My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 21, 2024
1:25
:16
pm
Future_Tacos
All-American
I think most of the contact happened before the ball was thrown
I think that makes a difference on PI rules. Maybe could have been holding
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Future_Tacos
Previous username
Bonemachine
Bio page
Future_Tacos
Joined
Feb 7, 2005
Last login
Oct 21, 2024
Total posts
11,831 (25 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
I need a ruling. The Double Pass
Borg
12:15pm
There was some question of whether the ball was tipped at the line
canuckchuck
12:16pm
Nvm just watched it
canuckchuck
12:19pm
I think most of the contact happened before the ball was thrown
Future_Tacos
1:25pm
I think it should have been a defensive holding. I think if ball is not in the
cwilke1
12:16pm
The first "pass" wasn't a pass. It's like a hand-off. A lateral. But I've
Manti
12:17pm
The first pass isn't a forward pass, it's more akin to a pitch.
CougPrime
12:17pm
I liked when the announcer tried to talk about it "Was that a hold?" And the other guy just totally ignored the question
brj8
12:18pm
Yeah, “wow the home fans were not happy about that play call” uhhh no they
ChiCityCoug
12:22pm
I wasn't happy with the play call, its execution, or the reffing
byujag
12:30pm
trick plays lose their effectiveness if you run it every game from the same part
fulano
12:44pm
Don't think Hinckley will ever be asked to throw again
baldcoug74
5:10pm
To me, looks like the receiver trips trying to change directions because
Doogal McCougar
12:24pm
the guy who held was also the guy who made the interception. Whether pass is
cwilke1
12:37pm
doesn't matter, ARod got cute and used Ropati to make a throw he shouldn't be making, I know they practice those plays,
ChinaFan
12:29pm
Is it a bad idea because it didn’t work? What if it had worked ?
Polecat
3:25pm
I think it was a bad decision because it wasn't needed. We were driving the ball
morningcalmcougar
3:35pm
Fair. I think this is a moment in which Arod shows an unwillingness to develop
Polecat
3:38pm
I agree. His play calling was pretty good this game, especially he 2nd half
morningcalmcougar
3:46pm
I’ve called them out as bad ideas when they have worked sometimes. When it’s in
ColonelMustard
3:40pm
It has worked well when Kingston is throwing the ball but
NonmormonYfan89
5:08pm
a flag should have been thrown on the personnel used in the play design.
Cougarclaw
12:30pm
how so? I see seven BYU players on the line and 4 back. Doesn't 7 guys on the
cwilke1
12:39pm
Ropati didn't meet the minimum requirement for anyone throwing a D1 ball.
Cougarclaw
12:42pm
Exactly. Why have Ropati throw that?
Orem58thBall
1:12pm
My biggest gripe with ARod. He uses the B team far too often on important plays.
TheLoneCougar
2:59pm
Assuming they practiced it like that all week, wouldn’t that make them the A
Polecat
3:26pm
No, I want the best players in. Hinckely or LJ throwing that pass, LJ.
TheLoneCougar
3:35pm
Kingston, former Roy high QB, is the only one who should be passing.
Mabuhay Coug
3:46pm
That may get too predictable if we do that too many times with him.
TheLoneCougar
4:25pm
I mean you’d want the players who practiced it during the week doing it on
Polecat
3:48pm
Fair points. And I agree with you to a degree. But in general it feels like ARod has 2nd and 3rd stringers in for
TheLoneCougar
4:26pm
I mean every set of downs can include critical plays right? Any third down is
Polecat
6:15pm
I assume play design was for Ropati to get outside and Lasiter running corner
fulano
12:47pm
I'm guessing it would have been called if the pass was even remotely accurate
MaximusMeridius
1:29pm
The rule doesn’t change with the a lateral…but officials give a lot more leniency. Kind of like when Batty destroyed
FromCAtoUT
2:53pm
If the first pass is not a forward lateral, then all PI rules should apply
morningcalmcougar
3:05pm
The first one is not a pass. The 2nd one is. PI applies
RGGeemer
4:11pm
No tip. Ropati passed the ball way behind Lassiter who tripped adjusting.
Bryceo19
6:27pm
No flag: WORST (non)-call of the entire game. #NoExcuse
BleedCougarBlue2
7:02pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad