Can you hear yourself? The defense was terrible and the offense managed

Jul 25, 2024
3:52:09pm

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

terribly. If that were true we would have lost to each and every one of those teams. Yet you are on here complaining about how far we won by. Like we should have out talented all of those teams that killed us in recruiting.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Nov 13, 2024
Total posts: 50,907 (1,535 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Is this a make or break season for Roderick?

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:36am

Right or wrong, I think there is more pressure on Roderick than Sitake.

TO11

Jul 25, 10:37am

I’m curious how this perception came about that BYU’s offense was anything but very good under ARod until last year.

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 10:40am

One of my biggest 2023 issues was how he missed so badly on Slovis.

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:46am

Retzlaff was the better choice? Based on what empirical evidence?

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 10:47am

Based on his style of play. Roderick's offense is not statue friendly.

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:48am

Seems misplaced to think Slovis was the heart of the problem. ARod falls in love

goodcleanfun

Jul 25, 11:11am

Honestly I agree, Roderick has been good, he could’ve looked even better if

TO11

Jul 25, 10:50am

The QB fiasco is Roderick's problem, he is OC AND QB Coach, that position group

CameronG

Jul 25, 11:09am

That’s why I said it’s contributed…also he has hit on several QB’s as well.

TO11

Jul 25, 11:59am

Which QBs has he hit on?

CameronG

Jul 25, 12:03pm

Zach Wilson and Jaren Hall

TO11

Jul 25, 3:50pm

He didn't recruit either of them, he did well with them but he hasn't brought in

CameronG

Jul 25, 3:52pm

All I care about is the QB product on the field- we have had good QB play under

TO11

Jul 25, 3:58pm

I think it's like how the 2016 season was good, but 2017 ended up being so bad

TheNerd

Jul 25, 10:55am

Detmer was the guy in 2016-2017

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 11:01am

I know, but I'm saying that 2016 is generally seen as a success despite the

TheNerd

Jul 25, 11:05am

Can his offense be at least average with replacement-level QB play?

Bandit

Jul 25, 10:56am

It was still good in 2022 but showed some signs of regression

CameronG

Jul 25, 11:04am

I think it's a make-or-break season for Kalani. He might survive a 5-win season. But I don't think survives a 4-win one.

Spiff

Jul 25, 10:44am

The more I have read the more I think he is gone if he doesn't get to 6 wins.

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 11:09am

RE: The more I have read the more I think he is gone if he doesn't get to 6 wins.

Spiff

Jul 25, 11:12am

Not if the O-line performs well.

CMAC38

Jul 25, 12:13pm

Strange answer. So if the O-line performs well it won't matter if we win 2

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 12:18pm

He should be out regardless

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:07pm

That has to be the most wildly inaccurate summaries I've seen in awhile. Particularly about the 2021 season.

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 3:18pm

You are in denial about that season

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:23pm

There is no empirical measure you could use about 2021 to substantiate your position. You literally don't have

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 3:56pm

Most of those P5 schools we beat weren’t exactly the best defensively

runningryan

Jul 25, 6:00pm

The FPI and FEI rankings are opponent-adjusted, so that’s already been accounted for

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 6:21pm

Yes, hard to believe that person was actually watching BYU football.

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 3:25pm

I was at 5 of those games

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:46pm

Can you hear yourself? The defense was terrible and the offense managed

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 3:52pm

If any of you voted for the last two options you are content with mediocrity.

Posting on CougarBoard