Yup - you get one or the other, not both. Take the play or the penalty.

Nov 25, 2024
3:02:58pm

Eddie Truly Addicted User

Take the play and the game ends. Take the penalty, and you get another chance to make a play. But not from the 1-2 yard line - from the 35 or 40.

Report problem with this ad

Eddie

Bio page: Eddie
Joined: Dec 12, 2002
Last login: Nov 25, 2024
Total posts: 46,322 (1,063 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

To wrap up the game at ASU from someone who was there…..

BYU Grounds Truly Addicted User

2:19pm

Just an FYI - PI in college is a 15 yard penalty at best.

Eddie

2:23pm

Pass was caught. It would have allowed another play from the spot where

PhilPete

2:57pm

Wouldn't BYU need to decline the penalty to get the ball where caught?

hydro

3:00pm

Yup - you get one or the other, not both. Take the play or the penalty.

Eddie

3:02pm

Nope - it would not. Take the play or take the penalty - you don't get both.

Eddie

3:16pm

He caught the ball

BYU Grounds

3:02pm

1. It was ruled incomplete.

Kalani4Prez

3:10pm

that’s incorrect. It was clearly a catch

BYU Grounds

4:27pm

It was clearly a catch - but it was called incomplete.

Eddie

4:34pm

Here's the link - go to the last play by scrolling to the bottom.

Eddie

4:36pm

Here is a number of links that show he caught it

BYU Grounds

4:59pm

Like I said before - it is clearly a catch.

Eddie

5:06pm

It would go a long ways if alcohol was banned in all sports venues, especially college.

Posting on CougarBoard