A little concerned, but it’s still early and you gotta think about transfers too

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 11, 2024
1:18:21am

andrewg3 All-American

A little concerned, but it’s still early and you gotta think about transfers too

Kingsley, Puka, Samson, Taysom, Taggart, etc…a lot of these “BYU guys” end up getting lured away initially by the glitz of other places, but they always end up coming back home eventually.

I’m still not convinced Isaac Wilson won’t end up at BYU eventually. And he’s not really a “BYU guy,” but kinda.

Report problem with this ad

andrewg3

Previous username: Agarrett321
Bio page: andrewg3
Joined: Jul 19, 2016
Last login: Sep 19, 2024
Total posts: 3,891 (7 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the B12 for

Magneto

Sep 10, 3:45pm

RE: Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the

Eddie

Sep 10, 3:49pm

We spent ~$2M on Egor Demin? Would that money have been better used to get a stud QB?

krindorr

Sep 10, 3:55pm

nah. Get a QB like Charlie Ward.

Eddie

Sep 10, 3:58pm

No.

Blewis15

Sep 10, 6:50pm

Only one answer

Deleted

Sep 10, 3:50pm

Is an 85 average rating all that different from 86 or 87?

RGGeemer

Sep 10, 3:54pm

I’m surprised we don’t have a single 4*. Some kids commit early too and others

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:02pm

We got a bunch of ours this year during the offseason, right? I wouldn't worry

RGGeemer

Sep 10, 4:09pm

I tried to have that discussion a couple of months ago

Belboz

Sep 10, 4:58pm

In my experience involving this type of discussion,

Everyman

Sep 10, 5:28pm

One kid can be an 85 today and an 86 tomorrow.

Belboz

Sep 10, 6:03pm

I did a pretty decent analysis of this by rating (not stars)

krindorr

Sep 10, 8:56pm

To get a better idea, you'd need to separate them more

Belboz

Sep 11, 12:34am

84% of NFL first round draft picks were 247 rated 4 stars // 27 of 32. I would

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 10, 11:13pm

RE: I tried to have that discussion a couple of months ago

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 11, 1:00pm

It's a REALLY strong relationship

krindorr

Sep 11, 3:05pm

The recruiting rankings aren't a perfect science but they are as accurate as

BYUfannonLDS

Sep 12, 5:48am

Also, here's an analysis of BYU recruiting vs Wake Forest, Northwestern, Boston College, Northwestern, Cal, USF & others

krindorr

Sep 11, 3:09pm

No because the players love Sitake and everyone is having a great time:

byuTX

Sep 10, 3:54pm

Its certainly an indicator that we're not planning on competing to win the Big12

DodgerCoug

Sep 10, 4:15pm

Nothing is being planned. There is no plan or set up. No accountability.

byuTX

Sep 10, 4:28pm

I love that you keep repeating this, hoping that it comes true. But it's not

OldFogey

Sep 10, 8:02pm

deion sanders is the football equivalent of KY. that’s what it takes to have that impact in football.

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 4:00pm

KY actually recruits good players.

spidercoug

Sep 10, 4:07pm

we don’t know that yet

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 4:17pm

We sure know that Deion doesn't

spidercoug

Sep 10, 4:27pm

RE: we don’t know that yet

getdal

Sep 10, 5:45pm

sorry but KY hasn’t even coached a game at BYU.

FieroCoug

Sep 10, 6:08pm

The statement was that we didn't know whether KY had recruited good players not

getdal

Sep 11, 6:42am

he said we know KY recruits good players like deion doesn’t. deions players are better on paper than the guys

FieroCoug

Sep 11, 7:12pm

This is fair

krindorr

Sep 12, 6:28am

Deion was an assistant coach in the NFL?

andrewg3

Sep 11, 1:09am

we’re talking about recruiting impact not actual resume

FieroCoug

Sep 12, 10:52am

If BYU wants to compete for championships, absolutely

Projectoor

Sep 10, 4:26pm

Yes

Big12Yfan

Sep 10, 4:26pm

Great way to put it.

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:53pm

Yes, it is the single most reliable predictor of wins and losses. BYU consistent

miblue

Sep 10, 9:01pm

Yes. Kalani has been a terrible recruiter and we can't sustain more years of it

Sep 10, 4:43pm

We need to lock down Austin Pay for sure, hopefully we get Taj Crutchfield, tho

Captain Stubing

Sep 10, 4:54pm

We also MUST get Tuakoi and Akuila enrolled for winter smstr and in spring ball

Captain Stubing

Sep 10, 4:59pm

I think we're at least a few weeks in front of December's early signing period

Belboz

Sep 10, 4:54pm

We’ve seen a bump in recruiting since joininthe B12 but nothing like UCF has had

Magneto

Sep 10, 4:54pm

Thankfully our coaching and development is top notch. So we can get by with

byubyu

Sep 10, 5:01pm

It is called do the Pope thing, get rid of KS and bring in someone else.

Sep 10, 5:21pm

There isn't much difference in being 15th vs 8th to be honest

boctabulous

Sep 10, 6:08pm

You don't want the answer to how to duplicate in football what happened in basketball

KYU

Sep 10, 6:22pm

We are getting 1/2 share of tv money. Double coaching money next year.

ParentingNotForSissy

Sep 10, 6:32pm

RE: Should we be concerned that we’re currently 15th in recruiting in the

Sep 10, 11:00pm

Love and learn

Haysom Till

Sep 10, 11:19pm

A little concerned, but it’s still early and you gotta think about transfers too

andrewg3

Sep 11, 1:18am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad