12:09pm

You’re freaking crazy if you thought I wasn’t cheering for Kalani and would rather have had a horrible season. That’s

shimmy

3:56pm

You just posted that. "I'd prefer to have a couple bad seasons and start over

SUAVO

4:03pm

Nobody wants KS not to SUCCEED. We want him not to SUCK.

Mitty

1:21pm

There were plenty in the spring/summer who were just fine seeing this season

SUAVO

1:24pm

Winning cures all, but when the team has lost there have been flat out mean

Polecat

10:20am

This

2:55pm

BYU isn’t even fully “resourced” yet for the P4…

NorCal_Coug

10:42am

I’ve never hated him

byukarl

10:48am

Kalani has changed intensity level/focus & hired Hill. Kudos. I'm loving this

Forzaitalia

11:41am

RE: Where Are All The Kalani Haters Now?

rtl

12:24pm

His biggest criticism is and has always been his failure to fire Tuiaki.

m_beav

1:03pm

RE: Where Are All The Kalani Haters Now?

DrewGundy

1:12pm

😬

gurt

1:14pm

Happy to have a team in such a great place. We are fans of BYU much, much more than fans of our takes lol. I wonder if

byuTX

1:37pm

Hate is such a stupid word. It’s criticism, and it was deserved. So is the

Helm Hammerhand

1:44pm

I like Kalani. I think he is a great figurehead, but he isn’t perfect.

Boring

2:26pm

RE: Where Are All The Kalani Haters Now?

KYU

3:07pm

Wait til Jay Hill gets poached after this season

CharlottesvilleCoug

3:56pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad