up stories to vilify anyone who has fair observations and critiques based on logic, wins and losses, etc.

I love Kalani and respect him as a man and coach. Love that he’s in our football program and was a fan and player of byu first.

I’ve observed that Kalani is not an Xs and Os guru, often seems to bumble our timeouts, loses games to vastly inferior programs, under performs in recruiting especially on the dline, and seem to play overly emotional which can lead to big wins and big let downs. He takes his foot off the gas way earlier than I’d like (style points are not part of his repertoire and that hurt us this year IMO).

It’s a fair critique based on how his tenure has played out. even if you disagree with what that means, it’s hard to dispute those facts.

Conversely, Kalani wins games he “shouldn’t” at times, is very likeable, is a people guru, seems to be improving in recruiting, and has hired some really good coaches in this last go around, after years of not doing that. We def are on an uptick after some brutal years.

His approach of love and learn is interesting. It’s a lightning rod approach to football in my opinion and will draw some mixed feedback.

This season was amazing and we won almost twice as many games as I predicted we would. Last year was the opposite, and the years before that I was pretty spot on.