Page 1 - CougarBoard

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I don’t think Scalley will last long

Cooouuugs

5:22am

Utah has had superior recruiting for like 12 years straight

JoeExotic

5:26am

Still competitive, but Utah took a bit of a fall in recruiting.

Jeffacka

5:40am

Jay Hill being a HC would be a good thing.

JoeExotic

5:20am

Why would we want to lose a coach so we can rehire him?

NGB

5:32am

Saw this first time a couple of weeks ago. Saw it again this morning. Seriously

TrueBlue67

5:14am

Jay Hill wants A HC gig. He wants p4 eventually. If I'm him, go where he can win and be noticed. Is that USU? Not sure

Crazy Joe Davola Intervention Needed

4:56am

Does he?

TheHop

5:02am

I read somewhere (sorry, don't recall) in recent years he applied for several MWC HC gig and was turned down

Crazy Joe Davola

5:05am

How many coaches don’t?

Sea Chicken

5:21am

I dont know?

TheHop

5:39am

Jay Hill doesn’t even go to the locker room during halftime. He stays in the

rainorsnow

5:05am

I don't disagree. Current health situation may change things

Crazy Joe Davola

5:07am

Was the hail Mary actually incomplete?

Riseandshout81

4:18am

it was likely due to confusion that the referee gave the incomplete signal, and

cwilke1

4:19am

Hill leaving would be terrible. But losing coordinators happens when you win.

Shinshin

4:15am

Losing him to a local school would be bad. Local recruiting competition is always bad

Crazy Joe Davola

4:57am

If Jay Hill leaves my worry is how many of our D coaches is he taking with him

jigidajrit

4:10am

it seems to me that people that are quick to explain that ARod isn't the problem

HouseDeeking

2:39am

Tell me, again, what is the problem?

kccougar

4:49am

We have video replay and reviews, why do coaches react like the ASU coach did

Y05

1:51am

unfortunately its often part of the industry based around a violent sport. Its

cwilke1

2:03am

I think this was personal because of his end of game strategy and nervous it

Pied Piper

3:37am

ASU fans should be critical of him for that weird ending he caused.

NumbersGuy

5:05am

For the real answer you would have to ask Utah’s athletic director.

Sea Chicken

3:53am

One nice thing about the Kansas St game is that they're still alive to make CCG

Cougs4Lfe

1:40am

But will they be alive when they play ISU? I honestly have no idea, because of

Shinshin

4:11am

2 early games would need to go their way. Kansas over Baylor (more possible) and OSU over Colorado (less likely)

Crazy Joe Davola

4:51am

Puka can still realistically get 1000 yards this season.

Y05

1:32am

Glad he's looking more like last season's version. Love seeing him ball out.

Cougs4Lfe

1:35am

I like to see Puka do well while the Rams lose. It’s a win win.

Sea Chicken

3:55am

<< Deleted >>

Cougs4Lfe

1:31am

State of Utah salaries data base says USU head coach (Anderson) was only making

Das_Countach

12:58am

It would be like going back to Weber State to be HC.

Y05

2:35am

6 ACC teams and 2 Big 10 teams make up the women's soccer final 8. The 6 ACC

cwilke1

12:53am

Rady invitational

KYU All-American

12:47am

Name the great OC or DCs we’ve enjoyed since Kalani became HC.

Hawk Talons

12:26am

Also different with p4 status and more money now.

cougarfann888

12:28am

Time will tell. I don’t think our coaching pool magically enlarged substantially

Hawk Talons

12:30am

I think it increased but not as much as people think it did.

NYCougz

12:32am

Agreed

Hawk Talons

12:32am

I don’t think it’s just money that has increased it. It’s Big 12 membership,

Polecat

1:04am

still got to have coaches willing to live the honor code and teach it.

runnincoug

1:28am

<< Deleted >>

Polecat

12:50am

Idk maybe it’s me, but there’s no way Jay Hill is leaving BYU to be the HC at

bigbossbyu

12:18am

Jay will ge more opportunities at better programs.

NYCougz

12:21am

Yep this. He’ll probably have his pick of being the main guy at BYU or Utah in

bigbossbyu

12:26am

Hope we can keep him. I worry about his health too. Had a big scare not that

NYCougz

12:29am

You think kalani is out in 3-5 years?

cougarfann888

12:34am

No, nor do I think Hill is the BYU DC 5 years from now. Kind of a sucky

bigbossbyu

12:39am

Sounds like you have the future all planned out. Do you have any stock tips?

Ozymandias

12:43am

CFB coaching carousel is easier to predict than the stock market.

Y05

2:36am

Not for BYU and Utah, it isn’t.

Ozymandias

2:51am

Huh? Kalani and Scalley are both young guys.

Ozymandias

12:37am

The average length of head coaching careers is getting smaller. Kalani is

Polecat

1:09am

Kalani is 49. He will likely be at BYU now as long as he wants. Scalley is 45

Ozymandias

1:14am

My point is things are unpredictable, and modern college football coaches stay

Polecat

1:19am

Do you think that the odds are that in 5 years someone other than Kalani or

Ozymandias

1:22am

They say never replace a legend. Scalley will be doing just that in a new world

Polecat

1:30am

Haha. Their defense has been good to very good this year. He gets 4 years

Ozymandias

2:33am

That just seems like nonsense to me.

YSMACK

12:35am

What does the HC make at UsU?

NYCougz

12:40am

Google says $1.3M. You think he makes less now?

NYCougz

12:42am

He makes 1 m now. He will likely be offered 1.4 by USU

YSMACK

12:45am

I just don’t see it. Maybe he’s desperate to be the main guy, we’ll see. But to

bigbossbyu

12:54am

It seems like we could come up with another $400 and give him associate HC role

NYCougz

12:58am

They surely would pay more for Hill. And Hill could parlay that job to a huge

Hawk Talons

12:46am

I agree it’s nonsense that USU is some kind of terrible gig that Hill wouldn’t

Polecat

1:17am

BYU fans should be worried. The way to becoming my a coach at a P4 program for

Ozymandias

12:36am

Idk if Hill is they type of coach that needs a G5 HC gig at USU to land at a

bigbossbyu

1:05am

What coordinators from a BYU type program have gone from a coordinator to HC

Ozymandias

1:11am

When has BYU ever been a P4 program? Not saying he’d be a run away candidate,

bigbossbyu

1:16am

I asked for a BYU type program. Show me a Baylor coordinator or a

Ozymandias

1:19am

So you’re essentially saying his FCS coach experience is enough to land a P4

Polecat

1:28am

BYU is in playoff and conference championship contention.

Y05

2:49am

Show me a comparable program where a coordinator went from coordinator to

Ozymandias

3:53am

Kirby Smart - head coach for top 5 georgia went from being defensive coordinator

cwilke1

4:16am

I said a comparable program. Alabama is not that.

Ozymandias

4:25am

I love Hill, but in typical CB fashion, some of you act like there are no other

Thrill

12:15am

Losing Jay would be huge.

NYCougz

12:16am

Of course there are. But I doubt they would have the on field and recruiting

Hawk Talons

12:18am

Hill is unique in that he’s been a HC before as well, so prob helps Kalani w/

Das_Countach

1:22am

Right? Has no one ever heard of a guy by the name of Nick Howell?!!

Crazy Joe Davola

5:02am

Dallin Leavitt. Here is the clip from his pick against BYU. I remember being

Ozymandias

12:14am

Here's another angle of it

ryebrye

12:17am

Who?

kalifi

5:42am

It's amazing the capability that AI can already do. Here's some old paintings that have been morphed into videos.

Zenoch All-American

12:04am

It's hard to trust any video anymore. Could be doctored so easy now

TNT

12:06am

That’s really cool

Breaded Hamster

12:10am

Ute Twitter is running with the idea that the Big12 refs are out to get them.

YOHONOMOTO

12:02am

They have had so many lucky breaks the last 10-12 years. It's

cougarfann888

12:07am

Is there a replay of the holding call? How do you get a holding on a FG attempt?

BenTheBoss

12:09am

This is only a guess but maybe like the defense gets one on an offensive running play. They grab the offensive player

Chemish

1:20am

I’m just sitting back and smiling

hdx57

1:24am

They're just salty because talk refs are taking notice of their dirty play.

TrueBlue67

5:17am

In retrospect, complaining very loudly about what ended up being a textbook

fbguru

5:35am

I honestly feel the competitive future for BYU hinges on keeping Jay Hill.

Hawk Talons

Nov 24, 11:59pm

Jay is is an excellent coach and great resource, but he’s not the be all end

Polecat

12:02am

Then why not get someone better than ARod? Hill is showing he gets it done

TNT

12:03am

Arod is Kalani’s third OC, and my guess is it he won’t be his last. I know TNT

Polecat

12:11am

Do you understand how difficult it is to find a DC as good as Hill to coach at

Hawk Talons

12:05am

People here think Bronco was an elite DC. Now we have Hill. Gary Andersen

Polecat

12:18am

I disagree. I’ll bookmark this to see who is correct.

Hawk Talons

12:21am

Are you predicting BYU is on the brink of collapse ? What exactly do you

Polecat

12:23am

I disagree with your dismissal of Jay Hill and the thinking he is replaceable by

Hawk Talons

12:28am

I actually said neither of those things. Although I will say almost nobody

Polecat

12:34am

I’m sure they will. Just like they found Detmer, Tuiaki, Grimes, and Howell.

Hawk Talons

12:38am

Dude I’m not commenting on Hill at all. I’m saying BYU is a quality

Polecat

12:51am

I don’t think we are on the brink of disaster. But I don’t think we will find a

Hawk Talons

12:55am

I’m not in the interest of comparing coaches, Hill is great. Somewhere

Polecat

12:59am

For weeks now Utah’s conference record on ESPN and a few other places has been

Nittany Cougar

Nov 24, 11:46pm

Baylor was not a conference game. Scheduled pre Big12 invite, and doesn’t count in conference

WP17

Nov 24, 11:48pm

Baylor didn't count as a conference game.

yorksama

Nov 24, 11:49pm

IIRC the Baylor game had been previously scheduled as an OOC game

Hinta

Nov 24, 11:49pm

But the Big12 still hates Utah, right? Right?!?!

Nittany Cougar

Nov 24, 11:55pm

College football is a funny thing. We’ve all become conditioned to think the

Polecat

12:57am

BYU is slow to fire bad coaches. Do coaches consider that a perk?

maYbe

Nov 24, 11:41pm

Better job security

TNT

Nov 24, 11:42pm

Kind of like the Steelers.

maYbe

Nov 24, 11:52pm

Tomlin is a great coach though

CBaass

5:35am

Give us the power and we will have new fresh coaches every year.

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:46pm

Except for the guy who was the most decorated player in BYU history

LongtimeLurker

Nov 24, 11:53pm

who had arguably the worst offense in his own lifetime

FieroCoug

Nov 24, 11:55pm

You know who else is slow to fire coaches? The Pittsburgh Steelers. They’ve

gwalker

Nov 24, 11:55pm

Nebraska firing Frank solich for 9-3 seasons was not a good idea

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:58pm

Firing Larry cocker at Miami after two 9-3 seasons didn’t work out great

NYCougz

12:05am

The last time BYU needed to fire a head coach, I think they did it right when

Polecat

12:07am

The recording of Batty being posted on X by a Ute fan is par for the course. Reminds me what Utes did to Spencer Hadley.

SierraCoug All-American

Nov 24, 11:40pm

That was Utah's Compliance office. Even worse

BYU '80

12:10am

One very underrated ability that Jake has shown since he became the starter...

Ja'Crispy

Nov 24, 11:28pm

He’s resilient and a real leader. He’s played the most challenging schedule in byu history. Not flawless but dangerous

GoodBetterBestBYU

Nov 24, 11:31pm

That’s a good description.

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:56pm

If Whitt retires, Scalley goes to HC, Hill goes up there to DC

OU Cougar

Nov 24, 11:23pm

It’s very unlikely Hill moves laterally for less money

WP17

Nov 24, 11:24pm

And a heckuva lot less security. BYU is stable, Utah is in crisis and unknown.

runnincoug

Nov 24, 11:27pm

And work for a defensive coach as a defensive coach. Jay will want to run it

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:36pm

Please tell me why Hill goes? Especially bc if scalley gets axed so does hill. If hill stays and s alley gets axed now

BYU Grounds

Nov 24, 11:28pm

Won’t happen

GoodBetterBestBYU

Nov 24, 11:29pm

Wouldn't it be great if people stopped wetting their pants every time some dumb rumor comes out?

ManicBlue

Nov 24, 11:33pm

This is more likely related to an undiagnosed or untreated incontinence issue.

Nittany Cougar

Nov 24, 11:51pm

Having great coaches is a double-edged sword.

dut99002

12:00am

BYU has more money than Utah. Hill may interview for leverage, but don't see him

fbguru

5:12am

0 chance. He’ll let Scalley and Utah feel it out for 2-3 years and if at that

bigbossbyu

12:32am

Do you just like to make stuff up?

LifeLongLakerFan

1:05am

I'm not an attorney, isn't this a felony? A.R.S. § 13-3005

Uno Doctoro

Nov 24, 11:20pm

Maybe but Probably not. Idaho has a similar statute and there is a debate

cougarfann888

Nov 24, 11:56pm

I am an az attorney. Recording a conversation you aren't a part of is illegal

the_archduke

5:42am

Why has the offense faltered at the worst time?

Countcougula

Nov 24, 11:17pm

…arod

Das_Countach

Nov 24, 11:19pm

I'm not sure they've ever been that good. I am starting to think that the

Emmett Fitz-Hume

Nov 24, 11:28pm

This is how football games are. Alabama put up 3 in a must win game.

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:51pm

Don’t you know BYU is just supposed to beat everyone 66-3? And if they don’t,

Polecat

12:31am

I’m get emotional during games like we all do.

NYCougz

12:35am

Every fan base thinks their OC is a terrible play caller. The reality is the

Polecat

12:47am

It's 2-2 on last-minute long drives but has otherwise been bad all year.

vagabonder

Nov 24, 11:41pm

This is so stupid and not even close to true.

Polecat

12:27am

I’d say the D faltered too…

Pretorian

Nov 24, 11:50pm

But you see the defense is coached by Jay Hill. He’d probably have to start

Polecat

12:29am

Film

HouseDeeking

2:44am

Teams are bringing a lot more pressure on Jake the second half of season. More

BYUfannonLDS

5:37am

Jay Hill’s bio, born in Lehi, served a mission in Puerto Rico, played at Ricks

OU Cougar

Nov 24, 11:16pm

I’ve been really impressed with the Oregon State DL this year. If Jay Hill left

DieHarder

Nov 24, 11:15pm

What about New Mexico's DC?

Great38

Nov 24, 11:36pm

POLL: Personal feelings aside, if you're an NFL GM, and you need a starting QB now, who would you rather have?

Mr. Belding Truly Addicted User

Nov 24, 11:05pm

Three ways for BYU to deal with Jay Hill assuming he is offered the USU job:

Emmett Fitz-Hume

Nov 24, 11:03pm

So we have to pay him or we get Howell? Yikes.

puntersarepeople

Nov 24, 11:05pm

#3 doesn't ring a bell. SERENITY NOW!!!!!!!!!

TNT

Nov 24, 11:08pm

pay the man, he's the best guy for our defense and culture.

4mack

Nov 24, 11:13pm

HC @ USU or really any G5 now is essentially a JUCO HC today w/ all the turnover

Das_Countach

Nov 24, 11:24pm

This is how I see it. You can’t keep a roster together in the G5

deliciousmocha

Nov 24, 11:28pm

That's limited to the G5?

TNT

Nov 24, 11:41pm

RE: That's limited to the G5?

deliciousmocha

12:27am

Last thing.. Any rationale as to how that wasn't intentional grounding?

Yes

Nov 24, 10:58pm

Crazy enough, some reports say it was called intentional grounding.

Madam Pattirini

Nov 24, 11:19pm

The Last of Us

TNT

Nov 24, 10:58pm

Wait till you see what they did to Ron Swanson

SJS

Nov 24, 10:59pm

Have a feeling KSU v ISU going to break a record for most 👀 this year

Kolobrdm

Nov 24, 10:56pm

Jay Hill is getting poached 2 years into the job and ARod has gone 6 seasons with no interest…

WP17 King of the Kenai

Nov 24, 10:51pm

USU is a career killer. If he goes there he's not very smart.

Blueto

Nov 24, 10:56pm

Not at all the point of this post- more an observation that he’s being considered and A rod isn’t

WP17

Nov 24, 10:57pm

How do you know ARod hasn't had interest from other schools? Are you his spouse?

ManicBlue

Nov 24, 11:02pm

It becomes public, just like it has w/ Hill. Arod’s not a sought after commodity

Das_Countach

Nov 24, 11:27pm

Sure. There is usually a press release about it. Everyone knows..

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:55pm

Unless of course it doesn’t become public.

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:59pm

Trust me, it gets out there if they want it or not

Das_Countach

12:01am

Why would I trust a random dude on CB? These discussions will and do

NYCougz

12:03am

You don’t know that everyone knows about every time a coach has discussions

NYCougz

12:01am

lol, bro, no ones trying to poach Arod, just like no one tried to poach Tuiaki

Das_Countach

12:04am

Well if das countach says so, obviously that must be true.

NYCougz

12:07am

It is, if you want to believe it or not 😂

Das_Countach

12:10am

You would know. I remember when people didn’t think highly of bronco

NYCougz

12:13am

I know more than I think you realize, and thats why I laugh at you pushing back

Das_Countach

12:19am

About how it goes public when every coach has discussions with other?

NYCougz

12:24am

Wasn’t for Gary Anderson. Jay knows how to recruit Utah and small programs.

Bin01015

Nov 24, 10:59pm

and Matt Wells used that job as a springboard to a P4 head coach job

cwilke1

12:05am

It is what it is

TNT

Nov 24, 10:58pm

You have no idea who has or hasn’t reached out to ARod. If he doesn’t want to go

gwalker

Nov 24, 10:59pm

This is true. The guys that turn down offers don’t make the headlines.

Mexicougazul

Nov 24, 11:04pm

The people that bashed ARod all summer and then simmered because they couldn’t

gwalker

Nov 24, 11:07pm

RE: The people that bashed ARod all summer and then simmered because they couldn’t

PJMort

Nov 24, 11:15pm

I still find the energy to challenge them when they try and retroject the last 2

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:56pm

If ARod was interviewing at other schools that information isn't going to be kept a secret. Nobody wants ARod

Coug

Nov 24, 11:13pm

💯

Das_Countach

Nov 24, 11:28pm

You do understand that him not interested means him not interviewing, right?

kimdaddy35

Nov 24, 11:50pm

I have some idea to say he hasn’t gotten serious interest. You might also recall he’s already been fired once at Utah.

WP17

Nov 24, 11:20pm

Oh he must be bad then. It’s really hard to be fired as offensive coordinator

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:58pm

You’re forgetting about Arod’s mind changing instances earlier in his career

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:01pm

Jay Hill is very good.

OU Cougar

Nov 24, 11:03pm

Totally whenever I see a team go 9-2, first thing I think is:

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:04pm

It is when they have legitimate issues- just ask Austin Collie

WP17

Nov 24, 11:23pm

My point is not that the offense doesn’t have issues or that Roderick has no

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:44pm

Nice appeal to authority. Still a logical fallacy.

TheLoneCougar

5:25am

…your theory falls apart with Utah and Ok St

Das_Countach

Nov 24, 11:29pm

And general QB recruiting pipeline.

WP17

Nov 24, 11:30pm

💯

Das_Countach

12:13am

the offense was good against OSU, and while it was bad against utah, 22 points being bad is a really GOOD sign that

FieroCoug

Nov 24, 11:35pm

He was good against Utah when the game was online, and especially good against

Polecat

Nov 24, 11:36pm

Man let’s just go get any OC we want. Easy peasy.

NYCougz

Nov 24, 11:34pm

FS1
BYU Radio

ESPN
BYU Radio

Top 10 recent

Idk maybe it’s me, but there’s no way Jay Hill is leaving BYU to be the HC at

As an Iowa state fan, here’s what we think about the KSU game this weekend

State of Utah salaries data base says USU head coach (Anderson) was only making

I'm not an attorney, isn't this a felony? A.R.S. § 13-3005

We have video replay and reviews, why do coaches react like the ASU coach did

Was this already reported re:Jay Hill?

Batty had an NIL deal with my company. You won't find a better human. I love the

ASU may be forced to fire him if video of their guy filming in secret gets out

I honestly feel the competitive future for BYU hinges on keeping Jay Hill.

Jay Hill is getting poached 2 years into the job and ARod has gone 6 seasons with no interest…

Site Statistics

Today

Posts: 188
Threads: 23
Visitors: 1,094
Logins: 1,000

Yesterday

Posts: 6,084
Threads: 960
Visitors: 4,903
Logins: 3,662

Currently Online

Total: 281
Subscribers: 212
Non-subscribers: 44
Non-login: 25

More statistics

Report problem with this ad