The only reason you would have your hands down and be leaning slightly back with

Mar 24, 2025
4:21:03pm

Agaricus All-American

your crotch out is to bait the player into trying to split the double team so that you can immediately hit the ground pretending to be mortally injured.

With your hand down you are giving him a window of hope that he can muscle through.

Report problem with this ad

Agaricus

Bio page: Agaricus
Joined: Sep 29, 2008
Last login: Apr 1, 2025
Total posts: 1,665 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

My understanding of the Baker Flagrant 2 Ejection

Skeptical Optimist Truly Addicted User

Mar 24, 11:50am

Incidental but not accidental is a distinction without a difference

Plato

Mar 24, 11:53am

You meant to strike out--just didn't mean to hit the guy where he got hit

byujdmba

Mar 24, 12:16pm

Right, your first line describes an accident

Plato

Mar 24, 12:39pm

You're still responsible under the law in my gun example.

byujdmba

Mar 24, 2:15pm

Using your analogy, the defender stepped in front of the gun. Truth.

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Mar 24, 2:20pm

Correct. It works that way, too.

byujdmba

Mar 24, 5:56pm

I hate the imbedded response by Gene Steratore

HRCougar

Mar 24, 11:53am

yep, the problem with the whole premise is that it was non-incidental

cruiserhead

Mar 24, 12:05pm

I think he's saying that by the wording of the rule, they were kinda hamstrung and had to call it

Skeptical Optimist

Mar 24, 12:06pm

Agree to disagree. Blaming a poorly written rule (which it is) for tossing some

HRCougar

Mar 24, 12:13pm

The refs had a chance to right a wrong they made earlier in the game with Mag's dumb technical they called earlier..

greatbam

Mar 24, 3:08pm

I think the call on the Wisconsin bench was the makeup for Mag.

Eddie

Mar 24, 3:14pm

Ah ok. I'm not really remembering that one but I'll take your word for it.

greatbam

Mar 24, 3:31pm

The problem is that it was "clearly accidental". So the whole they had no choice but to call a

cruiserhead

Mar 24, 3:24pm

I agree. The standard is absurd

RealTaysomHill

Mar 24, 11:54am

It seems poorly written, but to me it was clearly accidental.

JuicyJam

Mar 24, 11:54am

And yet far more examples of forcible contact to the head and neck are re not deemed to be targeting

Littlerich

Mar 24, 11:56am

JT Toppin was ejected from the Texas Tech-Houston game for the same reason.

SG Blue

Mar 24, 11:58am

Guilty until proven innocent.

Sea Chicken

Mar 24, 11:58am

The defender clearly knew the rule and got his junk in position

Zerigke Ally Zerigke

Mar 24, 12:11pm

Let me help. It was clearly accidental. The standard is dumb, but it was clearly accidental. Play on. Ref got it wrong.

PJMort

Mar 24, 12:11pm

The rule was written for intentional nut shots like when a player swings his arm

westsidecoug

Mar 24, 12:12pm

I'll bet that is why the rule was written.

Eddie

Mar 24, 1:06pm

A good ref says he is making a basketball play (splitting an aggressive trap)

Still Blue

Mar 24, 12:13pm

Poorly written rule and consequence. Also, could have been deemed accidental,

Captain Stubing

Mar 24, 12:25pm

By this interpretation, nothing can be accidental

m1k3l33

Mar 24, 12:42pm

I think that's why it's such a poorly written rule

Skeptical Optimist

Mar 24, 12:52pm

It was interesting to read that Wisconsin had a player ejected earlier this...

Eddie

Mar 24, 1:01pm

That would explain the UW player sticking his groin out w/ his hands behind him.

ldssdl

Mar 24, 1:03pm

Evidence to support your claim:

Dr MoBYU

Mar 24, 3:25pm

RE: Evidence to support your claim:

Eddie

Mar 24, 3:45pm

His crotch was in the offensive player's cylinder

byuod

Mar 24, 5:35pm

RE: His crotch was in the offensive player's cylinder

Eddie

Mar 24, 5:42pm

Taking one for the team?

Blue Heart

Mar 24, 4:47pm

yet they dismiss shots to the head quite often

Count Cougar

Mar 24, 1:16pm

Traore was hit in the face which should have been a flagrant 1. Our review guys missed that.

jre85

Mar 24, 2:00pm

<< Deleted >>

cruiserhead

Mar 24, 2:12pm

If that’s the rule you shouldn’t be able to trap

SBB

Mar 24, 2:13pm

Seems like common sense is lacking.

tkh9

Mar 24, 3:16pm

Also,the dude stuck his junk out. As seen in this photo

Dr MoBYU

Mar 24, 3:24pm

"You put your crotch in my face, here's an elbow from me,"

Accipiter

Mar 24, 3:58pm

The only reason you would have your hands down and be leaning slightly back with

Agaricus

Mar 24, 4:21pm

Do refs see slow motion of plays on the review? If this video was regular speed

ShellieCooper

Mar 24, 3:38pm

Rolling around, writhing in pain — was that NOT "clearly accidental" too refs??

SinkingQuffa

Mar 24, 3:58pm

It was clearly accidental. Didn’t even look at him and made a bball play

BYU '80

Mar 24, 4:27pm

His crotch was in Baker's offensive cylinder

byuod

Mar 24, 5:38pm

RE: His crotch was in Baker's offensive cylinder

Posting on CougarBoard