Catchings certainly more talented than Waterman but

Jun 18, 2024
12:05:15pm

CycloneCoug Redshirt Freshman

Will he produce more than Waterman would’ve had he stayed?

Catchings is a bigger deal for the school/program for sure. I wouldn’t switch him for Waterman. I’m just curious to hear thoughts on production

Does experience trump talent?

Report problem with this ad

CycloneCoug

Bio page: CycloneCoug
Joined: Sep 18, 2023
Last login: Jun 26, 2024
Total posts: 227 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Catchings certainly more talented than Waterman but

CycloneCoug

Jun 18, 12:05pm

We will see if he has the same drive to rebound. He feels like a better shooter.

Boring

Jun 18, 12:06pm

Same drive to rebound? Shirley you jest.

Les IsMore

Jun 18, 5:02pm

Certainly more expensive

Cougrrrs Roll

Jun 18, 12:07pm

do you know how much NIL Catchings got? on this board it was posted that NW got

cwilke1

Jun 18, 5:42pm

I think that is a good perspective to have. For as exciting as it is to have these young players

jvr7

Jun 18, 12:10pm

If we had kept Waterman, I'd say this team is really good

RenoCoug

Jun 18, 12:11pm

Waterman did some good things but not a huge loss

TNT

Jun 18, 12:35pm

It’s been proven by Kentucky and others that adding talent alone

I'mBatman

Jun 18, 12:19pm

He will, yes. More importantly, Mag will be a better defender, too. And Noah was very valuable for us on D.

SinkingQuffa

Jun 18, 12:23pm

Bart Torvik has us currently projected #41 for next year w/ updated roster.

jreid191

Jun 18, 12:25pm

When I was in mutual, the young men would play the Elders Quorum in basketball.

BYUCPA

Jun 18, 12:34pm

... and size and strength

NYC and Japan

Jun 18, 1:31pm

No guarantee of the established guys having an advantage there either

cajuncoug

Jun 18, 4:45pm

we routinely crushed our men's team. They stopped playing us

icecougar

Jun 18, 5:58pm

I sure wish we still had Noah. He would make this a better team. You

Submariner

Jun 18, 12:50pm

RE: Catchings certainly more talented than Waterman but

Ward5

Jun 18, 1:25pm

Waterman was good but he was a huge liability on the road in the big 12.

Muscle IQ

Jun 18, 1:27pm

Waterman will never be drafted, but Catchings will be, that is a big difference!

GoodGuyGary1

Jun 18, 1:58pm

I 💙’d 🍉

MightyFreakingCougar

Jun 18, 2:03pm

Waterman would be my fifth option at the 4 if on the current roster

Phreddy

Jun 18, 2:11pm

I might be a bit kinder than that — but I tend to agree. Noah was best as a mismatch 3.

SinkingQuffa

Jun 18, 2:19pm

a mismatch 3....is that like a 3.25? 3.5 maybe?

icecougar

Jun 18, 5:55pm

Something like that. Noah was the right kinda tweener — forced to play in the wrong position mostly last season.

SinkingQuffa

Jun 18, 6:01pm

Tim Fanning says there won’t be a lot of differentiation between positions 1-4…

icecougar

Jun 19, 8:43pm

That's gonna be pretty sweet to behold at BYU.

SinkingQuffa

Jun 19, 11:09pm

Ummm. Wut

gurt

Jun 18, 2:49pm

Waterman was a terrific player for us who improved greatly

cajuncoug

Jun 18, 3:58pm

Waterman wasnt that good, i dont know why people act like he was a huge loss.

Grock

Jun 18, 4:00pm

It was the story they ran on him. Very likeable. Tough upbringing. Soft player

Phreddy

Jun 18, 4:04pm

Waterman disappeared in big games

4mack

Jun 18, 4:54pm

Not in the Vegas tourney. Or always thereafter

cajuncoug

Jun 18, 5:00pm

Exactly. Defense was good but offensively, he was a no-show in many big games

bad84cougar

Jun 18, 6:45pm

my one issue with Waterman is his confidence in big games...

Posting on CougarBoard