My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 29, 2023
11:02
:24
am
niqmadu
All-American
I think the common disappointment is when the QB pipeline hits a dry spell.
This happens even at the best schools (thankfully). It happened to Lavell quite a bit in his last decade. Lots of discontinuity in there.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
niqmadu
Bio page
niqmadu
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Last login
Sep 7, 2024
Total posts
2,638 (4 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Some observations based on performance and coaches comments
bald man
11/29/23 6:22am
A former WR is coaching the QBs, that is what's going on there
astroman
11/29/23 6:27am
Yeah he sucked at it with the last two guys.
A Drew Aitch
11/29/23 6:29am
Is that more to do with John Beck or ARod?
astroman
11/29/23 6:37am
All college QBs have an outside trainer.
A Drew Aitch
11/29/23 6:38am
Plus, the original post hinted as lack of development at backup QB, not starters
astroman
11/29/23 6:41am
thank you. To me, this is the biggest question mark. Why aren't the backups
bald man
11/29/23 7:33am
But Wilson and Hall both backups at one time and certainly progressed
viper
11/29/23 12:16pm
Was Romney a Back up under ARod, Jaren Hall? You mean back ups this year.
A Drew Aitch
11/29/23 12:55pm
It's funny how some want to assign blame without ever giving credit.
Unibro
11/29/23 8:01am
it's funny how some think you can't question the performance based on results
bald man
11/29/23 8:11am
Both those NFL QBs were backups… an NFL RB was a walk on…
Pretorian
11/29/23 10:27am
so basically arod can only develop nfl caliber guys.
bald man
11/29/23 11:08am
I believe only NFL caliber guys make it to… the NFL, regardless who’s coaching
Pretorian
11/29/23 11:57am
Not uncommon for former players to coach a position they didn’t play.
Metallicat
11/29/23 6:31am
I remember Jim McMahon once saying about Andy Reid
Belboz
11/29/23 8:03am
I remember hearing that too. So funny.
Metallicat
11/29/23 8:55am
Norm Chow coached QBs. Played guard in college.
BYU Statsman
11/29/23 6:32am
He coached WRs for years at BYU.
Les IsMore
11/29/23 12:14pm
Yes he did. And QBs.
BYU Statsman
11/29/23 12:25pm
For years I heard people complain about Norm Chow's play calling.
Benfica1
11/29/23 3:45pm
Nick Saban is calling and Mike Leach is rising from the dead
BYU Grounds
11/30/23 10:47am
Personally, unless recruiting does really, really well this offseason
PortlandCoug
11/29/23 6:36am
Granted KS hs to navigate some difficult things like
bald man
11/29/23 7:36am
It would take a 3 win season or less for Kalani to be gone after 2024
donnerstag
11/29/23 8:51am
Defensive talent though is a big issue, DL has to get much better
PortlandCoug
11/29/23 1:12pm
Good points, but this is BYU. I predict 2 more years.
CougarMandias
11/29/23 9:52am
I think he's a really good recruiter
deliciousmocha
11/29/23 2:50pm
100% agreed. If we have a repeat performance in 2024 I think Sitake is gone
TaysomJimmerEraCoug
11/29/23 2:54pm
It would take back-to-back seasons of 4 wins or less for KS to be gone.
Hammer15
11/30/23 12:19am
What do you mean Personally? Are you gonna fire him? You don’t have to worry
canofpicante
11/30/23 1:05am
Going to be a long off-season on CB
WJCougar
11/29/23 6:46am
it was a long season. 🙁
bald man
11/29/23 7:38am
We’ve had some good backup qbs last four years
niqmadu
11/29/23 7:48am
so good in fact that we'd rather play an injured starter and lose than put the
bald man
11/29/23 8:12am
I didn’t say this year. You paint with a wide brush and are forgetting that
niqmadu
11/29/23 8:18am
That is true, I wasn't thinking of them.
bald man
11/29/23 8:43am
I think the common disappointment is when the QB pipeline hits a dry spell.
niqmadu
11/29/23 11:02am
haven't we recruited 4 start guys? but they didn't pan out?
bald man
11/29/23 11:09am
I’d have to dig in to see but it’s not uncommon
niqmadu
11/29/23 11:45am
Not all 4* players pan out
Pretorian
11/29/23 11:59am
If true, Kalani's approach to the portal will be the final nail in the coffin.
Karl Poppin
11/29/23 8:17am
I took his quote to mean
RiseUp
11/29/23 10:30am
If true, that's fine, I suppose.
Karl Poppin
11/29/23 10:47am
Same here
runningfoo
11/29/23 10:47am
Same. And I agree. Recruit players but they can't be a drain or a distraction.
YOHONOMOTO
11/29/23 12:39pm
Same. And I agree. Recruit players but they can't be a drain or a distraction.
YOHONOMOTO
11/29/23 12:40pm
That is 100% the fault of program culture and Kalani is responsible for righting the ship
runningryan
11/29/23 8:48am
additional observations - grass is green and the sky is blue
AFitisemanu
11/29/23 11:56am
sometimes
jetycns
11/29/23 1:23pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad