So because Retzlaff didn't win those games, you wouldn't want him to start, even

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 18, 2024
3:08:27pm

BYUtka Intervention Needed

So because Retzlaff didn't win those games, you wouldn't want him to start, even

if he gives us the best chance to win?

You would rather lose with a different QB than win with Retzlaff?

Report problem with this ad

BYUtka

Previous username: yutka
Bio page: BYUtka
Joined: Aug 18, 2007
Last login: Sep 14, 2024
Total posts: 64,334 (2,140 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Who SHOULD start the first game this season at QB for BYU

elderyoda

Jul 18, 1:19pm

Whichever QB gives us the best chance to win.

BYUtka

Jul 18, 1:22pm

No clue. Nobody will know the answer to that except the team.

shoganai

Jul 18, 1:29pm

Well, time to shut down the football category. Opinions are prohibited.

elderyoda

Jul 18, 1:47pm

I don't know how you even form an opinion on it if you're not in practice

shoganai

Jul 18, 1:53pm

At what point are we allowed to form an opinion? And why can't we base our opinion on what QB's have done in the past?

byuTX

Jul 18, 3:01pm

So because Retzlaff didn't win those games, you wouldn't want him to start, even

BYUtka

Jul 18, 3:08pm

I'd like to win. But JR was historically bad and I think we have enough data to presume GB can do better because he was

byuTX

Jul 18, 3:18pm

Despite the prohibition on having an opinion. I don't think JR will ever have the requisite accuracy to be a good QB.

shimmy

Jul 19, 12:32pm

You can form an opinion whenever you want. I don't know how you would feel like

shoganai

Jul 18, 8:01pm

So 4 games, in your opinion isn’t enough of a sample size. How many is enough for you to form an opinion?

byuTX

Jul 19, 7:45am

If you feel like you have enough info to have a firm opinion on who the starter

shoganai

Jul 19, 10:43am

How much info do you think is reasonably enough to form an opinion?

byuTX

Jul 19, 11:19am

Some Fall practices. Certainly something more recent than last season.

BYUtka

Jul 19, 11:56am

But since none of us see those (public practices don't really count), we can't form an opinion until how many '24 games?

byuTX

Jul 19, 12:14pm

13.

BYUtka

Jul 19, 12:24pm

Does that 13 include last year? So after game 9 this year is ok? Or just this season? Cause if it's JR we won't play 13

byuTX

Jul 19, 1:41pm

Nope..this season. And did Retzlaff do something personal to you? He wasn't

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:00pm

No. I just want BYU to win and he was statistically the worst BYU QB in 50+ years and was a bottom tier P5 QB last year.

byuTX

Jul 19, 2:04pm

I just think it is a TBD situation. He might be a bust, he might not. I think

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:10pm

I don't think there's a set number. Can be very circumstantial.

shoganai

Jul 19, 1:32pm

So in some circumstances it might be never ok to question a coach's decision? And you've never complained about a QB?

byuTX

Jul 19, 1:40pm

Poor coaching decisions were a large part of why Jake struggled...

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:12pm

Why would he improve (but GB, who was already better not improve) under the same coaches?

byuTX

Jul 19, 2:23pm

You can question a coach's decision whenever you want. I don't think anybody

shoganai

Jul 19, 2:32pm

You care. But you did finally answer so thanks.

byuTX

Jul 19, 3:27pm

Nothing wrong with "opinions"...but what are you really asking here? Everyone

BYUtka

Jul 18, 2:00pm

Zach Wilson, but that's unlikely. so I'll take whoever John Beck endorses on our current squad.

byujag

Jul 18, 2:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad