"All of the accolades" would generally include a bunch of offers and a high star ranking.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 20, 2024
9:56:50am

kimdaddy35 Former Fly Half

"All of the accolades" would generally include a bunch of offers and a high star ranking.

I am not saying we shouldn't have signed him, but that comment seemed a little silly to me.

Also the one about coaches. Why is our coach the only one who saw this great ability?

I hope he pans out and plays great. But he is a flyer. Hopefully it hits.

Report problem with this ad

kimdaddy35

Bio page: kimdaddy35
Joined: Aug 23, 2010
Last login: Dec 20, 2024
Total posts: 52,502 (1,561 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Geilman commits to BYU.

cougfanblue Assistant to the manager

Dec 19, 11:51pm

Who?

LifeLongLakerFan

Dec 19, 11:58pm

5A player of the year. Bountiful QB

cougfanblue

12:02am

Any more info about him? Not able to find a recruiting profile.

GatorCoug

Dec 19, 11:59pm

This…

CougarGuy84

12:04am

Love his film. Looks all of 6’3” with a strong and accurate arm and can run. How

YbeatsU

12:18am

Crazy that Weber State, USU, etc don’t even want him.

RootieBoy

12:38am

<< Deleted >>

The Old Y

7:29am

Recruited as a QB or athlete?

Archaea

5:20am

QB.

The Old Y

1:09pm

Great highlight video. Baller!

jpal1397

12:11am

Anyone know if he’s a mission first guy?

Soupie

12:26am

His bio says he was on the seminary council. So probably a mission first guy.

Zenoch

12:30am

I thought CES did away with seminary councils

BYU'01

8:55am

Emerson's older brother who was the starting Bountiful QB before Emerson is on

cwilke1

5:30am

<< Deleted >>

The Old Y

7:30am

Yes. 100%

MaxxPower

10:34am

My youngest brother is in his class at Bountiful. Says he’s definitely mission first.

WP17

11:42am

If it’s like many QB recruits lately, it’ll be fun to speculate about his future

Your Royal Blueness

12:58am

That probably means no Lyons

thewaterboy

5:06am

I don't agree with that. Different classes. Geilman's recruitment is late

cwilke1

5:33am

OK

thewaterboy

5:58am

After Lugo transfer, it leaves room for 2.They also have Su”esu’e coming in 26

Mabuhay Coug

7:32am

I’m pretty sure he’s home and will be playing Linebacker or another position

Julius Pepperwood

9:32am

I wondered which one he would see on. Don’t be surprised to see a Wildcat set

Mabuhay Coug

11:24am

This guy thinks it’s a great pick up:

Mjolnir

5:21am

I was skeptical, not having heard of him nor having seen him on 247 then seeing

Your Royal Blueness

8:25am

agreed

PabloSanchezz

8:43am

I agree, I love his film. Very mobile for how tall he is. I'm excited about him.

Atmospheric_Cougar

2:05pm

Really good QB. Looks like a steal.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:08am

Look at his development from 23 to 24 in terms of TD to Int ratio.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:13am

Funny how CB bemoans the fact that we aren't getting good LDS/Utah talent, then we take a kid who has all the accolades

7:20am

I’ll take a coach’s assessment over the journalists who run 24/7 any day. We fixate on the star ratings, coaches watch

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:26am

Recruiting press ratings rely heavily on coaches' assessments in the form of

russkiejedi

7:33am

By paying attention it’s often a matter of who has a PR machine.

Soupie

7:36am

When someone looks at a guy who has no offers from P4 programs, that's a

russkiejedi

7:43am

Yep, there is a game. The 7v7 club coaches play the game with the players.

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:48am

Those numbers are largely a function of volume. There are far fewer recruits at

russkiejedi

8:11am

Of course but the point is there are plenty of kids at each level who are high quality

GoodBetterBestBYU

1:58pm

Here's hoping he's our Josh Allen.

russkiejedi

7:31am

"All of the accolades" would generally include a bunch of offers and a high star ranking.

kimdaddy35

9:56am

Accolades refer to his accomplishments at the high school level. He doesn't have full control over who sends him offers

1:29pm

So getting a star rating and scholarship offers are not accolades?

kimdaddy35

1:44pm

Josh Allen didn’t have any offers out of HS either. Maybe some got it wrong 😑

jpal1397

2:30pm

I'm pretty sure you are proving my point. Josh Allen was a huge project at both the

kimdaddy35

2:42pm

I corrected my post. 😑

jpal1397

2:58pm

If you want to go by strict definition, it is not.

4:47pm

Seems like an awesome pickup! As he doesn't have a recruiting profile & doesn't

BamaCoug

7:28am

A lot of kids bloom late and don’t play the recruiting game well. My nephew was defensive player of the year in AZ and

GoodBetterBestBYU

7:33am

My sons high school team I’ve watched them a lot

DavisCoCoug

7:30am

His film looks better than Keeney's

donnerstag

7:40am

Ganz geil

NGB

7:41am

Ganz toll

Burton162

9:11am

Ganz wunderbar!

BYU Grounds

11:54am

Athletic...4.6 40 and a 38" vert.

vabeachcoug

7:56am

Yes. And tall, and has a little touch on his long balls.

rockhound

10:31am

In finance, trust fund, 6'5", blue eyes

Burton162

1:58pm

Great pickup. Full on baller. Had lots of convos going on with big programs.

The Old Y

8:11am

I'm a full skeptic when BYU signs some "diamond in the rough" but that kid has a canon

8:40am

BYU football camp MVP last year. Kid can ball

PabloSanchezz

8:45am

I watched him in the quarter final against Maple Mountain, he led the team to a comeback win. Looks good. He had that

dingus79

9:00am

One scout at the LP/Corner Canyon game last August said he was...

DazeofBlue

1:55pm

I like what I see. Get him in the program and see what he can do!

Accipiter

3:08pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad