They’d have to make athletes employees and collectively bargain that restriction

Report problem with this ad

Dec 16, 2024
7:47:36am

chilawcoug Playmaker

Which I’m not against, but it would take a big change

Report problem with this ad

chilawcoug

Bio page: chilawcoug
Joined: Mar 6, 2021
Last login: Dec 16, 2024
Total posts: 3,042 (7 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Move the portal window

Longseason

7:36am

Move it to when?

BigTex

7:38am

After the season

fattycoug

7:40am

It’s the only thing that makes sense. Can’t do it during the season

Borg

7:41am

It makes little sense from an academic standpoint

RGGeemer

7:42am

Yep, and they are still students

Littlerich

7:43am

They are essentially pros. Missing a semester or making a mil is a no brainer

Borg

7:48am

That’s both a non sequitir and a strawman.

chilawcoug

7:49am

No. It’s obviously the only thing that matters to these guys else they wouldn’t

Borg

7:50am

Twice in a row. Impressive again

chilawcoug

7:51am

Not everyone is leaving for money

fattycoug

8:06am

I would venture the majority are

Borg

8:19am

Quite wrong. The well known ones are leaving for $$. The vast majority will not

NYC and Japan

8:33am

Fair enough

Borg

9:09am

You're correct. But $$$ or not, they ARE transferring for football related...

COACHdrn

10:03am

The number who are "making a mil" is miniscule

NGB

7:50am

Then the athletes are screwed with the academic year

RealTaysomHill

7:42am

Yep. They have to drop out of the old school (have to enroll for the new

chilawcoug

7:45am

They can dry their tears with hundred dollar bills. It’s not about academics.

Borg

7:49am

If you had read my post, you’d know I never said it was about school

chilawcoug

7:50am

If the portal opens mid Jan (after NC game) …they can still make it

Borg

7:52am

Only at some schools, and only if they enter, get offers, make decision

chilawcoug

7:53am

Hmm…I guess there are risks hitting the portal. Guess the grass isn’t always

Borg

7:56am

I know you are already on your condescending high horse so whatever I say

chilawcoug

7:58am

I hope they do bust up the current system with an anti trust lawsuit. What’s

Borg

8:13am

Okay so you admit your proposed system won’t work. Got it.

chilawcoug

8:16am

Academics are still part of it though. Players can be suspended for poor grades. If you’re arguing that college sports

RealTaysomHill

7:51am

Do players enroll in Spring semester if they plan to leave in the portal?

Borg

7:53am

They have to enroll in the school they will be attending if they want to participate in spring ball

RealTaysomHill

7:57am

Can’t they transfer after the season is over and finish the semester and then

ballen

7:51am

If my season ended in Dec. And I’m hitting the portal. Why would I enroll in

Borg

7:55am

Wait now you want a variable window depending on the team?

chilawcoug

8:00am

there already is.

molodyets

1:38pm

Only when a coach leaves, correct?

chilawcoug

1:44pm

All teams in the CFP get a week after the NCG.

molodyets

1:57pm

Open the portal in April. Make academic requirements in order to transfer. You’d

Powerbait DPM

11:36am

Make it so that if they enter the portal before the end of the season, including

Submariner

8:00am

Many reasons for entering the portal… team performance, coach changes,

NYC and Japan

9:00am

That is why I said "is enforceable" and not that it must be enforced.

Submariner

9:21am

Closes the later of January 9 or 1 week after you play your last game.

unctoothman

8:55am

This is what Deliingham was talking about. He told his guys they can enter the transfer portal, but he still wants

P-Boy Squad

7:42am

Did he get him in the position they’re in, or did they get him in the position

Polecat

9:19am

he is saying he understood the position the kids were in so he let them enter

BYUBuckeyeGoCougs

11:12am

The bigger problem is timing of the playoff/bowls. School starts in January.

chilawcoug

7:42am

Don't most schools allow transfers at the beginning of the quarter (mid-semester

thewaterboy

7:45am

Some do, some don’t. And even for those who do, it’s not always in time for

chilawcoug

7:46am

In addition, one portal entry a year might be susceptible to antitrust claims

chilawcoug

7:46am

There's already a spring portal. They need to lengthen the time on that one and

thewaterboy

7:43am

Reinstate sitting out a year and move the portal dates

Indy Coug

7:46am

They’d have to make athletes employees and collectively bargain that restriction

chilawcoug

7:47am

the settlement with congress already paved the way to make athletes employees

Saxa

8:01am

Settlement with Congress? What do you mean?

chilawcoug

8:03am

I really wish this rule came back.

TADOW

7:49am

Athletes sued and the courts got rid of it. Not much the NCAA could do.

Ghost of Peanut

8:11am

Is someone making him transfer?

benny1982

8:27am

That is a "back up the brinks truck if you want me to play in the playoffs" move

JimmyZ

8:33am

The easier answer is you let them opt out of the next season for the transfer

sandtrapcougar

8:49am

Heavy heart? Pretty sure he meant open wallet.

KCFan85

8:50am

There is an easy solution. Move the playoffs earlier. Start mid-December finish

NYC and Japan

10:48am

So just skip finals?

RGGeemer

10:53am

This is the best solution. Start the season a week earlier. All players are

wildwilderness

12:04pm

or let kids still play in their bowl game or playoff games even if they enter

imdocrob

11:00am

They Can if the school lets them and still enrolled. So Yes some kids do if the

wildwilderness

12:01pm

<< Deleted >>

andrewg3

12:56pm

Adopt the women’s soccer model. Start early Aug, end early Dec

andrewg3

1:02pm

The College National Championship Game on New Years Day would be Perfect!!

wildwilderness

1:31pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad