No clue. Nobody will know the answer to that except the team.

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jul 18, 2024
1:29:02pm

shoganai All-American

No clue. Nobody will know the answer to that except the team.

Report problem with this ad

shoganai

Bio page: shoganai
Joined: Jul 15, 2004
Last login: Aug 31, 2024
Total posts: 32,748 (790 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Who SHOULD start the first game this season at QB for BYU

elderyoda

Jul 18, 1:19pm

Whichever QB gives us the best chance to win.

BYUtka

Jul 18, 1:22pm

No clue. Nobody will know the answer to that except the team.

shoganai

Jul 18, 1:29pm

Well, time to shut down the football category. Opinions are prohibited.

elderyoda

Jul 18, 1:47pm

I don't know how you even form an opinion on it if you're not in practice

shoganai

Jul 18, 1:53pm

At what point are we allowed to form an opinion? And why can't we base our opinion on what QB's have done in the past?

byuTX

Jul 18, 3:01pm

So because Retzlaff didn't win those games, you wouldn't want him to start, even

BYUtka

Jul 18, 3:08pm

I'd like to win. But JR was historically bad and I think we have enough data to presume GB can do better because he was

byuTX

Jul 18, 3:18pm

Despite the prohibition on having an opinion. I don't think JR will ever have the requisite accuracy to be a good QB.

shimmy

Jul 19, 12:32pm

You can form an opinion whenever you want. I don't know how you would feel like

shoganai

Jul 18, 8:01pm

So 4 games, in your opinion isn’t enough of a sample size. How many is enough for you to form an opinion?

byuTX

Jul 19, 7:45am

If you feel like you have enough info to have a firm opinion on who the starter

shoganai

Jul 19, 10:43am

How much info do you think is reasonably enough to form an opinion?

byuTX

Jul 19, 11:19am

Some Fall practices. Certainly something more recent than last season.

BYUtka

Jul 19, 11:56am

But since none of us see those (public practices don't really count), we can't form an opinion until how many '24 games?

byuTX

Jul 19, 12:14pm

13.

BYUtka

Jul 19, 12:24pm

Does that 13 include last year? So after game 9 this year is ok? Or just this season? Cause if it's JR we won't play 13

byuTX

Jul 19, 1:41pm

Nope..this season. And did Retzlaff do something personal to you? He wasn't

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:00pm

No. I just want BYU to win and he was statistically the worst BYU QB in 50+ years and was a bottom tier P5 QB last year.

byuTX

Jul 19, 2:04pm

I just think it is a TBD situation. He might be a bust, he might not. I think

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:10pm

I don't think there's a set number. Can be very circumstantial.

shoganai

Jul 19, 1:32pm

So in some circumstances it might be never ok to question a coach's decision? And you've never complained about a QB?

byuTX

Jul 19, 1:40pm

Poor coaching decisions were a large part of why Jake struggled...

BYUtka

Jul 19, 2:12pm

Why would he improve (but GB, who was already better not improve) under the same coaches?

byuTX

Jul 19, 2:23pm

You can question a coach's decision whenever you want. I don't think anybody

shoganai

Jul 19, 2:32pm

You care. But you did finally answer so thanks.

byuTX

Jul 19, 3:27pm

Nothing wrong with "opinions"...but what are you really asking here? Everyone

BYUtka

Jul 18, 2:00pm

Zach Wilson, but that's unlikely. so I'll take whoever John Beck endorses on our current squad.

byujag

Jul 18, 2:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad