Is Hunter worth the #1 pick? I don't think so. He was awesome playing both

Jan 7, 2025
12:18:26pm

mudpupper All-American

ways but that won't happen much in the NFL. And is he a standout at either position that is worthy of a #1 pick?

If he were just WR or CB would spend the #1 pick on him? Absolutely not.

Report problem with this ad

mudpupper

Bio page: mudpupper
Joined: May 13, 2003
Last login: Jan 8, 2025
Total posts: 44,492 (151 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I would take Cam Ward over Sanders too, but this is really a two QB draft. Not a whole lot else there. Expect those

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

Jan 7, 11:31am

I am not sure I would take either QB that high. You might be better off

Archaea

Jan 7, 11:33am

Maybe, but this last year's crop of rookie QBs has shown quite well.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 11:35am

And Maye was actually pretty good when he played, even though the Pats suck.

RealTaysomHill

Jan 7, 11:39am

I agree. He played well.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 11:49am

I think it's the way it is with rookie QBs because QB salaries are too high.

Belboz

Jan 7, 11:45am

Is Hunter worth the #1 pick? I don't think so. He was awesome playing both

mudpupper

Jan 7, 12:18pm

I think Jaxson Dart is better than all of them

ElkhunterUT

Jan 7, 11:35am

I think that Jaxon Dart will surpirse many when he does his workouts

PhilPete

Jan 7, 11:35am

I mean Mel Kiper (the least knowledgeable draft "expert" of all time) has him as his #3 QB

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 11:49am

It'll be really interesting to see what happens. Lots of teams need QBs, but it does seem to be a weak QB class.

RealTaysomHill

Jan 7, 11:45am

Dart is the best QB in the class. He has every quality needed to have long term sustainable success in the NFL.

Zach Morris

Jan 7, 11:48am

You are out on an island on this one. Time will tell if you are right. But the people who are paid to

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 11:53am

I could name numerous Trey Lance-like picks by the experts who are paid for their expertise. The “experts” screw up more

Zach Morris

Jan 7, 11:58am

Of course they get it wrong. Some may be on them and some on the player who doesn't work hard enough.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 12:11pm

Jackson Dart doesn't have near the arm talent that Jordan Loves has/had. Love was also incredibly raw coming out

RealTaysomHill

Jan 7, 12:51pm

I’d probably go Ward > Dart > Sanders. Running ability being a big part

Odysseus

Jan 7, 12:10pm

Sanders is definitely the better athlete of him and Dart, but in terms of running ability I agree

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 12:23pm

As a success case, I’d say a mix of Darnold & Mayfield. He feels like a reach in

Odysseus

Jan 7, 2:15pm

Sanders' player comps have been all over the board. I have seen Joe Burrow, Geno Smith and Tyrod Taylor.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 2:35pm

I'd take Dart later, coach him up for a few years, and play him in a few years.

Adwight

Jan 7, 12:11pm

Man I haven't seen this board so in love with a player that isn't a BYU guy in....well ever.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 12:20pm

What don't you like about Dart? His biggest drawback is the propensity to take

Adwight

Jan 7, 1:11pm

Dart and Sanders are the exact same height. The arm talent is not similar and strongly favors Sanders.

kimdaddy35

Jan 7, 1:25pm

I think this analysis is spot on. Dart is way more mobile than Goff, but otherwise, it's a fair comp.

RealTaysomHill

Jan 7, 1:27pm

I don't mind the Goff and Dart comparison, Dart is the better athlete.

Adwight

Jan 7, 1:58pm

Goff was a better prospect coming out of college than Dart is because of his height and accuracy

Posting on CougarBoard