Yes, hard to believe that person was actually watching BYU football.

Report problem with this ad

Jul 25, 2024
3:25:56pm

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

Yes, hard to believe that person was actually watching BYU football.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Nov 13, 2024
Total posts: 50,907 (1,535 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Is this a make or break season for Roderick?

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:36am

Right or wrong, I think there is more pressure on Roderick than Sitake.

TO11

Jul 25, 10:37am

I’m curious how this perception came about that BYU’s offense was anything but very good under ARod until last year.

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 10:40am

One of my biggest 2023 issues was how he missed so badly on Slovis.

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:46am

Retzlaff was the better choice? Based on what empirical evidence?

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 10:47am

Based on his style of play. Roderick's offense is not statue friendly.

BlueFever

Jul 25, 10:48am

Seems misplaced to think Slovis was the heart of the problem. ARod falls in love

goodcleanfun

Jul 25, 11:11am

Honestly I agree, Roderick has been good, he could’ve looked even better if

TO11

Jul 25, 10:50am

The QB fiasco is Roderick's problem, he is OC AND QB Coach, that position group

CameronG

Jul 25, 11:09am

That’s why I said it’s contributed…also he has hit on several QB’s as well.

TO11

Jul 25, 11:59am

Which QBs has he hit on?

CameronG

Jul 25, 12:03pm

Zach Wilson and Jaren Hall

TO11

Jul 25, 3:50pm

He didn't recruit either of them, he did well with them but he hasn't brought in

CameronG

Jul 25, 3:52pm

All I care about is the QB product on the field- we have had good QB play under

TO11

Jul 25, 3:58pm

I think it's like how the 2016 season was good, but 2017 ended up being so bad

TheNerd

Jul 25, 10:55am

Detmer was the guy in 2016-2017

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 11:01am

I know, but I'm saying that 2016 is generally seen as a success despite the

TheNerd

Jul 25, 11:05am

Can his offense be at least average with replacement-level QB play?

Bandit

Jul 25, 10:56am

It was still good in 2022 but showed some signs of regression

CameronG

Jul 25, 11:04am

I think it's a make-or-break season for Kalani. He might survive a 5-win season. But I don't think survives a 4-win one.

Spiff

Jul 25, 10:44am

The more I have read the more I think he is gone if he doesn't get to 6 wins.

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 11:09am

RE: The more I have read the more I think he is gone if he doesn't get to 6 wins.

Spiff

Jul 25, 11:12am

Not if the O-line performs well.

CMAC38

Jul 25, 12:13pm

Strange answer. So if the O-line performs well it won't matter if we win 2

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 12:18pm

He should be out regardless

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:07pm

That has to be the most wildly inaccurate summaries I've seen in awhile. Particularly about the 2021 season.

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 3:18pm

You are in denial about that season

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:23pm

There is no empirical measure you could use about 2021 to substantiate your position. You literally don't have

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 3:56pm

Most of those P5 schools we beat weren’t exactly the best defensively

runningryan

Jul 25, 6:00pm

The FPI and FEI rankings are opponent-adjusted, so that’s already been accounted for

Indy Coug

Jul 25, 6:21pm

Yes, hard to believe that person was actually watching BYU football.

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 3:25pm

I was at 5 of those games

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:46pm

Can you hear yourself? The defense was terrible and the offense managed

kimdaddy35

Jul 25, 3:52pm

If any of you voted for the last two options you are content with mediocrity.

runningryan

Jul 25, 3:25pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad