If you want to go by strict definition, it is not.

Dec 20, 2024
4:47:14pm

TheLoneCougar Adrielle?!

You point out the dumbest things to nit pick at kimdaddy. Holy sheesh, this whole subthread doesn't need to exist except you have some weird response to my word choice.

What gives?

Report problem with this ad

TheLoneCougar

Bio page: TheLoneCougar
Joined: Dec 10, 2015
Last login: Dec 20, 2024
Total posts: 23,532 (5,348 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Geilman commits to BYU.

cougfanblue Assistant to the manager

Dec 19, 11:51pm

Who?

LifeLongLakerFan

Dec 19, 11:58pm

5A player of the year. Bountiful QB

cougfanblue

12:02am

Any more info about him? Not able to find a recruiting profile.

GatorCoug

Dec 19, 11:59pm

This…

CougarGuy84

12:04am

Love his film. Looks all of 6’3” with a strong and accurate arm and can run. How

YbeatsU

12:18am

Crazy that Weber State, USU, etc don’t even want him.

RootieBoy

12:38am

<< Deleted >>

The Old Y

7:29am

Recruited as a QB or athlete?

Archaea

5:20am

QB.

The Old Y

1:09pm

Great highlight video. Baller!

jpal1397

12:11am

Anyone know if he’s a mission first guy?

Soupie

12:26am

His bio says he was on the seminary council. So probably a mission first guy.

Zenoch

12:30am

I thought CES did away with seminary councils

BYU'01

8:55am

Emerson's older brother who was the starting Bountiful QB before Emerson is on

cwilke1

5:30am

<< Deleted >>

The Old Y

7:30am

Yes. 100%

MaxxPower

10:34am

My youngest brother is in his class at Bountiful. Says he’s definitely mission first.

WP17

11:42am

His Dad is in the stake presidency and works for the church.

GSwarriorcoug

7:35pm

If it’s like many QB recruits lately, it’ll be fun to speculate about his future

Your Royal Blueness

12:58am

That probably means no Lyons

thewaterboy

5:06am

I don't agree with that. Different classes. Geilman's recruitment is late

cwilke1

5:33am

thewaterboy

5:58am

After Lugo transfer, it leaves room for 2.They also have Su”esu’e coming in 26

Mabuhay Coug

7:32am

I’m pretty sure he’s home and will be playing Linebacker or another position

Julius Pepperwood

9:32am

I wondered which one he would see on. Don’t be surprised to see a Wildcat set

Mabuhay Coug

11:24am

This guy thinks it’s a great pick up:

Mjolnir

5:21am

I was skeptical, not having heard of him nor having seen him on 247 then seeing

Your Royal Blueness

8:25am

agreed

PabloSanchezz

8:43am

I agree, I love his film. Very mobile for how tall he is. I'm excited about him.

Atmospheric_Cougar

2:05pm

That film

I'mBatman

6:34pm

Really good QB. Looks like a steal.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:08am

Look at his development from 23 to 24 in terms of TD to Int ratio.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:13am

Funny how CB bemoans the fact that we aren't getting good LDS/Utah talent, then we take a kid who has all the accolades

TheLoneCougar

7:20am

I’ll take a coach’s assessment over the journalists who run 24/7 any day. We fixate on the star ratings, coaches watch

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:26am

Recruiting press ratings rely heavily on coaches' assessments in the form of

russkiejedi

7:33am

By paying attention it’s often a matter of who has a PR machine.

Soupie

7:36am

When someone looks at a guy who has no offers from P4 programs, that's a

russkiejedi

7:43am

Yep, there is a game. The 7v7 club coaches play the game with the players.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:48am

Those numbers are largely a function of volume. There are far fewer recruits at

russkiejedi

8:11am

Of course but the point is there are plenty of kids at each level who are high quality

GoodBetterBestBYU

1:58pm

Here's hoping he's our Josh Allen.

russkiejedi

7:31am

"All of the accolades" would generally include a bunch of offers and a high star ranking.

kimdaddy35

9:56am

Accolades refer to his accomplishments at the high school level. He doesn't have full control over who sends him offers

TheLoneCougar

1:29pm

So getting a star rating and scholarship offers are not accolades?

kimdaddy35

1:44pm

Josh Allen didn’t have any offers out of HS either. Maybe some got it wrong 😑

jpal1397

2:30pm

I'm pretty sure you are proving my point. Josh Allen was a huge project at both the

kimdaddy35

2:42pm

I corrected my post. 😑

jpal1397

2:58pm

If you want to go by strict definition, it is not.

TheLoneCougar

4:47pm

Seems like an awesome pickup! As he doesn't have a recruiting profile & doesn't

BamaCoug

7:28am

A lot of kids bloom late and don’t play the recruiting game well. My nephew was defensive player of the year in AZ and

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:33am

My sons high school team I’ve watched them a lot

DavisCoCoug

7:30am

His film looks better than Keeney's

donnerstag

7:40am

Ganz geil

NGB

7:41am

Ganz toll

Burton162

9:11am

Ganz wunderbar!

BYU Grounds

11:54am

Athletic...4.6 40 and a 38" vert.

vabeachcoug

7:56am

Yes. And tall, and has a little touch on his long balls.

rockhound

10:31am

In finance, trust fund, 6'5", blue eyes

Burton162

1:58pm

Great pickup. Full on baller. Had lots of convos going on with big programs.

The Old Y

8:11am

I'm a full skeptic when BYU signs some "diamond in the rough" but that kid has a canon

BIG XII Coug

8:40am

BYU football camp MVP last year. Kid can ball

PabloSanchezz

8:45am

I watched him in the quarter final against Maple Mountain, he led the team to a comeback win. Looks good. He had that

dingus79

9:00am

One scout at the LP/Corner Canyon game last August said he was...

DazeofBlue

1:55pm

I like what I see. Get him in the program and see what he can do!

Posting on CougarBoard