you're missing good sportmansip

Sep 7, 2024
8:28:43am

Zoobieman All-American

SMU called off the dogs. . . so byu snapped early.

offense should still run down the play clock. . . but youre analysis misses sportsmanship and docorum.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Sep 7, 2024 at 8:28:43am

Message modified by Zoobieman on Sep 7, 2024 at 9:41:23am

Report problem with this ad

Zoobieman

Bio page: Zoobieman
Joined: Apr 23, 2012
Last login: Sep 18, 2024
Total posts: 11,175 (32 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU knelt the ball with 18 seconds left in the 4th quarter. The scoreboard...

COACHdrn

Sep 7, 2:07am

It wasn’t 4th down. We knelt on 3rd down with 18 seconds left. We still had

Hawk Talons

Sep 7, 2:34am

You are both correct.

cambo

Sep 7, 2:45am

<< Deleted >>

Socrates Johnson

Sep 7, 1:07pm

which now makes it 4th down with 18 sec left. Had SMU used their TO, we would

Coug-Ida

Sep 7, 8:30am

Right, so timeout forces a punt.

RGGeemer

Sep 7, 3:08pm

We could have run the clock down much further before taking the knee on 3rd down

tkh9

Sep 7, 3:02am

Kyle, upon seeing two teams do things sportsmanlike at the end of a game...

ryebrye

Sep 7, 4:45am

Let's hope Kalani doesn't do something like this against Utah.

JAGA97

Sep 7, 12:30pm

Which is dumb, its not sportsmanship to let the clock roll - time has to run

ABCoug

Sep 7, 8:42am

AGREED. You can’t assume the other team will play “fair.” You have to make them.

7FootRussian

Sep 7, 9:20am

What is "fair" about not using a timeout you have

kosmokramer

Sep 7, 1:39pm

I am agreeing with you. If a coach makes a mistake, you capitalize on it.

7FootRussian

Sep 7, 1:46pm

Not calling a timeout is only good sportsmanship when the game is out of hand.

HonestTakes

Sep 7, 9:45am

There was only a 1 second difference between the game and play clock.

tkh9

Sep 7, 9:57am

He could have called time at 20 seconds when JR took a knee. There was a bit of

Blue Ridge

Sep 7, 10:34am

As previously stated, we could have run the clock down further, but SMU

tkh9

Sep 7, 10:39am

How did they "signal"? A wink, wink?

ABCoug

Sep 7, 10:45am

By not calling it after first or second down.

tkh9

Sep 7, 10:52am

Idk - some people are wired as savers

ABCoug

Sep 7, 11:06am

But what if the coach noticed it and called TO? You HAVE to let the clock run

RGGeemer

Sep 7, 3:11pm

Kalani is friends with Rhett Lashlee

tkh9

Sep 7, 3:21pm

“to guess” are the key words here

ABCoug

Sep 7, 8:15pm

And he was right. Move on.

tkh9

Sep 7, 11:21pm

They needed 2 timeouts. 1 was not enough to force a punt so they conceded.

momowagon

Sep 7, 10:05am

wondered same thing. I thought maybe espn was wrong & SMU didn’t really have TO

zerome4sooners

Sep 7, 4:34am

SMU had not used the timeout the play before, signaling they weren't going to

momowagon

Sep 7, 4:36am

<< Deleted >>

Coug-Ida

Sep 7, 7:54am

Time has to run anyways, why leave it to chance?

ABCoug

Sep 7, 8:45am

I don't get the "Just stop." It was definitely a fair question. I thought it

spidercoug

Sep 7, 8:49am

Amen. I very valid question as clearly many were confused

ColonelMustard

Sep 7, 9:26am

Just stop? Oh, ok. so nobody can ask a question? The announcers couldn’t unders

Coug-Ida

Sep 7, 11:14am

I had the exact same thought...

NotoriousBUD

Sep 7, 4:53am

Same here. He’s going to get excoriated for not using that time out. Us

cougsareforreal

Sep 7, 5:02am

No he won't. If he was trying to extend the game he would have used it the play

momowagon

Sep 7, 5:08am

*camera pans to one coach who would do it*

Hambone

Sep 7, 5:26am

Exactly who I had in mind...

momowagon

Sep 7, 5:36am

RE: *camera pans to one coach who would do it*

ryebrye

Sep 7, 7:42am

SMU coach should be excoriated, inexcusable not to take your timeout

ABCoug

Sep 7, 8:46am

When did Lavell step on someone's throat?

Les IsMore

Sep 7, 12:02pm

lol, Umm… SMU, they took out their starters and the rest is history

ABCoug

Sep 7, 12:49pm

It could have been a Michigan State over Michigan situation, or they could have

Blue Ridge

Sep 7, 5:18am

IIRC, there were 125 seconds left. With a 40 second play clock and SMU holding

Corn Pop

Sep 7, 5:47am

Sadly, I wonder if our coaches even recognized that.

kansascougar

Sep 7, 7:01am

1:25 so 85 seconds left

goidcougs

Sep 7, 7:26am

Math is hard.

momowagon

Sep 7, 9:17am

Yes, that's what I meant. Just over two 40 second play clocks.

Corn Pop

Sep 7, 10:28am

I think not running up the score is disrespectful to your opponent.

EDthoracotomy

Sep 7, 8:25am

you're missing good sportmansip

Zoobieman

Sep 7, 8:28am

How is it good sportsmanship to snap 20 seconds early though? It's 20 seconds.

RGGeemer

Sep 7, 3:14pm

I think BYU's offense messed up. . .

Zoobieman

Sep 7, 11:29pm

100% correct & another coaching fail here for BYU.

DoctorEvil

Sep 7, 8:57am

I don't recall ever seeing a coach "eat" a TO at the end of the game with that

EM_Puma

Sep 7, 9:53am

The whole situation is really quite baffling

kosmokramer

Sep 7, 10:38am

Yeah the defense can be "sportsman" by not attacking but they get the benefit of

ABCoug

Sep 7, 10:49am

Why all the thumbs down on this post? Did I say something incorrect? False?

COACHdrn

Sep 7, 10:54am

it's not what you said. . . it's what you didnt say

Zoobieman

Sep 7, 11:23am

??? Which was?

COACHdrn

Sep 7, 11:30am

This thread explains it well enough

Zoobieman

Sep 7, 11:40am

Yeah I don’t get it either. Perfectly reasonable question/post.

zerome4sooners

Sep 8, 6:27am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad