I seemed like you were quoting the 247 website.

Report problem with this ad

Jul 8, 2024
6:46:11pm

lurKing5000 Redshirt Freshman

If that was your take, I hope you just take it as a good natured ribbing. No offense intended 🙂

Report problem with this ad

lurKing5000

Bio page: lurKing5000
Joined: Jul 29, 2020
Last login: Oct 5, 2024
Total posts: 155 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU's eleven 86+ rated players in the 2025 class are all graded as p4 caliber

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:18pm

How can anyone take that seriously?

Charles Darwin

Jul 1, 6:20pm

It’s all science. Trust science.

WallaX2

Jul 1, 6:24pm

Man, this debate gets old. The ratings are not always right, but are on average

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:31pm

Do you think they actually evaluate 600 players? Why have they inflated the

Charles Darwin

Jul 1, 6:34pm

You switched from differentiating between 85 and 88 to differentiating between

Belboz

Jul 1, 6:38pm

So what??

nova_coug_fan

Jul 1, 6:46pm

You wrote about 3 stars versus 4 stars as if that addressed something else

Belboz

Jul 1, 6:55pm

Ok, looking at ratings, here's an analysis

krindorr

Jul 1, 9:02pm

And that list doesn't distinguish between an 87 or 88

Belboz

Jul 2, 9:11am

Ratings are subjective.. but they're also really good indicators

krindorr

Jul 2, 10:14am

There's such a significant difference, that ranges are grouped in that report

Belboz

Jul 2, 10:25am

Thanks for your analysis- I don't understand the debate here

nova_coug_fan

Jul 2, 10:40am

The primary reason for debate is that the analysis doesn't say what we want it to

krindorr

Jul 2, 10:53am

Complete straw man

Charles Darwin

Jul 2, 11:16am

No, my only issue is when we pretend there a big difference between 86 and 87

Belboz

Jul 2, 5:55pm

You can’t. But it probably beats guys no other P4 offers

cajuncoug

Jul 1, 7:54pm

I love the thoughtful analysis evidenced in this statement:

lurKing5000

Jul 1, 10:21pm

I will grant you, that was not at all an insightful statement

nova_coug_fan

Jul 2, 11:03am

I seemed like you were quoting the 247 website.

lurKing5000

Jul 8, 6:46pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad